As someone who owned a Dreamcast at launch, remembers the NFL 2K score ticker on the bottom of the screen saying, "What is Shenmue? Find out on [date]!", and who spent countless hours wasting Ryo's money at capsule toy and soda vending machines, Shenmue holds a very special place in my heart.
I realize it's not for everyone. It had clunky controls, weird mechanics, a slow-developing melodramatic plot, minutiae out the wazoo, and of course, some of the most delightfully awful voice acting you might ever hear.
Outside of the sheer technical accomplishment the game was though in the early 2000s, it had a undeniable charm that made it wholly unique.
It IS essential the ultimate playable 80's Kung-Fu B-movie, replete with terribad dubs, every martial art cliche in the book, and charmingly one-dimensional characters. That's the best way I can describe it. It's like playing a poorly dubbed B-movie from the 80's that's trying oh so hard, but you're chuckling at the whole way through.
Seriously, you enjoy Shenmue because of the quirks. Not in spite of them. It's the same reason people enjoy terrible 80's action movies and martial arts epics. It's the same reason people still enjoy Chuck Norris movies from the 80's. They're gooney. Goofy. Silly. Over-the-top. And thoroughly charming in their way.
Some of the hardest I've ever laughed in my life at a game, was at some of the situations and dialogue in Shemue 1 and 2.
Yes, it told a fun story. And yes, the characters were engaging. And the fights and exploration were enjoyable. But you have to go into a game like Shenmue with the right mindset. I honestly feel sorry for the folks who didn't, or who expected Dostoevsky, or (understandably) were put off by the clunkiness of the controls at first.
But my memories of Shenmue (and to a lesser extent, Shenmue 2) were some of my best ever in gaming. It's the definition of a flawed gem. It's not for everyone, but if you went in with the right mindset and a lighthearted approach, it was one of those indelible experiences that will always hold a special place in your gaming memories.:thumbsup:
*EDIT-Darn double post*