Rent Music. Can it happen?

Cashmoney995

Senior member
Jul 12, 2002
695
0
0
Do you think it would be possible to start a music rental service with the same premise as Netflix? Are there already laws against "renting" music.

I personally know that if a service like this started up I would use it. They could pay something to the artist, every time a cd' changed hands.

What do you think?
 

Bootprint

Diamond Member
Jan 11, 2002
9,847
0
0
They would DRM it up the ying-yang.

You can already rent music from Yahoo's service. Download and keep playing so that you can listen to it, but as soon as you stop playing, no more music.
 

DaveSimmons

Elite Member
Aug 12, 2001
40,730
670
126
Originally posted by: TheFlamingDead
Ha! I laugh at your primitive concept of paying for music.
I look down upon you sadly for your lack of ethics and morals. Theft is bad mmkay?



Like werk said, Napster and Yahoo already offer this if you buy a portable that supports DRM protected WMA files, and also offer PC-only playback even cheaper.

I run Napster on my music server box to legally preview CDs before buying them from Amazon.
 

Epic Fail

Diamond Member
May 10, 2005
6,252
2
0
Originally posted by: Cashmoney995
Do you think it would be possible to start a music rental service with the same premise as Netflix? Are there already laws against "renting" music.

I personally know that if a service like this started up I would use it. They could pay something to the artist, every time a cd' changed hands.

What do you think?

You don't need mailing like Netflix, songs are small enough to download.
 

Cashmoney995

Senior member
Jul 12, 2002
695
0
0
No duh, you can download them. But two things, once DVD AUdio comes in, its not so downloadable anymore. And next, if I started a rent cd service, for 15$ a month, wouldnt you rather do that and just rip all the cd's you wanted in full quality and say to hell with DRM. The movie guys gotta know everyone does it with DVD Movies already anyways...so why not music?
 

cornbread

Senior member
Jan 4, 2001
606
0
0
xm radio is "renting" music. if you think about it, regular fm radio is "renting" music as well, because you pay for it by listening to a bunch of commercials and songs that you don't care to hear just to hear a decent song that you care to listen to.
 

Cashmoney995

Senior member
Jul 12, 2002
695
0
0
Your still not understanding the concept.

I don't mean rent like you do with napster.

I mean rent as in the way you do a movie from blockbuster.

And if you had a rent service such as netflix, where you could just get a music cd in the mail, play it, and then send it back when you were "done" would you not pay for that rather than going through the hassle of buying all the music and downloading it. There is a lot of old music out there that you just can't feasibly download at decent quality. And sometimes you want entire albums which can get costly.
 

FoBoT

No Lifer
Apr 30, 2001
63,084
15
81
fobot.com
i am not sure you could charge enough $ per month and get enough customers to make money

i love netflix
 

thomsbrain

Lifer
Dec 4, 2001
18,148
1
0
DVD-Audio still isn't all that much data. It would take a few hours, but you could reasonably download that quality of audio over a broadband connection.
 

thomsbrain

Lifer
Dec 4, 2001
18,148
1
0
Originally posted by: Cashmoney995
Your still not understanding the concept.

I don't mean rent like you do with napster.

I mean rent as in the way you do a movie from blockbuster.

And if you had a rent service such as netflix, where you could just get a music cd in the mail, play it, and then send it back when you were "done" would you not pay for that rather than going through the hassle of buying all the music and downloading it. There is a lot of old music out there that you just can't feasibly download at decent quality. And sometimes you want entire albums which can get costly.

entire albums cost less to legally download than they do to buy... and music being old has no effect on the quality of the downloaded material. which isn't to defend downloading, since i'd still prefer a real CD any day. but for what you are suggesting, downloading is the obvious solution, and that's why there are already multiple big name music services doing exactly that and zero renting physical media.

even netflix is moving into the download arena, though they are facing huge licensing hurdles and they will be using a set-top box to protect the material and make it easy for everyone to view it on their TV. but i think everyone in the buisness sees movie downloading as the inevitable progression from netflix's current model.

and you're one of a tiny minority if you actually listen to music in that kind of "ok, i heard it once, i don't want to hear it again" fashion. unlike movies, where people are content to see it once or twice (with a few exceptions), music is something people will listen to over and over. i've left CD's in my car stereo for weeks at a time without changing them. even accounting for the "flavor of the week" nature of Top 40 Radio, I just don't see how anyone would be content to only have 3 or 4 albums to listen to at any given time. my favorite album was released 11 years ago, but i still play it once a month and often it stays in my car stereo for weeks at time.

and why would anyone pay to have 3 or so disc at a time when they could have access to record companies ENTIRE catalogs with the download services? and do you have any idea how much it would cost to develop a new media for this? and to promote the new players that everyone would have to buy? and for consumers to actually buy these players? you wanna talk about costly, imagine buying a new car stereo, new home stereo, new portable, new boombox, and even a new optical drive for your computer.