As a student working toward my Masters degree in education, I am currently student teaching in an inner-city high school here in Denver. Actually, the school I am at is currently "ranked" last out of the 12 high schools in the Denver Public School system.
I hate to say it, but the people in this thread bashing the public schools really don't have any idea of all the factors that come into play in public schools.
Right now in CO, the governor has implemented a plan that is basically what many of you are proposing - "perform or die." All students in the public schools in the state are required to take the CSAP test - a standardized test that measures literacy and math ability. The test itself is actually a good test, but the way it is being used is FAR from how the authors intended it. Each school administers the test, and then is given a grade based on the students performance. If a school fails, and continues to fail 3 years in a row, the school essentially is shut down and becomes a charter school.
Right now, all those people criticizing the public schools are cheering, saying what a great way to make the schools, and especially those lazy, greedy teachers accountable, right?
Well, lets look at some of the reasons the school I work at has trouble. (I am sure many other schools face similar problems.)
Attendance: On any given day, though the school has almost 1,200 students enrolled, there are between 800 and 900 students in the building. With the attendance policies that are in place, most teachers could fail 1/2 of their students based solely on attendance. There are numerous reasons for this. Kids have to walk or find a ride to school if they are within three miles of the school. So, there are kids who have to walk three miles through heavily industrialized areas (there are
FIVE EPA Superfund sites in our attendance area), through areas known for gang violence and racial conflicts, just to get to school, even if they want to come. (Also note that if a kid misses the CSAP test, the school does not get a zero for the test score, but actually
LOSES five points from their overall score. Because of this, the school is adopting some logistical procedures for administering the test that will actually be harmful to most students, but they are trying to cover their asses.)
Poverty: Four years ago, the state ended a mandatory bussing order that had been in place in Denver since 1970 or so. When the school board established the new boundaries for schools, it wasn't done in a manner to be fair and equitable, it was done in a political manner. There is a high school down the street from ours that has a better reputation, and as such, the affluent neighborhoods were zoned to attend that school. When you get outside of our attendance area, there is literally a $10,000 increase in mean income immediately outside the borders. The middle-class and more affluent neighborhoods attend the other school, even though ours is closer and they have to be bussed through our attendance area to get to the school.
Migrant population: This is maybe more unique to our school than others, but we have students that travel through the area with their parents, who are migrant workers, for 3 months at a time, often less. These kids show up, come to school, take standardized tests and bring the schools scores down. They often have little or no record that can be used to assess where they are at.
Someone earlier hit the nail right on the head when he said that parents who send their kids to private schools take a more active role in their kids' education. That is one of the major factors effecting how well a kid does. Because of the environment many of our kids come from, the parents don't focus on that. Many of our kdis do really well, but most of them have support from their parents.
Am I making excuses? No. I am simply pointiung out that people who don't have any idea what goes on in the schools are not aware of all the issues that they face.
Those of you who call the teachers greedy, I almost find that laughable. At the beginning of my program, we went around and asked all the students in the teacher ed. program why they want to be a teacher. The MAJORITY of them were coming from careers in business or technology or even medicine. They were not happy with the shallowness they felt in the business world, and wanted to make a positive impact. It sounds like a cliche, but it is true. We could all be making more money somewhere else.
Go spend a day, or a week in an inner city school and see how quick you are to judge. THEN come back to me and tell me how easy it is. There are some truly amazing teachers at the school I work in. If they didn't love the kids and what they did, there is no way they would stay there.
Just trying to keep things in perspective here people.
