They are trying to stand out from the crowd. Nintendo has ALWAYS put out things that don't go with the grain, and most of them were flops.
The other 2 are almost mirror images of each other. There is no way Nintendo following that path will be any better off than they are now. We don't need 3 consoles + PC with the exact same games. They don't put out enough exclusives (any of them) to justify it. They are fine where they are at. Again do you really want 3 consoles with 90% the same catalog? That isn't going to make anyone any happier. The 'games are more expensive to make these days' is a crutch excuse. Games are making more money than ever, and not just some of them. These companies aren't hurting. Same as the movie industry.
This NX seems like a real slap in the face, and isn't going to fix their image unless they come with guns blazing...which isn't possible at this point unless they stopped all production on Wii U and set all future games for it, even then you are looking at a 4-5 year trickle before you get any sizable amount of games. THIS is their problem.
Indeed, that's what I was trying to get across. Nintendo's still pushing
Star Fox and
Zelda (among others) as Wii U titles, which means they won't be ready until a couple (or more) years into the NX's life cycle.
Thing is, this isn't even about worrying about multi-platform fatigue. Nintendo has enough software/IP to get by, but not enough developers to produce it at an acceptable rate. Is it possible that the development of
Splatoon (a fine game, mind you) is why we haven't seen a proper
Animal Crossing since 2012, and a proper console iteration since 2008? If
The Legend of Zelda will be the first home console release (ignoring the re-release of
Wind Waker) in 5 years, will the NX have to go without a proper
Zelda until 2021? The console could easily be dead by then, if it flops.
Mario Kart took 6 years, and
Smash took 6 years as well. You can't be so first-party dependent and take 5+ years on franchises with regularity.
Nintendo can work just fine as a second-level offering for gamers, but it's going to be ugly if they exhaust all of their software options on the dying/dead Wii U, then launch the NX with the same problem--a lack of impending first-party releases.