1. Ok and I love when people have old posts thrown in their face, get mad, and yell "stalker" at the other person, high comedy. Too short and not enough ownage to win.
2. Classic ownage. Idiocy from the OP, then when everyone beats them down with evidence to the contrary, trying to spin out of it by saying he's trolling/just kidding (classic ownage maneuver) . I like this one a lot.
3. Troll thread, not an ownage thread. If you look at Muse's threads/posts in other subforums, he is obviously not this stupid. DISQUALIFIED.
4. Quality self-ownage, but too much regret and self-flagellation for it to be a great ownage thread. I don't want to feel bad for the ownage candidate which I do here.
5. Good one, though the thread itself is a little shorter than I would have liked; not quite enough back and forth. Maybe it was closed too soon?
6. I think Cheez is just an epic troll also I don't necessarily call it ownage unless the OP gets very irate trying to defend his thread/opinion and/or going into the denial phase like I mentioned in #2. It is ownage, since we all know better, but the reactions are just not there to make it as fun as I would normally like from an ownage thread.
7. Same as #6.
8. Good one and I think moonbogg turned and ran after seeing what actually transpired. Probably my second favourite so far.
9. How did you choose only one Texashiker thread?

As always owned, then denial and attack. Another good one.
10. Ok, not great. Too short.
11. I don't get this one. Am I missing something??
12. Mild ownage, but not all that interesting and boring because the person never seemed to return.
13. Amusing I suppose, but not great. more a rail against speculative reporting than any actual ownage.
14. This is awesome. Complete denial and an attempt to back out of the post by reinterpreting what he said and how contests work. Excellent stuff.
15. I want to choose this one, but I think we need to keep this one reserved for 2013. Still a little too open-ended at this point.
So I think I would rank them:
14
2
9
8
1
5
10
12
4
13
6
7
11
15
3
KT