Seventh grader suspended for... sucking helium out of a balloon?

glenn1

Lifer
Sep 6, 2000
25,383
1,013
126
Story link

EUCLID, Ohio -- A seventh-grade Euclid boy was given detentions and suspended from recess for inhaling helium from a balloon while in school. The principal said that the act set a bad example for other students and violated school policy.

Horkan (pictured, below) can't believe the penalty that was handed down at St. Robert Catholic School in Euclid after he grabbed a party balloon in class and inhaled the helium to alter his voice.


The school principal, Mary Pittinger, gave Horkan detentions and suspended him from recess for the three remaining days of the school year. "I asked the principal, 'Didn't you ever do this when you were a kid?'" said Kevin Horkan, Ben's father.


Ben's father said that he was stunned by the punishment leveled against his son and the report suggesting his son abused a foreign substance. "What is his intent? Is it his intent to abuse drugs? Absolutely not. He was just changing his voice. Heck, I've done that in the last two years," Kevin Horkan said.


But Pittinger stands by her punishment, pointing to the warning label on every helium tank that the gas can cause suffocation.
She said that inhaling helium from a party balloon sets a bad example to others students. "There have been instances where children have fainted," she said. "I can't let them see this is an OK thing to do. It's not." Apparently, a child in Washington recently died after inhaling large quantities of helium from a tank.


In protest, Kevin Horkan has pulled his son out of St. Robert for the remainder of the school year. Ben said that he's learned his lesson and is not likely to ever inhale helium again. "Just watch what you're doing," he said. "There (are) some crazy rules out there."


Pittinger doesn't think it's a "crazy rule." She said that students aren't even allowed to bring cough drops into class without permission and that she'll stick to that policy.

 

gopunk

Lifer
Jul 7, 2001
29,239
2
0
you can't inhale helium anymore? what are you going to do? walk around with a filter?
 

CrazyDe1

Diamond Member
Dec 18, 2001
3,089
0
0
man, my whole elementary school class would have gotten suspended if that was the case...
 

jlee

Lifer
Sep 12, 2001
48,518
223
106
Oh, please....
rolleye.gif


I never considered inhaling helium a punishable offense....is it documented as an illegal drug or something?
 

virusag11

Senior member
May 22, 2002
336
0
0
Pretty soon kids won't be able to sniff glue or markers either.

This is crap, the kid was just having fun. I would have been kicked out of school if they put that rule into play. BS
 

ElFenix

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Mar 20, 2000
102,389
8,547
126
sounds like a private school, they can do what they want.
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
"Psst - hey man over here. Wanna come with me behind the school and suck some H?"
 

TomC25

Platinum Member
Oct 12, 1999
2,120
0
0
I had a teacher inhale the gas from a helium baloon in front of the whole class :Q

wow
 

MikeO

Diamond Member
Jan 17, 2001
3,026
0
0
Originally posted by: ElFenix
sounds like a private school, they can do what they want.

It's still fvcked up. Sucking some helium from party balloon to alter voice is innocent fun, I still do it every time I get my hands on those balloons :D I did it several times as a kid, all my friends have done it, fvcking everyone I know has done it. It's innocent fun. And I have never ever heard anyone getting harmed by it.
 

Nitemare

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
35,461
4
81
Originally posted by: Skoorb
"Psst - hey man over here. Wanna come with me behind the school and suck some H?"

as opposed to going to the Father O'Malley's office and sucking some P?
;)

What do you expect you can't even have aspirin there.
Yet another reason why public/private schools suck
 

royaldank

Diamond Member
Apr 19, 2001
5,440
0
0
Shouldn't the person that brought the ballons to the school be punished as well? I mean, they did bring a potentially fatal and horrible drug into the school and gave kids easy access to it.

On the other hand, though, it's not the like the kid got suspended from school. He got a detention and couldn't go outside and play for a day. I'll bet it set an example, as well, and kids wont be inhalling helium from ballons anymore. It's not good for you and it accomplishes nothing but being disruptive and potentially harming the kid. I don't see much wrong with how the situation was handled. If he had been suspended from school and forced to miss out on his education or his grades suffered, then I would think the punishment was too extreme. However, I don't think his dad should have pulled him out school. Why make him suffer even more? And why make his learning and social development worse? I think people should be upset with the father here for taking his child out of the school. He's teaching the great lesson...if you don't like the rules, just quit.
 
Jan 18, 2001
14,465
1
0
Originally posted by: royaldank
Shouldn't the person that brought the ballons to the school be punished as well? I mean, they did bring a potentially fatal and horrible drug into the school and gave kids easy access to it.


thats what i was thinking. The school supplied the balloons and left within reach of the students. So kids are supposed to see the wrong in things even though the supervising adults dont?

from the article:
"There have been instances where children have fainted," she said. "I can't let them see this is an OK thing to do. It's not." Apparently, a child in Washington recently died after inhaling large quantities of helium from a tank.

And yet the school continues to expose children to Helium Balloons. If they are really concerned about it, then they should stop having helium balloons.
 

ChefJoe

Platinum Member
Jan 5, 2002
2,506
0
0
This is a catholic school. Having gone to catholic private schools from k-12 I would say this is right in line with how they view inhalation of a non-air substance and mistreating your body.

That being said, is it any wonder I would never send my kids to one of those schools.
 

trmiv

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
14,670
18
81
Originally posted by: royaldank
Shouldn't the person that brought the ballons to the school be punished as well? I mean, they did bring a potentially fatal and horrible drug into the school and gave kids easy access to it.

Yes!! WE must crack down on helium at the SOURCE that is dealing this evil substance to our children. I am declaring a war on helium! We will go after party planners, clowns, amusement park vendors. If our kids aren't tempted by these voice-candy pushers, maybe we can break the cycle once and for all. Once we take down the dealers, we will see that the brains behind this entire evil helium industry is taken down once and for all. His name? None other than the infamous Chuck E. Cheese. The big mouse is going down for pushing this drug on our children for so long! We need to name a Helium Czar to manage this whole War on Helium.
 

DaiShan

Diamond Member
Jul 5, 2001
9,617
1
0
Pittinger doesn't think it's a "crazy rule." She said that students aren't even allowed to bring cough drops into class without permission and that she'll stick to that policy.

Notice how she justifies the rule by citing another equally ridiculous rule?

Gopunk - LOL yeah do they want all kids to have a filter to filter out helium from the air?
 

bmd

Golden Member
Feb 17, 2001
1,043
0
0
Pittinger doesn't think it's a "crazy rule." She said that students aren't even allowed to bring cough drops into class without permission and that she'll stick to that policy.
Seems like the principal has all kinds of crazy rules. No cough drops?! Sheesh...

Edit: Bah, Daishan beat me to it :p
 

Jzero

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
18,834
1
0
Fine if they want to teach the kids the dangers of sucking helium.
I think that's great.

The problem is that this Pittinger character is supposed to be a TEACHER.

An educator should never hide behind poorly written policy to avoid actually having to teach a child a valuable lesson!
This kid learned a valuable lesson: People are schmucks and the innocent often get the shaft. While this poor kid was doing a Donald Duck impression, there were probably 3 other 7th graders smoking in the bathroom.

Couldn't the teacher have just said "HEY! Don't do that!"
Couldn't the teacher have explained the dangers of inhaling helium and told the kids that if they messed with the balloons, they'd get a detention?

*sigh*
 

piku

Diamond Member
May 30, 2000
4,049
1
0
Three students were suspended a few weeks ago at my high school for this exact thing. One of the kids (who is grossly overweight and out of shape) had a reaction or something so the teacher had to report it. One students who was suspended missed his senior prom because of the ordeal.
 

Cyco

Diamond Member
Jan 15, 2002
4,226
173
106
Originally posted by: CorporateRecreation
Hey it's a catholic school, at least he wasn't sucking something else.
Yechhh
At least he wouldn't have gotten suspended though.