PSA: Credit Card Minimum Payments About to DOUBLE

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Feb 19, 2001
20,155
23
81
Originally posted by: Tiamat
Originally posted by: Siva
Originally posted by: Tiamat
don't buy what you can afford. Its very simple. No need for minimum payments.
:shrugs;

So what if you can't afford groceries one month because you got fired? I guess it really is simple, to avoid debt you simply starve.

Thats why I have had a savings account that I haven't removed any money from for the past 12 years. (I understand that not everybody does this, but this is the way my parents raised me)

However, just so its known, my comment was more towards the overall view of credit cards. I had my "reply to message" window open for a while and by the time I actually posted, other more "tough situations" were posed. I was definately not commenting on situations like what Homerboy is going through. Situations like these make it impossible to not debt spend. Losing a job at the same time as getting a newborn is a catastrophy on finances and nobody can expect to recover from that for an extended period of time.

For the people living in a stable financial environment, debt spending isnt a great idea because if you lose your job while in debt and have other pressing financial needs, you are fvcked. This is what I was touching upon.


Yea and groceries cost like $8000 a month doesn't it. If you're telling me you didn't save even $200 to buy food for one month, then you're pretty damn sad. Living paycheck to paycheck when you make a decent amount means you need to learn to SAVE.

Americans don't save. It's a given. You gotta be cheap asian like me to start saving. I make a rule. spend 60% of what you make at most, save 40%. Don't even touch the 40%. I end up saving way more than 40% usually.
 

PricklyPete

Lifer
Sep 17, 2002
14,582
162
106
Originally posted by: SouthPaW1227
Anyone who only pays the minimum (heck, anyone who doesn't pay it COMPLETELY off by the end of the grace period) on a credit card is any idiot anyway.

And you are an idiot when it comes to grammar. I agree that having a balance on a high interest loan is not the best way to use your money...to blindly label these people as idiots pretty much makes you sound the same way.
 

akubi

Diamond Member
Apr 19, 2005
4,392
1
0
Originally posted by: Homerboy
Originally posted by: SouthPaW1227
when your married with 2 kids, send me your budget and we'll talk :)

How hard is this? Don't buy what you can't afford. That is all there is to budgeting on the basic level. Savings is another aspect if you have leftover funds each month. If you couldn't afford the kids, those should've been left outta the budget too.

All I'm saying is paying CCs interest rates is murder. There ARE other ways.

You're right. My newborn didn't need those diapers or formula. My 2yr old didn't need anything either. I wasn't buying freaking gold watches and new cars. In fact I SOLD my car and started riding the bus.

Your ignorance is painful

well... I honestly sympathetize with your hardship, but perhaps you could go with washable cloth diapers and breastfeed to save a few pennies here and there...
 

BlueWeasel

Lifer
Jun 2, 2000
15,944
475
126
Originally posted by: waggy
I was able to RETIRE at 28 years of age. so yes i do know about savings.

Retire at 28??? WTF did you do - sell drugs or win the lottery?
 
Feb 19, 2001
20,155
23
81
Originally posted by: PricklyPete
Originally posted by: SouthPaW1227
Anyone who only pays the minimum (heck, anyone who doesn't pay it COMPLETELY off by the end of the grace period) on a credit card is any idiot anyway.

And you are an idiot when it comes to grammar. I agree that having a balance on a high interest loan is not the best way to use your money...to blindly label these people as idiots pretty much makes you sound the same way.


Blindly? Spending more than you can afford is pretty idiotic. IT's an impossibility if you used cash only, but given its a possibility with CC you need to limit yourself. And if you can't? You're as good as an alcoholic or a drug addict.
 

gigapet

Lifer
Aug 9, 2001
10,005
0
76
Originally posted by: Budmantom
Originally posted by: gigapet
Why don't they just pay the whole balance off

obviously everyone on here has no experience living paycheck to paycheck.

:roll:


I do and it sucked so I stopped.

Tom

Its not so easy for some. There payday may barely cover food, shelter, car, insurance and gas.

If there are any emergencies....they have no reserves so they must use credit. These are the ppl that will be effected most by this, people that dont spend beyond there means and are struggling to make ends meet.

You may not see these people in your neighborhood but there are plenty of them in this country.
 

Homerboy

Lifer
Mar 1, 2000
30,890
5,001
126
well... I honestly sympathetize with your hardship, but perhaps you could go with washable cloth diapers and breastfeed to save a few pennies here and there...

sometimes breast feeding is not an option. Sometimes children or the mother don't do well. Honestly, my wife probably could have breast fed, and actually very painfully wishes she would have at this point, simply for the health of our child. However at the time she tried it, she just "couldn't" do it. And I know the next thing people are going to say is "well she should have due to cicumstances, health of child etc, but YOU try telling that to a post-partum mother. I triple-dog-dare you.

 

theGlove

Senior member
Jan 13, 2005
884
0
0
Originally posted by: DLeRium
Originally posted by: PricklyPete
Originally posted by: SouthPaW1227
Anyone who only pays the minimum (heck, anyone who doesn't pay it COMPLETELY off by the end of the grace period) on a credit card is any idiot anyway.

And you are an idiot when it comes to grammar. I agree that having a balance on a high interest loan is not the best way to use your money...to blindly label these people as idiots pretty much makes you sound the same way.


Blindly? Spending more than you can afford is pretty idiotic. IT's an impossibility if you used cash only, but given its a possibility with CC you need to limit yourself. And if you can't? You're as good as an alcoholic or a drug addict.

i didn't know the orig poster had multiple handles/accounts lol

 

oboeguy

Diamond Member
Dec 7, 1999
3,907
0
76
So let's see, a quick calculation... if you have "enough to live off of savings for one month", that means that you make at most what, 13 months worth of expenses, which means your savings rate is at most 1/13 < 8%. Ouch. I feel for you, homerboy. We have no kids (yet), but I understand that you'd want second, but it sounds like things were pretty tight for you in the first place. Sounds like you're employed now, though, that's good. Best of luck, dude.

And to stay on topic... increasing min payments sounds like a Good Thing(TM) in general for reasons stated above.
 

KK

Lifer
Jan 2, 2001
15,903
4
81
I use credit cards to take advantage of 0% financing for a year or so, then I get another one and transfer the balance.

Using a credit card for have to have items, food, clothing, ie., is pretty stupid unless you can pay it off in full.
 

Damn Dirty Ape

Diamond Member
Nov 1, 1999
3,310
0
76
The people that is going to hurt the most are the ones already in trouble (as said, the ones making minimum payments now)..

that said, I owe $16 on my (1) credit card. If we can't pay cash or afford to pay off the card each month, we really probably don't need it.
 

Murpheeee

Diamond Member
Apr 30, 2000
3,326
0
76
Originally posted by: KK
I use credit cards to take advantage of 0% financing for a year or so, then I get another one and transfer the balance.

Using a credit card for have to have items, food, clothing, ie., is pretty stupid unless you can pay it off in full.

So say you carry a $6K balanace on a 0% card

Your minimum payment jumps from $120 to $240

Thats a big deal with no warning.
 

Ns1

No Lifer
Jun 17, 2001
55,420
1,600
126
Originally posted by: DLeRium
Originally posted by: PricklyPete
Originally posted by: SouthPaW1227
Anyone who only pays the minimum (heck, anyone who doesn't pay it COMPLETELY off by the end of the grace period) on a credit card is any idiot anyway.

And you are an idiot when it comes to grammar. I agree that having a balance on a high interest loan is not the best way to use your money...to blindly label these people as idiots pretty much makes you sound the same way.


Blindly? Spending more than you can afford is pretty idiotic. IT's an impossibility if you used cash only, but given its a possibility with CC you need to limit yourself. And if you can't? You're as good as an alcoholic or a drug addict.

are you fvcking kidding me? I had to damn near max out 2 credit cards when i was unemployed at school making the min. payments. Credit was a godsend for that....9 month period of unemployment.
 

KK

Lifer
Jan 2, 2001
15,903
4
81
Originally posted by: Murpheeee
Originally posted by: KK
I use credit cards to take advantage of 0% financing for a year or so, then I get another one and transfer the balance.

Using a credit card for have to have items, food, clothing, ie., is pretty stupid unless you can pay it off in full.

So say you carry a $6K balanace on a 0% card

Your minimum payment jumps from $120 to $240

Thats a big deal with no warning.

Sure it make little difference, but not a big deal if you don't blow the 6k.
 

Homerboy

Lifer
Mar 1, 2000
30,890
5,001
126
Originally posted by: oboeguy
So let's see, a quick calculation... if you have "enough to live off of savings for one month", that means that you make at most what, 13 months worth of expenses, which means your savings rate is at most 1/13 < 8%. Ouch. I feel for you, homerboy. We have no kids (yet), but I understand that you'd want second, but it sounds like things were pretty tight for you in the first place. Sounds like you're employed now, though, that's good. Best of luck, dude.

And to stay on topic... increasing min payments sounds like a Good Thing(TM) in general for reasons stated above.


The full story is a bit longer if you really care...
It went like this:

Great job GREAT money, savings, spending, pretty much w/out worry.
Wife gets pregant; everything is great with the world and I'm living the american dream. ~10% into savings, 10+% into 401K... White picket fence and all. (admitedly we dipped into the savings to put in a new driveway so that didn't help).
~1 month later BLAM company goes bankrupt; laid off.
unemployed for ~month; land new job that pays A LOT less but just pays the bills, or most of them but allows nothing for savings for impending new baby and impending medical costs.
~2 months at new job they deceide to close our remote office for no apparent reason... back to unemployment, pending baby, vanished savings and same bills looming.

All in all it works out to the same sob story, just I "yada-yada" the middle part of it. Regardless, we were saving when we could, and it did hellp us out signficantly by buying us a months+ of less debt but the entire situation snowballed and couldn't really have been worse (ok I guess it could have been MUCH worse with some sort of car accicent or whatever, but you get my point).

We're not PERFECT with our spending now or even when we were horribly desperate, but we were by no-means frivolous in waht we bought or did. What the people (read: kids) in this thread need to realize is that no matter how well yor plan for ANYTIHNG is laid out, it is breakable... and often too easily.

Now... whos hiring part time? :)
 

Budmantom

Lifer
Aug 17, 2002
13,103
1
81
Originally posted by: NeuroSynapsis
Originally posted by: DLeRium
Originally posted by: PricklyPete
Originally posted by: SouthPaW1227
Anyone who only pays the minimum (heck, anyone who doesn't pay it COMPLETELY off by the end of the grace period) on a credit card is any idiot anyway.

And you are an idiot when it comes to grammar. I agree that having a balance on a high interest loan is not the best way to use your money...to blindly label these people as idiots pretty much makes you sound the same way.


Blindly? Spending more than you can afford is pretty idiotic. IT's an impossibility if you used cash only, but given its a possibility with CC you need to limit yourself. And if you can't? You're as good as an alcoholic or a drug addict.

are you fvcking kidding me? I had to damn near max out 2 credit cards when i was unemployed at school making the min. payments. Credit was a godsend for that....9 month period of unemployment.


Unemployed for 9 months... I don't think that I've gone 9 months with only one job.

Tom
 

waggy

No Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
68,143
10
81
Originally posted by: BlueWeasel
Originally posted by: waggy
I was able to RETIRE at 28 years of age. so yes i do know about savings.

Retire at 28??? WTF did you do - sell drugs or win the lottery?

i got lucky and inherited a lot of money and made smart decisions.

heh started a business at 15. hired some very smart people to work for me. outsourced help on the Y2K (yeah go lazy programers!) to the goverment, etc. sold that got a another job got laid off and didnt bother getting another heh.

I worked 12+hour days, worked part time at Lowe's, other computer related jobs to make it work.
 

CrimsonChaos

Senior member
Mar 28, 2005
551
0
0
I tend to agree that if you are paying the minimum balances on credit-cards, you're likely in a financial bind to begin with -- or you do not understand how paying minimum balances is about as effective as flushing 95% of your payment down the toilet.

With that in mind, I see nothing wrong with credit cards companies increasing their minimum payments. Since apparently a lot of Americans cannot take a responsible approach to paying off their credit cards on their own, they must be forced to.

Yes, there will be those rare instances where someone accumulated debt due to circumstances completely beyond their control. To this small percentage, I sympathize. But for the rest, just consider this increase in payments as a "helping hand" in managing your debts.


 

Murpheeee

Diamond Member
Apr 30, 2000
3,326
0
76
In saying all that, lets assume you are in a bind.

You have a lot of CC debt and are just making minumum payments for those cards.
They know they have to pay $xx per month.....to double that with no warning seems incredibly unfair.

Its like a bank renegotiating your mortage or car loan without your consent, suddenly you have to come up with twice the amount every month.
 

C'DaleRider

Guest
Jan 13, 2000
3,048
0
0
Originally posted by: dxkj
Originally posted by: SouthPaW1227
You are full of BS... you can make more money than they charge by turning it around and putting it in a CD or savings account


PLUS , you fvcktard, have you thought that if they are UP TO THEIR EARS in debt, they might have an IMPOSSIBLe time in getting approved for a low interest loan from a bank who looks at their CC balances and credit score as a liabilty

No, I'm not. It's called a "credit union" and you should find a way to become affiliated with one.

And if you've already ruined your credit, you're screwed anyway. There's no escaping it hardly once it starts, which is why I'm saying it's idiotic to even START charging so much that you're forced to pay minimums on 10% interest rates. You'll probably never recover if you live that lifestyle.


Im in a credit union... you cannot get unlimited funds at below 3%... if you could, I would take 10 million and turn around and put it in a 3.8% CD and be making 80k a year on the dumb bank/credit union

I'd ignore southpaw and his "advice". Fed fund rates right now....TODAY....are 3.25%, ant that's the rate the Fed charges banks. Prime rate, which is OUR interest rate, is currently 6.25%.

Of course, southpaw MAY be a bank so he's getting the Fed or selling AAA-rated bonds, and therefore getting that 3.25-4.48% rate. But of course he's not.

After all, as you and others have pointed out, in today's economy, having an unlimited access to 3% money would give one the HUGE opportunity to borrow and invest at a much higher rate of return......and essentially live off the interest differential between the borrowed funds and the invested funds. But I suppose, despite his profoundness in his postings, he's just not smart enough to grasp and follow through upon.

Source today's current Bank Rates.....Bloomberg.