Originally posted by: Don Vito Corleone
Originally posted by: Greg04
For what M*A*S*H* was, a dramedy, it was exceptional. Seinfeld, with the exception of Susan's death (horrible and rare writing misstep), was straight-up comedy. Hard to point to a better one. I'd put KOQ around 8/10 of Seinfeld. That's high praise.
I remember reading somewhere that when Seinfeld and Larry David sat down to conceive Seinfeld, they decided there would never be a "very special" Seinfeld. There would never be a moral to the story, the principal characters would never learn from their mistakes, and their narcissism would be reset and begin anew at the start of every episode. To me that is the show's defining characteristic and what makes it so brilliant - it is entirely amoral and doesn't aspire to be anything but what it is - a dark comedy focused on 4 essentially heartless people.
With all due respect to M*A*S*H, I think Seinfeld is purer and MUCH funnier because it doesn't purport to make the viewer a better person - it just entertains. I beg to differ that Susan's death was a misstep - IMO it was an entirely intentional demonstration of George's callow self-absorption. To me the idea that you could have a major character die with NO mourning or emotional consequences is part and parcel of Seinfeld's essential darkness.