Q: Is China going to overtake the U.S. as the world's foremost superpower?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

LegendKiller

Lifer
Mar 5, 2001
18,256
68
86
Originally posted by: OCguy
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: OCguy
There is no such thing as losing military Superpower status when you have the ability to destroy the world on your own within 45 min.


Economic superpower status? Sure, China can dump their USD holdings, and its bread-line time.

And watch China's economy go down the toilet. Bread lines here? They would kill to have bread in that situation.

They are starting to hedge their bets with Euros.

You can say many things about the Chinese, but being stupid is not one of them.

There's nothing to hedge. They can't possibly even out the dollar exposure, especially the double-down exposure since the US buys 1/3 of their stuff. If they US doesn't buy it, who will?
 

magomago

Lifer
Sep 28, 2002
10,973
14
76
Eh I don't ever see it in their plans to truly try to bring up the living standards of everyone. China is so large that its essentially an empire within itself. So as long as the cities are the advanced modern locations where the entire power bases are located, the rest is simply migrant workers upon which the country is built on. They'll wait for the population to drop and then slowly incorporate people into their main cities if its in their interest to do so.

That said a LOT of countries have major problems facing them. Not just the US and China. And this is ESPECIALLY true when it comes to water (and where battles are already being fought - like Israel's policy to secure water)
 
Oct 30, 2004
11,442
32
91

I don't think it's so much that China will overtake the U.S. as it is that the U.S. is going to atrophy. When you destroy your nation's economy through global labor arbitrage, that can happen to you.
 

Patranus

Diamond Member
Apr 15, 2007
9,280
0
0
Originally posted by: LegendKiller
Originally posted by: Patranus
China actually exports products...what does the USA actually manufacture and export?

China has a budget surplus...how are those trillion dollar budget deficits treating the US?

The US is still the world's largest exporter.

Are you sure about that?
https://www.cia.gov/library/pu...ankorder/2078rank.html

You also fail to address the issue of doing all of this with deficits while other countries (CHINA) can do with with budget surpluses.
 

gingermeggs

Golden Member
Dec 22, 2008
1,157
0
71
Originally posted by: BeauJangles
On the surface, I think China's economy will slowly catch up to ours. However, it will take a very long time for China to acquire the power projection capabilities that this country has. I don't see the US being supplanted as the foremost economic or military power in the world any time soon.

fuckin' time warps... OP BELOW

You mustn't discount the fact that as they obtain a greater slice of the pie,
someone is losing a portion of theirs. Who would you think would be losing part of their portion?
Would it ultimately be the one with the most disproportionally large piece?
Also as their proportion grow their sphere of influence on other countries and the access to resource control does also, so there's multipliers involved in such an equative formulation.
Power projection ability, the ability to militarily occupy other countries either through political pressure, economic pressure or out and out offensive military force.

Also I think your leaving out the EU's potential for growth in the pie also, remembering germany is the worlds largest export economy. Anti-Americanism/Neo-Imperialism isn't just about ideological, political or military interference with other countries, I believe it's primarily about economy and resource control issues.
So as other emergent countries come to get their slice, their effect is also apart of the conglomerate of the pie which squeezes the American portion of that economic pie. I noticed ex-president bush put some energy into india and I would think obama will do the same.
I think its mostly rationalizing the American portion, It's ironic how vampire themed sitcom's and movies are so popular these days.

 

DrPizza

Administrator Elite Member Goat Whisperer
Mar 5, 2001
49,601
167
111
www.slatebrookfarm.com
I think that the attitude in our country concerning China is very complacent. After WWII, many parts of Europe had been bombed back to the stone age. Look at Japan's capabilities at the end of WWII. Look at where Japan was economically by the mid to late 1980's. Europe is once again the wealthiest region in the world. Does China have a lot of problems that they have to overcome? Sure. One thing though that seems to really get forgotten a lot - a completely different cultural attitude toward learning/education. And, you can talk about percentages of money spent on education, etc. But, the sad truth is that the TOP 10% of students in China (and India) outnumber ALL of the students in the U.S.

Worse, American companies are relying more and more on intellectual capital overseas. Sure, we still have the financial capital, but we seem to have given up on learning math and science in the US, at least compared to our counterparts overseas. More and more of the top degrees in math, science, and engineering are going to foreigners. Meanwhile, the number of remedial level college courses is booming - something unheard of 30 years ago. I recently read two articles - editorials to a large degree, but still filled with a lot of accurate facts - two of them are worth a read:
http://www.fredoneverything.net/Foreigners.shtml
http://timesofindia.indiatimes...articleshow/403427.cms
actually, the 2nd isn't really that editorialized at all.

China could easily surpass us economically within 30-40 years.
 

LegendKiller

Lifer
Mar 5, 2001
18,256
68
86
Originally posted by: Patranus
Originally posted by: LegendKiller
Originally posted by: Patranus
China actually exports products...what does the USA actually manufacture and export?

China has a budget surplus...how are those trillion dollar budget deficits treating the US?

The US is still the world's largest exporter.

Are you sure about that?
<a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="https://www.cia.gov/library/pu...ankorder/2078rank.html"><a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2078rank.html">https://www.cia.gov/libr........./2078rank.html</a></a>

You also fail to address the issue of doing all of this with deficits while other countries (CHINA) can do with with budget surpluses.

I was thinking manufacturers.

http://investing.curiouscatblo...ing-countries-in-2007/
 

gingermeggs

Golden Member
Dec 22, 2008
1,157
0
71
Originally posted by: DrPizza
I think that the attitude in our country concerning China is very complacent. After WWII, many parts of Europe had been bombed back to the stone age. Look at Japan's capabilities at the end of WWII. Look at where Japan was economically by the mid to late 1980's. Europe is once again the wealthiest region in the world. Does China have a lot of problems that they have to overcome? Sure. One thing though that seems to really get forgotten a lot - a completely different cultural attitude toward learning/education. And, you can talk about percentages of money spent on education, etc. But, the sad truth is that the TOP 10% of students in China (and India) outnumber ALL of the students in the U.S.

Worse, American companies are relying more and more on intellectual capital overseas. Sure, we still have the financial capital, but we seem to have given up on learning math and science in the US, at least compared to our counterparts overseas. More and more of the top degrees in math, science, and engineering are going to foreigners. Meanwhile, the number of remedial level college courses is booming - something unheard of 30 years ago. I recently read two articles - editorials to a large degree, but still filled with a lot of accurate facts - two of them are worth a read:
http://www.fredoneverything.net/Foreigners.shtml
http://timesofindia.indiatimes...articleshow/403427.cms
actually, the 2nd isn't really that editorialized at all.

China could easily surpass us economically within 30-40 years.

Maybe spring rolls or dhal is better for your health then a cheese burger?
 

Engineer

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
39,230
701
126
Originally posted by: DrPizza
I think that the attitude in our country concerning China is very complacent. After WWII, many parts of Europe had been bombed back to the stone age. Look at Japan's capabilities at the end of WWII. Look at where Japan was economically by the mid to late 1980's. Europe is once again the wealthiest region in the world. Does China have a lot of problems that they have to overcome? Sure. One thing though that seems to really get forgotten a lot - a completely different cultural attitude toward learning/education. And, you can talk about percentages of money spent on education, etc. But, the sad truth is that the TOP 10% of students in China (and India) outnumber ALL of the students in the U.S.

Worse, American companies are relying more and more on intellectual capital overseas. Sure, we still have the financial capital, but we seem to have given up on learning math and science in the US, at least compared to our counterparts overseas. More and more of the top degrees in math, science, and engineering are going to foreigners. Meanwhile, the number of remedial level college courses is booming - something unheard of 30 years ago. I recently read two articles - editorials to a large degree, but still filled with a lot of accurate facts - two of them are worth a read:
http://www.fredoneverything.net/Foreigners.shtml
http://timesofindia.indiatimes...articleshow/403427.cms
actually, the 2nd isn't really that editorialized at all.

China could easily surpass us economically within 30-40 years.

Absolutely. :beer:

 

gingermeggs

Golden Member
Dec 22, 2008
1,157
0
71
Originally posted by: LegendKiller
Originally posted by: Patranus
Originally posted by: LegendKiller
Originally posted by: Patranus
China actually exports products...what does the USA actually manufacture and export?

China has a budget surplus...how are those trillion dollar budget deficits treating the US?

The US is still the world's largest exporter.

Are you sure about that?
<a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="https://www.cia.gov/l............8rank.html"><a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="https://www.cia.gov/libr........./2078rank.html"><a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="https://www.cia.gov/library......rder/2078rank.html"><a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="https://www.cia.gov/library/pu...ankorder/2078rank.html"><a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2078rank.html">https://www.cia.gov/l............ml</a></a></a></a></a>

You also fail to address the issue of doing all of this with deficits while other countries (CHINA) can do with with budget surpluses.

I was thinking manufacturers.

http://investing.curiouscatblo...ing-countries-in-2007/

those figures are confusing as there is many eu member countries there and the eu, when you add those member countries up, the total is much more then the eu total, must be excluding those members on that list I guess.
It still put germany as #1 all the same with china close second with regards to individual nations.
So the Usa relies heavily on capital holdings and productive assets to produce GDP- through "investment" in foreign resources- eg: Indonesian gold mining or oil production, little wonder USA set up Suharto.
And we still wonder why there is terrorism?
 

Atreus21

Lifer
Aug 21, 2007
12,001
571
126
Originally posted by: Elias824
Its possible that as we see their cost of labor go up we will see more people bring jobs back to the US. Though I could be wrong

Disagree. We will see more labor outsourced to countries like Vietnam and India. US companies are already investing partially in Vietnamese labor, while the rest of their investment (labor) lies in China.

 

5150Joker

Diamond Member
Feb 6, 2002
5,549
0
71
www.techinferno.com
What does the US produce these days? All it has going for it is a dying service sector which India is slowly taking bit by bit. The manufacturing base left for China long ago. America's remaining industry (e.g. cars) is in shambles, the financing sector is sunk, housing bubble burst, jobless rate at a record high and we continue borrowing from China. Wake up and smell the coffee. China already passed the US in power, America is a dying relic. In another 15 years, China will likely surpass the US in military strength as well--keep in mind they do not disclose their real military expenditures and we cannot sustain our current rate of expenditures. They are a growing economy, we are a shrinking one. If China gets control of Taiwan (which they will eventually), it will further consolidate their position as a superpower. The days of anglos being at the top are pretty much over but hey, everyone reaches their peak and falls, it's a cyclical thing. The Moores 600 years ago were on top of the world too and look at them today.
 

miketheidiot

Lifer
Sep 3, 2004
11,060
1
0
Originally posted by: Engineer
Originally posted by: JS80
The politically correct answer is "Never"

Corrected for you. Unless something changes our current paths, then yes, it will happen at some point.

american will be overtaken, but it likely won't be by the chinese
 

miketheidiot

Lifer
Sep 3, 2004
11,060
1
0
Originally posted by: OCguy
There is no such thing as losing military Superpower status when you have the ability to destroy the world on your own within 45 min.


Economic superpower status? Sure, China can dump their USD holdings, and its bread-line time.

this would likely not have a very big effect, actually. bond prices would drop about 10% in the short term then rebound as the market restabilized.
 

miketheidiot

Lifer
Sep 3, 2004
11,060
1
0
Originally posted by: Fox5
Originally posted by: 0marTheZealot
Originally posted by: Lemon law
I believe China is the number one economy already, military power is quite another thing. If military hardware were not a moving target, China would almost never catch up. As it is, China can slowly buy the best and the new high tech, and gradually pull ahead as
US existing stuff becomes obsolete.

Nah, the US economy is still at least 50% larger than China's, depending on who's estimates you believe. However, the growth of the two countries is quite different. China grows between 7% and 11% a year while the US is between 1% and 3%. It's all a question of trends. If the current trends hold, China overtakes us in the mid-century.

Militarily-wise, the US is far ahead of China. China still has to catch up with Russia before even thinking about the US. Technologically-wise, Russia and the US are within 5 years of each other. It's the absolute quantity that the US is well ahead in.

You think Russia is that close in technology? If you had picked any of our close allies (the UK, France, Israel, etc), I'd agree, but Russia...not so much.

russia has the tech thats on par with the us/uk/france, just not the money/organization to implement
 

miketheidiot

Lifer
Sep 3, 2004
11,060
1
0
Originally posted by: 5150Joker
What does the US produce these days? All it has going for it is a dying service sector which India is slowly taking bit by bit. The manufacturing base left for China long ago.
as has been pointed out, the us is still the worlds primary producer, especially of capital and durable goods.

America's remaining industry (e.g. cars) is in shambles, the financing sector is sunk, housing bubble burst, jobless rate at a record high and we continue borrowing from China.
and all these problems are getting better (excepts jobs which is 6-12 months out), furthermore we are not a record unemployment, not even close


Wake up and smell the coffee. China already passed the US in power, America is a dying relic.
china is still the weakest of the un security powers. dying relic, what are you some sort of china shill? We already have one of those here.

In another 15 years, China will likely surpass the US in military strength as well--keep in mind they do not disclose their real military expenditures and we cannot sustain our current rate of expenditures. They are a growing economy, we are a shrinking one.

seriously, not even close. china is a decade+ away from being even a secondary military power globally, at best now its a tertiary power, on par with iran, pakistan, or india.

 

1jzpowr

Junior Member
Apr 15, 2009
13
0
0
Originally posted by: 5150Joker
What does the US produce these days? All it has going for it is a dying service sector which India is slowly taking bit by bit. The manufacturing base left for China long ago. America's remaining industry (e.g. cars) is in shambles, the financing sector is sunk, housing bubble burst, jobless rate at a record high and we continue borrowing from China. Wake up and smell the coffee. China already passed the US in power, America is a dying relic. In another 15 years, China will likely surpass the US in military strength as well--keep in mind they do not disclose their real military expenditures and we cannot sustain our current rate of expenditures. They are a growing economy, we are a shrinking one. If China gets control of Taiwan (which they will eventually), it will further consolidate their position as a superpower. The days of anglos being at the top are pretty much over but hey, everyone reaches their peak and falls, it's a cyclical thing. The Moores 600 years ago were on top of the world too and look at them today.

China is no where near the US in power. In military expenditures, the US is around $600 billion while all generous estimates put China at around $250 billion (they claim its about $70 billion). The Us has the ability to project their power anywhere in the world within the hour, China can barely even complete field exercises that involve their airforce and ground forces. All estimates put China at about 25-30 years behind the US militarily. China doesn't even have the means to wage any type of war outside of their neighboring countries. Until China can project their power half way across the globe, the US doesn't have to worry about China passing the militarily.

Yes, their economy is growing faster than ours, but their GDP is also $10 trillion lower than ours. Sure, we a shrinking economy currently, because it is a recession. Most countries economies are shrinking right now, or have shrunk in the past couple years. As for most of our service sector going to other countries? There is much, much more to our service sector than call centers and help lines. Most of our service sector cannot be moved to other countries.
 

gingermeggs

Golden Member
Dec 22, 2008
1,157
0
71
Originally posted by: miketheidiot
Originally posted by: 5150Joker
What does the US produce these days? All it has going for it is a dying service sector which India is slowly taking bit by bit. The manufacturing base left for China long ago.
as has been pointed out, the us is still the worlds primary producer, especially of capital and durable goods.

America's remaining industry (e.g. cars) is in shambles, the financing sector is sunk, housing bubble burst, jobless rate at a record high and we continue borrowing from China.
and all these problems are getting better (excepts jobs which is 6-12 months out), furthermore we are not a record unemployment, not even close


Wake up and smell the coffee. China already passed the US in power, America is a dying relic.
china is still the weakest of the un security powers. dying relic, what are you some sort of china shill? We already have one of those here.

In another 15 years, China will likely surpass the US in military strength as well--keep in mind they do not disclose their real military expenditures and we cannot sustain our current rate of expenditures. They are a growing economy, we are a shrinking one.

seriously, not even close. china is a decade+ away from being even a secondary military power globally, at best now its a tertiary power, on par with iran, pakistan, or india.

That's the way stiff upper lip and be optimistic there, ol'boy!
While your weapon's tech remains A1, the USA will remain the worlds greatest arms exporter(durable goods? or do mean a maytag fridge that cost $10,000? I'd buy a skope' any day over that glorified yank esky) and military power that's undisputed fact, but it is a little disconcerting that your country is importing a lot of the scientists to hold the winners cup in those areas which float your economic boat, what happens if those people repatriate and take with them the ability to accelerate their own countries development of such production? there's no place like home!
Nobody is here supporting china's totalitarian dictatorship.

china is to Marxism, what the USA is to democracy.

The USA has toppled the governments of 50 countries, many of who where democratically elected ones, none of it is forgotten by those countries and observing nations, as the USA's economic clout swaggers, so will it's ability to pressure others to do things that aren't the most beneficial choices for those countries, like selling out their natural resources for a very small cut of its value.
USA buys 66% of the oil it consumes, but the price it actually pays through private ownership of the mining companies overseas is well short of what your average joe citizen of the worlds pays, so as the EU nations economically rise, so will the private holding by Europeans in those companies and that's why the USA's grubment is so entrenched in trying to stop state ownership of mineral, oil and gas resources internationally, it's ironic when a chinese corporation tries to make a take over bid for such resources corporations.
The USA has done this to my very own country, Australia, include major covert political interference in Australia's domestic politics. Such resources should never be just sold off at the expense of that nation own economy and with excise taxes being so low, any government in its right mind wouldn't let it happen. The USA's corporatocracy has stood over most of the worlds natural resources with bribes or bullets and you would be an absolute fucking idiot cockhead not to understand that as fact.
Do you think that's a fair enough thing to do?
Anti-Americanism isn't about the hatred of American citizens its about hatred of the capitalist system of exploitation.
Lets not even start with the USA/Australian trade agreement. If there was real free trade you wouldn't have a steer left in texass.
Chinese shill! Seriously your a fucken' shitcunt!



 

Svnla

Lifer
Nov 10, 2003
17,986
1,388
126
Superpower in military? No way.

1. China has no powerful Navy and zero carriers. How are they going to transport troops and planes for the long haul across the oceans? How are they going to attack someone from thousand of miles away?

2. China has almost no nuclear powered/sophisticate submarines or the ability to detect such submarines.

3. Highly train pilots and sophisticate planes? Not China.

Edit:
4. China has no high level of sophisticate intelligence gathering or communication via satellite and GPS.

5. Lethal and high tech weaponry research and development and manufacturing is still years, if not decades, behind the US.

Also don't forget about internal problems in China such as minorities, the HUGE gap between the filty rich and the penniless poor, rampart corruptions, and how to feed and get jobs for billions of Chineses.
 

miketheidiot

Lifer
Sep 3, 2004
11,060
1
0
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
Originally posted by: miketheidiot
Originally posted by: 5150Joker
What does the US produce these days? All it has going for it is a dying service sector which India is slowly taking bit by bit. The manufacturing base left for China long ago.
as has been pointed out, the us is still the worlds primary producer, especially of capital and durable goods.

America's remaining industry (e.g. cars) is in shambles, the financing sector is sunk, housing bubble burst, jobless rate at a record high and we continue borrowing from China.
and all these problems are getting better (excepts jobs which is 6-12 months out), furthermore we are not a record unemployment, not even close


Wake up and smell the coffee. China already passed the US in power, America is a dying relic.
china is still the weakest of the un security powers. dying relic, what are you some sort of china shill? We already have one of those here.

In another 15 years, China will likely surpass the US in military strength as well--keep in mind they do not disclose their real military expenditures and we cannot sustain our current rate of expenditures. They are a growing economy, we are a shrinking one.

seriously, not even close. china is a decade+ away from being even a secondary military power globally, at best now its a tertiary power, on par with iran, pakistan, or india.

That's the way stiff upper lip and be optimistic there, ol'boy!
While your weapon's tech remains A1, the USA will remain the worlds greatest arms exporter(durable goods? or do mean a maytag fridge that cost $10,000? I'd buy a skope' any day over that glorified yank esky) and military power that's undisputed fact, but it is a little disconcerting that your country is importing a lot of the scientists to hold the winners cup in those areas which float your economic boat, what happens if those people repatriate and take with them the ability to accelerate their own countries development of such production? there's no place like home!
Nobody is here supporting china's totalitarian dictatorship.

china is to Marxism, what the USA is to democracy.

The USA has toppled the governments of 50 countries, many of who where democratically elected ones, none of it is forgotten by those countries and observing nations, as the USA's economic clout swaggers, so will it's ability to pressure others to do things that aren't the most beneficial choices for those countries, like selling out their natural resources for a very small cut of its value.
USA buys 66% of the oil it consumes, but the price it actually pays through private ownership of the mining companies overseas is well short of what your average joe citizen of the worlds pays, so as the EU nations economically rise, so will the private holding by Europeans in those companies and that's why the USA's grubment is so entrenched in trying to stop state ownership of mineral, oil and gas resources internationally, it's ironic when a chinese corporation tries to make a take over bid for such resources corporations.
The USA has done this to my very own country, Australia, include major covert political interference in Australia's domestic politics. Such resources should never be just sold off at the expense of that nation own economy and with excise taxes being so low, any government in its right mind wouldn't let it happen. The USA's corporatocracy has stood over most of the worlds natural resources with bribes or bullets and you would be an absolute fucking idiot cockhead not to understand that as fact.
Do you think that's a fair enough thing to do?
Anti-Americanism isn't about the hatred of American citizens its about hatred of the capitalist system of exploitation.
Lets not even start with the USA/Australian trade agreement. If there was real free trade you wouldn't have a steer left in texass.
Chinese shill! Seriously your a fucken' shitcunt!

holy crap your dumb. (Australian was right with us on alot of those 50 overthrown governments btw) what does your post have to do with mine, anyways?
 

miketheidiot

Lifer
Sep 3, 2004
11,060
1
0
Originally posted by: Svnla
Superpower in military? No way.

1. China has no powerful Navy and zero carriers. How are they going to transport troops and planes for the long haul across the oceans? How are they going to attack someone from thousand of miles away?

2. China has almost no nuclear powered/sophisticate submarines or the ability to detect such submarines.

3. Highly train pilots and sophisticate planes? Not China.

Also don't forget about internal problems in China such as minorities, the HUGE gap between the filty rich and the penniless poor, rampart corruptions, and how to feed and get jobs for billions of Chineses.

china can't even train its own (civilian) pilots, they send them to the united states
 

0marTheZealot

Golden Member
Apr 5, 2004
1,692
0
0
Originally posted by: OCguy
There is no such thing as losing military Superpower status when you have the ability to destroy the world on your own within 45 min.

Well, only if you're Dr. Evil.

In any case, China has enough nukes to cause long-term damage to the entire world. Maybe not "melt the crust of the Earth" like the US/Russia, but still, there's not much difference between 500 nukes and 5,000 nukes going off. You are still talking about the destruction of modern civilization. Sure, the initial dead might be a bit lower, but the eventual outcome is about the same.
 
Aug 23, 2000
15,509
1
81
Originally posted by: DrPizza
But, the sad truth is that the TOP 10% of students in China (and India) outnumber ALL of the students in the U.S.



Please provide proof that their top 10% are better than any of our students. Or are you stating that 10% of their student population is a greater number than all of the students in the US which would be true, but that has no bearing on the level of education because their combined population is 5-6 times greater than the US.