Replace a laptop Mobile Athlon 4 with a desktop Athlon XP?

SlinkyDink

Member
Aug 20, 2001
99
0
0
Currently I'm trying to figure out a way to replace the Athlon 4 chip in my HP ZE1210.

After hours searching everywhere, I've only come up with limited information.

As far as I can tell the Mobile Athlon 4 identical to the desktop Athlon XP except that the L1 bridges are unlocked, and the default voltage is only 1.4v. Amd claims the mobile chip wont work in a desktop board, although I've heard that they infact will work (so why not a desktop chip in a laptop, if the bios would support it)

Two reasons jump out at me to do this. Obviously one is to install a faster chip in the laptop. Another posibility would be to install a chip of equal or close speed, but running at a much lower voltage such as the XP1600 AGOIA Y I have that runs at 1.0ghz with only 1.1v. The chip will probably need more voltage when in a notebook with a higher operating temperature (very little cooling going on inside a notebook), but I think there is a good bit of room to reduce the voltage dispite this. If this could be done, the lower heat and power draw would be very nice.

From everything I've read, the bridges on the Athlons can only specify a voltage as low as 1.4v (same setting as the mobile xp), although through PowerNow the voltage can scale down to only 1.1v at the lowest overall speed. Is this through modifying the VID in real time (in the same manner the multiplier is changed in real time), or is this simply dependant on the motherboard dropping the voltage? Is the voltage simply fixed on powernow, in which its always at 1.4v when at full speed, then scales back to 1.1v when at 500mhz? Or is it reducing the settings of whats already there? Theres always the option to simply reduce the voltage with a resistor mod on the mobo, although I only want to try that at last resort.

Other thought i had was to increase the fsb to 133mhz on the stock mobile chip, while lowering the multipliers to reflect the same total speed. The lowest cpu speed would then be 665mhz rather than 500mhz, but the overall preformance at any speed would be better.
AMD quotes the 100mhz bus as being "power saving", although the memory is still running at 133mhz, and I question the power saved with just a slower main bus. The new Mobile XP's (.13 micron mobile) run at a 133mhz bus, so why not the older chips?

I'm really wishing I had my old Duron 1ghz, which very easily would make playing with the bridges and testing to see if this could even work.

Sorry for the long post, but its quite a bit of "what if's" for me to figure out.
What do you guys think? Any ideas or knowledge on this?
 

jaybee

Senior member
Apr 5, 2002
562
0
0
fuggedabboudit. Have you opened your laptop? Me either, but my bet is that cpu is surface-mounted, not socketed. LMK if you know otherwise.

jaybee
 

Soulkeeper

Diamond Member
Nov 23, 2001
6,714
143
106
they sell Mobile athlons up to 1800+ at newegg
I don't think you'll be able to get the power now capabilities with the desktop ones
 

SlinkyDink

Member
Aug 20, 2001
99
0
0
The chip is in a socket (if it was soldered to the board, it would be pass-through and not surface)

The newer mobile XP's are a possibility, they have all I want, although you have to pay out the noise for one, if it can be done hacking a desktop chip to work would be much much cheaper.
 

zephyrprime

Diamond Member
Feb 18, 2001
7,512
2
81
No notebook has it's processor soldered on in any way. It's always either socketed or placed on a small carrier board which is socketed.

Try buying cheapo duron on ebay and you'll have a cpu to experiment with.

As far as your more technical questions go, I have no idea. Your only bet is to try AMD's processor documents on their web site.
 

SlinkyDink

Member
Aug 20, 2001
99
0
0
thanks zephyrprime, I'll see what I can figure out and post the results soon.
I'm a bit surprised I cant find any info of someone trying this before.
 

mrman3k

Senior member
Dec 15, 2001
959
0
0
They are usually socketed in a Socket A setup. Just open it up, pop it out, and replace it.