• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

[RANT]I was wrong about Mac...[RANT]

Jzero

Lifer
I once commented that I really like OS X because the GUI is very functional, easy to use, powerful, etc, but its BSD heart allows me as an administrator to configure and manage the machines with the same ease as my UNIX machines. Can't find it in the GUI? NBD--Just hit up the command prompt.

I noticed some network performance issues, and it seems that the OS X defaults to auto-negotiate for the ethernet card, and it auto-negotiated 100/Half. The switch at the other end is, of course, full duplex.

There is no way to configure this setting. I found a tip that says you can use ifconfig to do it, but as it turns out, while the command appears to work, no change takes place.

Research directly at Apple.com finds me the Read Me file for a G4, which basically says "You can't fix the Mac, you have to set your switch for autosense or half duplex."

So this <^> is for you, Steve Jobs, and your little clan. Fine if you want to protect stupid users from themselves, but if an administrator wants to administer his machine, you preventing him from doing so is a travesty. Don't give me the line from the G3 Read Me: "Your computer works best in half duplex mode." Because it is a LIE. It only works best in HDX if the freaking switch is set to allow it! These computers upload slower than dial-up.

Why not re-configure the switch? Because that involves setting individual ports as 100/Half, and then labelling them as such and making sure no one else uses them. If the Macs are ever moved to another building or suite where they cannot be plugged into those same switch ports, the old switch ports will have to be set back to 100/full and the new switch ports set to 100/Half.

It is much easier to bring these 4 computers into compliance with the other 500 than it is to make special exceptions for them.
 
omg, that must have been why when i moved a MAC into a different part of the building, it was having problems with the network!

haha, thats totally STUPID!!!!!
 
PowerMac G4: Maximizing Ethernet Performance

rolleye.gif
 
They WANT you to run the LAN connection at a greatly reduced speed so that the low networking performance is proportional to the low performance of everything else!!
 
I just can't freaking beleive this. Are you sure there is NOTHING you can do to set your duplex locally ?

I mean...jeez...I don't have a G4 in front of me, and therefore I am going to give you the benefit of the doubt...but shiz...this is RIDICULOUS !!!
 
Originally posted by: polm
I just can't freaking beleive this. Are you sure there is NOTHING you can do to set your duplex locally ?

I mean...jeez...I don't have a G4 in front of me, and therefore I am going to give you the benefit of the doubt...but shiz...this is RIDICULOUS !!!

See the article linked above.

According to this article, where ifconfig previously gave an error in earlier versions of OS X, in 10.2 if you order it to go FDX, no error is returned, but if you call ifconfig on the interface again, it is still set to auto and still at 100/half. The fourth reply down from jfanelli corroborates what I've found.

Grrrrrrrrrrrrr
 
Back
Top