Originally posted by: notfred
1) Missing a shift is an accident, it hardly quailfies you as a dumbass.
2) Cars these days have rev limiters, they don't blow up if you miss a shift.
3) How could you accidentally hit 3rd instead of fourth? 5th -> 4th: stick comes straight down and slightly to the left. 5th -> 3rd: stick comes down to neautral, over to the left, and then back up to 3rd. They're not even close to similar motions. It'd be a lot easier to accidentally do 5th-> reverse.
Don't most transmissions make you double-clutch to get into reverse, and only while you're standing still? Well, mine does anyway. :frown:Originally posted by: notfred
1) Missing a shift is an accident, it hardly quailfies you as a dumbass.
2) Cars these days have rev limiters, they don't blow up if you miss a shift.
3) How could you accidentally hit 3rd instead of fourth? 5th -> 4th: stick comes straight down and slightly to the left. 5th -> 3rd: stick comes down to neautral, over to the left, and then back up to 3rd. They're not even close to similar motions. It'd be a lot easier to accidentally do 5th-> reverse.
Unless you're smart enough to hit the clutch right away (i.e., most people), a downshift can and will kill your engine.2) Cars these days have rev limiters, they don't blow up if you miss a shift.
Originally posted by: genocide
Unless you're smart enough to hit the clutch right away (i.e., most people), a downshift can and will kill your engine.2) Cars these days have rev limiters, they don't blow up if you miss a shift.
I didn't mean an intentional downshift, say you mean to shift to 3rd and you hit 1st by mistake.... And yeah, if you try to go into reverse while moving you'll just grind the hell out of the dogs in the tranny... My car (and many other VW's and BMWs) have the reverse up by the 1st gear, with a lockout, so that can't happenI said miss a shift, not downshift. And also, you can still hit reverse from 5th. The tranny won't go into gear, and it'll make a god awful grinding noise, but it's still hitting reverse.
Originally posted by: NutBucket
I know my car has a lockout (91 Accord) that doesn't let you go into reverse from 5th unless you go to neutral first. Also, downshifting to 3rd from 60 isn't terrible assuming your car is geared to allow it. I can do 80 in 3rd, more if I took it right to redline.
