Originally posted by: yukichigai
Lost, with Smallville recording on the VCR. Actually, reverse that. I'd rather watch Lost with the ability to fast-forward through commercials.
Lost in general > Smallville in general
However
Lost Season 1 Finale < Smallville Season 4 Finale
I thought the season finale had nothing particularly special about it. In fact, if anything, it was less cliffhanger-ey than a normal episode; it had a disturbing finality to it, like the show's producers made it so they could end it there and mindf%$# us all if they felt like it.