• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Recommend me a good fantasy novel series!

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Originally posted by: jonks
Originally posted by: Pheran
Originally posted by: dainthomas
Originally posted by: Mide
Dragonlance

ROFL!

I second (third?) Erikson. I'm on #3 now and the series is outstanding. GRRM is a tool and I will only read another book from him if he somehow manages to avoid death long enough to finish the series.

I don't see what's funny about this, the original DL trilogies (Chronicles and Legends) are fantastic. I can't speak for any of the later stuff though.

The original 3 I read as a teen, and agree they were great fun. The hundreds that followed from authors of varying degrees of talent, not so much. Even W&H's later DL series were not so good. I've read a few of their other non-DL series. Rose of the Prophet was blah. DeathGate Cycle was quite good.

Yeah, with the sheer amount of books that came out later, there's no way the quality was maintained. I've only read the two original trilogies plus the first Tales trilogy. I don't doubt that lots of the later stuff is crap.
 
I liked the original Chronicles of Thomas Covenant, and I'm certainly liking the last.
I also enjoyed The Sword Itself by Joe Abercrombie, but made the mistake of reading the following two books of the series. That ending is seriously dipped in ink and made me not want to read another one of his books. But named book was really good, mainly because it was fantastically fun.
The first five books of Terry Goodkinds series (Wizard's First Rule ->) are good, then Richard becomes too stupid and preachy for my taste.

Of course Terry Pratchett's Discworld series is mostly outstanding.

Oh, and Fell Cargo (Warhammer Fantasy novel) by Dan Abnett is actually rather good.

 
Originally posted by: Fritzo
What kind of fantasy?

Mine would be girl on girl twins...what's a good book for that?

There are a few times when the movie is better than the book. That would be one of those times.
 
I too was skeptical about Harry Potter. Its not the best books I've read, but they are nice diversion. They were great to read in airport, on the plane since they don't require a ton of thought. However, they are still well-written and there's a reason why she's a freaking billionaire.

Song of Ice & Fire is exceptional
You've probably read it already though.
 
Originally posted by: Pheran
Originally posted by: Dorkenstein
Tee hee, Harry Potter won awards because the Wizard's First Rule is right, people are stupid. I remember being at work in the early new millennium and taking my lunch break at a fast food place. A female employee was cleaning tables and asked me if I was going to go see the new (first) Harry Potter movie. I said no and went about my business. But somehow in my mind's eye I could picture her going to see it straight after her shift was over, probably with 6 or 8 kids in tow.

So I'm curious, have you ever read a Harry Potter book or are you just spouting an uninformed opinion because it's cool to go against the mainstream?

Ignore the troll. I don't consider Stephen King or the huge host of other authors who love and admire HP to be stupid.
 
Originally posted by: SP33Demon
Narnia, Potter, or anything by RA Salvatore (Drizzt stuff).

Hmm the RA Salvatore stuff looks pretty cool. I played the games (Boulders Gate and Icewind Dale). What's the order of the books in terms of Drizzt timeline? I'm going out in a bit and might pick up the first book.
 
Originally posted by: GagHalfrunt
Originally posted by: Fritzo
What kind of fantasy?

Mine would be girl on girl twins...what's a good book for that?

There are a few times when the movie is better than the book. That would be one of those times.

This.

Or you could try Terry Brooks' Shannara series. Pretty much a LOTR copy but very readable.

Edit: scratch that, try The Starchild Trilogy That'll mess with your head a while.
 
Originally posted by: DVad3r
Originally posted by: SP33Demon
Narnia, Potter, or anything by RA Salvatore (Drizzt stuff).

Hmm the RA Salvatore stuff looks pretty cool. I played the games (Boulders Gate and Icewind Dale). What's the order of the books in terms of Drizzt timeline? I'm going out in a bit and might pick up the first book.

If you're new to fantasy you might enjoy it. I find Salvatores work a bit too cliche, but maybe I'm spoiled. I don't want to read another fantasy novel that has your typical elves and dwarves thing going on.

I'd recommend Erikson, but to a person new to fantasy it might seem a bit overwhelming.

Try Greg Keyes' Thorn and Bone series. Book one is Briar King. Very accessible and a great read.
 
Originally posted by: Tobolo
Although it kind of strings you along, the A Song Of Ice and Fire (George R R Martin) series is pretty good.

Also, I would recommend the Dark Tower (Stephen King), Sword of Truth (Terry Goodkind), and the Malazan Book of the Fallen (Steven Erickson) series.

I am reading the 5th of the Malazan series now and it is an awesome series.

These are most excellent suggestions though SoT goes downhill after awhile.

My additions:
Robin Hobb's Farseer Trilogy
Zelazny's The Chronicles of Amber
Jim Butcher's Dresden Files
Glen Cook's The Black Company
Tad Williams' Memory Sorrow and thorn
 
Chronicles of Thomas Covenant and The Lensman series, a serial science fiction space opera by Edward Elmer "Doc" Smith
 
Originally posted by: ktehmok
Originally posted by: GagHalfrunt
Originally posted by: Fritzo
What kind of fantasy?

Mine would be girl on girl twins...what's a good book for that?

There are a few times when the movie is better than the book. That would be one of those times.

This.

Or you could try Terry Brooks' Shannara series. Pretty much a LOTR copy but very readable.

Edit: scratch that, try The Starchild Trilogy That'll mess with your head a while.

Do not read Shannara, it is nothing more than a blatant ripoff of LoTR and it's so poorly written that I couldn't finish it.


Originally posted by: jonks
Originally posted by: DVad3r
Originally posted by: SP33Demon
Narnia, Potter, or anything by RA Salvatore (Drizzt stuff).

Hmm the RA Salvatore stuff looks pretty cool. I played the games (Boulders Gate and Icewind Dale). What's the order of the books in terms of Drizzt timeline? I'm going out in a bit and might pick up the first book.

If you're new to fantasy you might enjoy it. I find Salvatores work a bit too cliche, but maybe I'm spoiled. I don't want to read another fantasy novel that has your typical elves and dwarves thing going on.

I'd recommend Erikson, but to a person new to fantasy it might seem a bit overwhelming.

Try Greg Keyes' Thorn and Bone series. Book one is Briar King. Very accessible and a great read.

Salvatore is like Dragonlance Chronicles, a good intro to fantasy or a light read if you don't want anything deep/complicated. The complete opposite end of the spectrum is R. Scott Baker's Prince of Nothing series which is very well written but requires effort to read.
 
Originally posted by: ktehmok
Originally posted by: GagHalfrunt
Originally posted by: Fritzo
What kind of fantasy?

Mine would be girl on girl twins...what's a good book for that?

There are a few times when the movie is better than the book. That would be one of those times.

This.

Or you could try Terry Brooks' Shannara series. Pretty much a LOTR copy but very readable.

It's critical that the OP stop after High King and the original trilogy. It turns to complete garbage in a hurry after that.

Edit: Sword of Shannara is a LOTR clone (but at least a good one unlike McKiernan), but Elfstones and Wishsong are both pretty good.
 
A Song of Fire and Ice is tremendous, though I can understand someone wanting to wait until it's finished before starting it.

it's a little off the beaten path, but The Chronicles of Amber are pretty good.

I enjoyed the Dragonlance books, but if I were to recommend them to someone, I'd say read the core books and leave it at that, no matter how tempting the other books may seem. chronicles, legends, and that last summer flame book and then cut yourself off. TSR (and later WotC) really milked every last dime they could out of the franchise and published a shitton of crappy Dragonlance-related novels.

it's not a series, but The Neverending Story is superb. I can't imagine anyone into fantasy not liking the book.

the Dresden books are pretty enjoyable light reads... I'm currently on book 4. not super fantasy or anything, but the basic premise is that the main character is a wizard PI solving typically arcane mysteries in Chicago.

and if you've got any penchant for sci-fi/space opera, check out Saga of the Seven Suns.
 
I enjoyed Raymond Feist's Riftwar series. The later books in the series are a bit weak but you can zip through the series pretty rapidly.
 
I always forget to mention Alan Cole and Chris Bunch's collaberation: The Far Kingdoms.

I seriously loved these books and they're very uncomplicated. No 1000 characters, or 40 plot lines to keep track of, no glossary, and each novel is a self-contained story.
 
Originally posted by: Dorkenstein
Tee hee, Harry Potter won awards because the Wizard's First Rule is right, people are stupid. I remember being at work in the early new millennium and taking my lunch break at a fast food place. A female employee was cleaning tables and asked me if I was going to go see the new (first) Harry Potter movie. I said no and went about my business. But somehow in my mind's eye I could picture her going to see it straight after her shift was over, probably with 6 or 8 kids in tow.

LOL, someone mocking Harry Potter that reads Terry Goodkind's objectivist drivel with plots that make Bring it on's latest sequel look good.

If you're looking for high quality:
Joe Abercrombie (dude is seriously evil though, don't ever think about liking a character)
Steven Erikson
George R.R. Martin
Robin Hobbs

If you're looking for some decent pageturner variety:
Feist
first two Dragonlance series
Potter
 
Originally posted by: ktehmok


Or you could try Terry Brooks' Shannara series. Pretty much a LOTR copy but very readable.

No, COMPLETELY a LOTR copy. I'm pretty sure that if you read it closely enough you'll notice points where Brooks forgets himself and starts calling the heroes Aragorn, Gimli and Frodo. Pretty much every enemy and every situation Brooks uses is directly stolen from LOTR. He didn't even bother to try to disguise the fact.
 
I second the recommendation of Tad Williams Memory Sorrow and Thorn and Raymond Feist's Riftwar Series. The Great Book of Amber is also high on my list.
I also recommend L. E. Modesitt, Jr's Recluse Series. I have read every book, and although they do not have quite as much action as some Sword and Sorcery books, I have found his world based on Order and Chaos to be very interesting. The series is Fantasy but a couple books have some Sci-fi mixed in.
I also recommend Dave Duncan, A Man Of His Word and
The Seventh Sword
 
Originally posted by: ktehmok
Originally posted by: GagHalfrunt
Originally posted by: Fritzo
What kind of fantasy?

Mine would be girl on girl twins...what's a good book for that?

There are a few times when the movie is better than the book. That would be one of those times.

This.

Or you could try Terry Brooks' Shannara series. Pretty much a LOTR copy but very readable.

Edit: scratch that, try The Starchild Trilogy That'll mess with your head a while.

Yeah I'm re-reading Sword of Shannara. The last time I read it was in intermediate school. And wow, nearly every character and major plot point in the book has an analogue in Fellowship of the Rings. It's embarrassingly blatant.
 
Originally posted by: DangerAardvark
Originally posted by: ktehmok
Originally posted by: GagHalfrunt
Originally posted by: Fritzo
What kind of fantasy?

Mine would be girl on girl twins...what's a good book for that?

There are a few times when the movie is better than the book. That would be one of those times.

This.

Or you could try Terry Brooks' Shannara series. Pretty much a LOTR copy but very readable.

Edit: scratch that, try The Starchild Trilogy That'll mess with your head a while.

Yeah I'm re-reading Sword of Shannara. The last time I read it was in intermediate school. And wow, nearly every character and major plot point in the book has an analogue in Fellowship of the Rings. It's embarrassingly blatant.
It's entertaining though, but the later stuff is pretty bad. Every book has the main characters doing something really stupid just to keep the story going. A couple chapters of plot, the rest filler. It pisses me off trying to finish it.

 
Originally posted by: kedlav
Originally posted by: Dorkenstein
Tee hee, Harry Potter won awards because the Wizard's First Rule is right, people are stupid. I remember being at work in the early new millennium and taking my lunch break at a fast food place. A female employee was cleaning tables and asked me if I was going to go see the new (first) Harry Potter movie. I said no and went about my business. But somehow in my mind's eye I could picture her going to see it straight after her shift was over, probably with 6 or 8 kids in tow.

LOL, someone mocking Harry Potter that reads Terry Goodkind's objectivist drivel with plots that make Bring it on's latest sequel look good.

If you're looking for high quality:
Joe Abercrombie (dude is seriously evil though, don't ever think about liking a character)
Steven Erikson
George R.R. Martin
Robin Hobbs

If you're looking for some decent pageturner variety:
Feist
first two Dragonlance series
Potter

Haha, the first rule is the only good part of Goodkind's lame-o books. I got to book 3 and gave up. And yes, Harry Potter is for kids.
 
Back
Top