here's the other
thread on spanking.
i've seen kids spit in their mothers face. i've seen kids kicking and screaming at their mother. I've seen kids hitting other kids in front of their parents then complaining to their parents about the OTHER kid. if my kid ever did any of those things he would get a spanking and he knows it.
I have 3 kids, oldest is 5 yrs old and he has STRONG value ethics. he won't hit other kids because he feels it is wrong. he has these STRONG ethic values because I instilled them in him since BIRTH. disciplining children contrary to popular opinion begins at birth. children are to be GUIDED by parents. molded by parents. the younger the children the fewer inputs they understand, you can't reason w/ a 7 month old, but you can let him know you disapprove of his actions.
also, different things work for different kids, when my 5 yr old was 7 months old, i tried different forms of discipline, the one he hated the most was sitting in his bedroom alone. he would panic, all other forms of discipline he would cry a bit but he'd get over it quick.
my daughter, who is currently 2.5, doesn't mind time out's in her room. she freaks out when she gets spanked. by freaking out i mean she starts crying uncontrollably and gets a look of real fear in her eyes, a time out, however, just becomes a period of time that she can spend by herself.
kids are different, for anyone to make a hard and fast rule that SPANKING is bad just doesn't understand children. my oldest son would never have survived his baby stage if i had used time outs as a form of discipline, my daughter on the other hand has an equal hatred for spankings.
using the logic of most of you anti spankers you would actually make my oldest son suffer more by eliminating spanking and just using the so called time out.
all of this is w/ the understanding that disciplining children only works if you have already shown them by example that you love them unconditionally. my children and i have that kind of relationship. for them, the biggest part of the discipline is understanding that i have disproved of their actions. in truth my spanking is never severe enough to even leave red marks on their skin. it's not the amount of pain (they inflict more pain on themselves in their everyday play) it's the fact that i am expressing disapproval that really hurts these children and gives them the incentive to behave better.