OMG, please tell me this post is a joke.
Please tell me too! Gack, guess he didn't read the middle part of the thread. Must cede a point to you Lethal, he took it literally.
About Lithium-Ions and discharging...learned something new. Not that I don't believe you, just strange that I didn't run across that last night. I'll go look again. If nothing else I and hopefully a few others reading the replies will get longer life out of future batteries. Oddly enough one of Apple's recommendations is to run the battery completely dead in certain situations if the unit is locked up and their tips page for getting the most out of your battery says nothing about not letting it run down other than saying to charge the unit every 18 days or so. Even there it was phrased in such a way as to sound like "so it's ready to go when you want tunes" rather than "so your battery doesn't go kerput"
Guess I'm coming around to your way of thinking more about the video. If someone were to graffiti "Chrysler's unreplacable valve stem seals leak after 80,000 miles" on Caravan posters I wouldn't take that to mean my van was going to start smoking and using oil right at 80, but it'd make me pay attention to the possibility and maybe find out ways to delay it (or care for my iPod battery better). Guess some would take it as a deadline.
Still though that goes to consumer mentality, same people that can't apply some thinking to graffiti are going to fall for $255 refurbs, $99 battery exchanges, $400 paperweights... Then again if they can't be bothered to think about it why should I worry for them.
Funny Apple story occurred to me today - I once dug a sad looking MAC SE out of the mud where it'd been tossed when a foreclosed house was cleared out. House had sat empty for years so the computer couldn't have been used for as long. Took it home, wiped the mud off, was going to make it into an umbrella stand or something equally useless, but decided to plug it in to see what sort of explosion it'd make. It booted, the desktop came up, and to my amazement the clock was still accurate to the minute. All the while dead bugs were sizzling and some apparently non critical PCB was smoldering, could hear sparks arcing and smoke was billowing out the back...and the little ah heck of a computer was oblivous to it all, patiently waiting for me to open an application.
Maybe that's why I'm having trouble with the concept of Apple intending to make disposable hardware, which seemed to be the intent behind the design original iPod and supported by their begrudging help for out of warrenty support. They didn't used to make junk, don't think they do now, wonder now if their support was always this way.