• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Reminder **Mortgage Rates are way low ** Not an Ad, just a reminder

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
I'm really not sold on the 20%. Rates are so low that putting an extra $10,000-$20,000 down on a modest house does very little over 30 years, PMI is tax deductable for a lot of people and most people can simply use that money on more expensive short term debt if they have it.

Very good to know, thank you.
 
We wouldn't be able to save 20% for probably another 5-10 years, unless if we get some absolutely huge amounts from the wedding. Am I really supposed to wait until I'm 41 to buy a house?

Yes you should.

Age doesn't matter. If you are not ready, you are not ready. Some people NEVER own a house.

It's not a hand out, it's something you have to work for!!!

We wouldn't be able to save 20% for probably I want to start a family next year, so I do appreciate your advice, but getting a 20% downpayment just isn't going to happen.[/QUOTE]

And you going to throw kids into a mix?

You are REALLY setting yourself up for failure.

I've been putting money into rent for the past 10 years, which is all money wasted.

It's ok, lot of people do that.

Remember, 1-2 missed mortgage payments and you in a lot worse situation then you are in today.

Not to mention the fiancee is literally crying over the fact that we would have to wait to save up $50k

Sounds like you might want to reconsider your marriage?

You or your fiancee are not entitled to ANYTHING in life. You have to work hard and MANY years to be ready.

Most Americans will NEVER end up owning a house (simple as that).

If you are not ready, don't even think about it.


I'm really not sold on the 20%. Rates are so low that putting an extra $10,000-$20,000 down on a modest house does very little over 30 years, PMI is tax deductable for a lot of people and most people can simply use that money on more expensive short term debt if they have it.

Yes, everyone in our society seems to think that. But there was a good reason it was done this way in the 70s/80s....before they deregulated and let the banks hand out money left and right.

As long as you and others remember that the risk is on YOUR side.

Although it does very little you have some buffer zone IF you lose your job or the prices go down. It's called a safety net.

Funny how the entire housing market crashed and...
a) banks are still doing sketchy things
b) people are still doing whatever they can to "own a house"

House ownership is something you have to be ready for. Also it's not all that is hyped up to be (many don't realize this either).
 
Last edited:
a) go with local small (reputable) bank or credit union /Stay away from big banks is the rule of thumb

b) there is no going around/magic trick to PMI (like there used to be).

c) pull up "does it make sense to refinance" calculator> plug in the numbers and see how much you will save over 30 years and see when your break even point is.

d) remember, if you are moving within next 3-5 years...chances are, no point to refinance

e)Paying PMI might still save you TON of cash

f)don't EVER drop your mortgage from 30 years to 15 or 10. Just get 30 year mortgage and pay it like you would if you had 15 years. Sure it will cost you more in the long run but you ALWAYS have the option of paying LESS. Once you take out 10-15 year mortgage, there is no option....

My advice would be to save money so that you can put it down as a downpayment on a refinance to get you over 20% mark. If you are able to pay 10-15 year loan...you should have no problems of saving that money in relatively short amount of time.

Also, keep in mind there is always a room for Appraisal person to put the value of your house little higher (especially when you are refinancing), but don't count on it.

I'm a big believer in "if you don't have 20% down you cannot affort a house". In your case, if you don't have 20% equity/down payment you cannot afford to refinance.

Can't afford to refinance? Seriously? Up until the huge drop in house prices I had a 50% LTV. I have enough cash to pay it down, but don't want to use it for that.

Also, if someone can get a lower rate at 15 years and can afford it, it would be stupid to follow your advice about 30 year loans.
 
Can't afford to refinance? Seriously? Up until the huge drop in house prices I had a 50% LTV. I have enough cash to pay it down, but don't want to use it for that.

Also, if someone can get a lower rate at 15 years and can afford it, it would be stupid to follow your advice about 30 year loans.

Everything depends on individual situation.

If you have plenty of money, savings and emergency fund and feel very comfortable going with 10-15 year loan.

GO FOR IT

if you making ends meet/just getting by I always suggest 30 year and make much larger payments (but always have an option to pay less).

So again, it depends. The reason I say "in most cases" or recommend it that way is because most Americans do live paycheck to paycheck....etc
 
Yes you should.

Age doesn't matter. If you are not ready, you are not ready. Some people NEVER own a house.

It's not a hand out, it's something you have to work for!!!

We wouldn't be able to save 20% for probably I want to start a family next year, so I do appreciate your advice, but getting a 20% downpayment just isn't going to happen.


I can't believe you say I should reconsider my marriage... I really don't see what that has to do with a house. Everybody wants a house. So I'm supposed to be reconsider marrying a girl because she wants a house?

If I really wanted to, I could tap my 401k and so could she and we could get 20% much faster...

We're going to get an FHA loan and PMI. We both have about as secure jobs as possible so I don't see the fallback to that.
 
I can't believe you say I should reconsider my marriage... I really don't see what that has to do with a house. Everybody wants a house. So I'm supposed to be reconsider marrying a girl because she wants a house?

If I really wanted to, I could tap my 401k and so could she and we could get 20% much faster...

We're going to get an FHA loan and PMI. We both have about as secure jobs as possible so I don't see the fallback to that.

What people want is irrelevant.

What people CAN have is what's relevant.

If her expectations are set on "I want a house" regardless of your financial situation....you are in for a surprise (is what I was trying to say).

Tapping into 401k....not the smartest idea....

And don't tell me there is a such a thing as job security, cause there isn't.

Again, the theme of the conversation is:
I CAN buy a house

My theme is:
Are you READY to buy a house

Just because you CAN, doesn't mean you SHOULD.

Talk to any financial adviser and chances are they will tell you 20% down and 6-9 months emergency fund first.
 
wife and i are looking to buy our first home and i'm looking at a 4.125% rate on a 30 year loan with a 5% down payment, and no PMI.
 
Emailed my lender from our last refi.

Our 4.875 can go to 3.75% (main house)
Our 5.375 can go to 4.25% (rental)

Saving over $300/month.

Thanks for this thread!!!
 
I can't believe you say I should reconsider my marriage... I really don't see what that has to do with a house. Everybody wants a house. So I'm supposed to be reconsider marrying a girl because she wants a house?

If I really wanted to, I could tap my 401k and so could she and we could get 20% much faster...

We're going to get an FHA loan and PMI. We both have about as secure jobs as possible so I don't see the fallback to that.

don't listen to people like the one telling you what to do. everyone's situation is different and no one knows it better than you yourself.

sure there is some good advice in here, but it is very dependent of people's specific situations.
 
Im thinking of refinancing.. was at 5.75/15yr @ 405k , refinance 2 yr ago down to 3.85/15yr 350k. It basically lowered my payment down 1k monthly.

I plug in a few calculators and it looks like if I can get 2.75-3.2, I'm able to lower my payments down another 600-900/month. Seems like its worth it right ?
 
what does that even mean?

He's trying to say that you too can't afford a house.

While I used to believe in that philosophy, I don't anymore.

There comes a NEED for things at a certain point in life.

How would you feel if you couldn't get a loan for a car because your car died, and you couldn't get to your job?

Well, maybe you should be required to have 20% down for that too.

Or why not just have us all pay cash for everything. Let's not enjoy anything until we're too old to appreciate it.

Sounds great to me... :-/
 
There comes a NEED for things at a certain point in life.

How would you feel if you couldn't get a loan for a car because your car died, and you couldn't get to your job?

Well, maybe you should be required to have 20% down for that too.

Or why not just have us all pay cash for everything. Let's not enjoy anything until we're too old to appreciate it.

Sounds great to me... :-/
Now I disagree with you.

Nobody has a need for a $200k+ house. The vast majority of people get by on much less.

Nobody has a need for a loan for a new or slightly used car. There are plenty of vehicles out there that will get you to work for $2,000 or less if you absolutely need it.
 
He's trying to say that you too can't afford a house.

While I used to believe in that philosophy, I don't anymore.

There comes a NEED for things at a certain point in life.

How would you feel if you couldn't get a loan for a car because your car died, and you couldn't get to your job?

Well, maybe you should be required to have 20% down for that too.

Or why not just have us all pay cash for everything. Let's not enjoy anything until we're too old to appreciate it.

Sounds great to me... :-/

well then he is greatly mistaken.

the loan is a 30yr fixed rate.

5% down is just under $21k.

it would take too long to save up $63k more to get 5% downpayment of $84k while also paying nearly $1500/mo in rent + living our current lifestyles.

my mortgage payments with taxes and insurance are going to be around $2300/mo.

after doing the math, after paying all our bills (retirement included in that) + mortgage, we will still have over $4k/mo left, probably closer to $4500-$5000.

so we will be able to own a house AND be able to live our current lifestyles.

it's awesome when people have no clue wtf they are talking about.
 
Also, as it looks like we will need an FHA loan, are those easy to get if both parties have good credit and stable jobs?

FHA you can get with 3.5 down but do require PMI. i would wait a year and save a nice down payment so you can have a LTV around 80%, canceling out PMI.
 
well then he is greatly mistaken.

the loan is a 30yr fixed rate.

5% down is just under $21k.

it would take too long to save up $63k more to get 5% downpayment of $84k while also paying nearly $1500/mo in rent + living our current lifestyles.

my mortgage payments with taxes and insurance are going to be around $2300/mo.

after doing the math, after paying all our bills (retirement included in that) + mortgage, we will still have over $4k/mo left, probably closer to $4500-$5000.

so we will be able to own a house AND be able to live our current lifestyles.

it's awesome when people have no clue wtf they are talking about.

How long have you been renting?

How much money have you saved during that time.

Based on your numbers you should be saving good 6-7k a month during your rent.

1 year to have 20% down payment.

What's the problem?
 
He's trying to say that you too can't afford a house.

While I used to believe in that philosophy, I don't anymore.

There comes a NEED for things at a certain point in life.

You have absolutely no idea what NEED means.

How would you feel if you couldn't get a loan for a car because your car died, and you couldn't get to your job?

Well, maybe you should be required to have 20% down for that too.

Or why not just have us all pay cash for everything. Let's not enjoy anything until we're too old to appreciate it.

Sounds great to me... :-/

You see, difference between us is that I would get a $2000 used car (or whatever I can afford at the time)....while you would go down to a dealership and buy a new luxury car or something.

Cars depreciate MUCH faster than just about ANYTHING you buy, so 20% is kind of low. You probably lose that when you drive off the dealer parking lot.

re: subprime lending.

I figured if they had no idea what I meant.....they have been in the closet past 2-3 years. Certainly not ready to have a "am I ready to buy a house" discussion hehe.

🙂
 
I actually have a 2007 Honda Accord with 80,000 miles and don't owe all that much on (4500 currently). The car before that was also a Honda Accord and it had 100k when I bought it, and 144k when I was done with it. I would've kept it longer but unfortunately I got in a bad crash (2008), so I had to purchase something newer. I would never buy a luxury car, ever. A guy I know went off and spent all kinds of money on an Audi A4 about a year ago, and he racked up all kinds of miles on it over the past year driving to see his fiancee who lives 5 hours away (also a stupid move but that's another conversation), now it has almost 100k. Nobody wants to buy a German car with 100k miles on it because everybody knows it's a money pit. He thought he knew everything because he's a car dealer with his own side business, but in reality he has no sense of money coming from a family that has nothing but money.

I may buy an Accord for the rest of my life... so don't tell me I'd go off and spend money on a luxury car.
 
I hope you realize I'm just trying to help you.

I want (and THINK I have a need) for MANY things in life. All of that is worthless, what I can actually afford is what matters.

🙂

We all want things we can't have, human nature.
 
I hope you realize I'm just trying to help you.

I want (and THINK I have a need) for MANY things in life. All of that is worthless, what I can actually afford is what matters.

🙂

We all want things we can't have, human nature.
If you want to help, try being less condescending and using less sarcastic emoticons.
 
Initially tried to refinance with current lender (Wells Fargo), but their rates and fees were quite high. The rep claimed the "no cost refinance" ad pitches from other companies were a gimmick, and they would hit you in other places (higher overall rates, hidden fees, whatever).

Shopped around and did some research (Fatwallet has a pretty good thread discussing lenders, rates, and experiences). Decided on Provident. Just submitted the initial paperwork, but it's looking like 3.625% APR (down from our current 5%).

Maybe it's just me, but all of the fees and costs and percentages are ridiculously convoluted. It's not until you get actual documentation sent to you that you can start piecing together things.

One thing I learned - if you also do an escrow account to bundle mortgage/insurance/taxes, that will get thrown in as a "fee" as part of the closing costs which they don't include in their fee estimates. So if they say a flat $500 cost to refinance, that means $500 + whatever you need in your escrow (which can be 4k+ depending on your taxes).

Since I have a current escrow with existing mortgage, I assumed that would get transferred over. It does, but what they do is just deduct it from your total borrowed, not add it to the new escrow.

Just another hidden cost I figure I'd share.
 
Back
Top