protest against Abu Ghraib & get arrested

CanOWorms

Lifer
Jul 3, 2001
12,404
2
0
link (includes picture)

It was a skinny pair of stereo wires that got 21-year-old Joe Previtera charged with two felonies. A week ago on Wednesday, the Boston College student poked his head through a gauzy shawl, donned a black pointy hood, and ascended a milk crate positioned to the right of the Armed Forces Recruitment Center?s Tremont Street entrance. He extended his arms like a tired scarecrow; stereo wires dangled from his fingers onto the ground below. Without those wires, the Westwood native could have been mistaken for an eyeless Klansman dipped in black, or maybe even the Wicked Witch of the West swallowed by her hat shorn of its brim. But those snaky cords made the costume?s import clear: Previtera was a dead ringer for one of Abu Ghraib?s Iraqi prisoners ? specifically, the faceless man who?d allegedly been forced to balance on a cardboard box lest he be electrocuted.

"We found that street theater can be more effective in conveying a message than a flier," Previtera says nearly a week later, explaining why he?d dressed up like the Abu Ghraib prisoner. "We picked the location because we wanted to make people think about what they might be called or forced to do if they enlist in the military."

But the demonstration didn?t go as planned. Previtera ? along with four friends who?d come out to shoot photos and protect the blinded activist in case, as fellow BC student Nick Fuller-Googins put it, "some hyper-nationalist character came up and punched him in the stomach" ? figured the cops would warn him before they tossed him in the clink. But they didn?t. First, Previtera?s friends say, someone came out of the recruitment office and told him to get down; when Previtera didn?t, the person went inside. (No one from the Armed Forces Recruitment Center could be reached for comment.) Soon after, the cops appeared and watched the spectacle from their cruisers; shortly thereafter, the Boston Police bomb squad rolled up. Less than 90 minutes after the protest began, the police began taping off the area around him, and when Previtera stepped down, they took him into custody for "disturbing the peace." But Previtera had remained silent the entire time. "I was really trying to play the role as accurately as possible," he says. "So I was not speaking with anyone, just trying to stay there as still as possible." Any disturbance came from the crowd of gawking spectators that, witnesses say, assembled once the policeman showed.

At the precinct, Previtera discovered that in addition to the initial misdemeanor, he?d been charged with two felonies: "false report of location of explosives" and a "hoax device."

"This was supposed to be more symbolic than anything," says Previtera, who never imagined they?d nab him for a false bomb threat. "I never wanted to scare anyone into thinking I had a bomb. I just wanted to make people think about international affairs." He adds, "I never uttered the word bomb or explosive."

Previtera?s friend Soula was surprised too. But she realizes this kind of escalated police response has sadly become the norm for activists. "In the world and time that we are living right now ? most people will say the post-9/11 world ? when you go out to some demonstration or in any way display your dissent for anything related to the government or the status quo, you?re putting yourself at risk," she says. And the same day of Previtera?s protest, a report in the Boston Globe warning of possible terrorist threats read: "Officials were urged to take note of people dressed in bulky jackets in warm weather ... or trailing electrical wires."

So if Previtera didn?t mention a bomb, what exactly constitutes a bomb threat? "It can be implied, with fingers and wires ? especially in a heightened state of alert, as we are," says Officer Michael McCarthy, Boston Police Department spokesman. And McCarthy thinks this is common knowledge, even if the wires are accessories to a costume. "Mr. Previtera should know better. He?s a young adult educated at Boston College from a wealthy suburb. I?m sure he knows wires attached to his fingers, running to a milk crate, would arouse suspicion outside a military recruiters? office [when he?s] dressed in prisoner?s garb. If he has any questions as to why people think he may?ve had a bomb, then he needs to maybe go back to Boston College to brush up on his public policy. Or at least common sense, but they can?t really teach that there."
 

halik

Lifer
Oct 10, 2000
25,696
1
0
"for the land of the free and the home of the brave"



Officer Michael McCarthy, Boston Police Department spokesman. And McCarthy thinks this is common knowledge, even if the wires are accessories to a costume. "Mr. Previtera should know better. He?s a young adult educated at Boston College from a wealthy suburb. I?m sure he knows wires attached to his fingers, running to a milk crate, would arouse suspicion outside a military recruiters? office [when he?s] dressed in prisoner?s garb. If he has any questions as to why people think he may?ve had a bomb, then he needs to maybe go back to Boston College to brush up on his public policy. Or at least common sense, but they can?t really teach that there."


wtf??
 

Vadatajs

Diamond Member
Aug 28, 2001
3,475
0
0
The demonstration was in poor taste, but the police response it inexcusable.
 

GoPackGo

Diamond Member
Oct 10, 2003
6,496
558
126
Dress up like you might be wearing a bomb...get busted for wearing a bomb.

I am glad this idiot has been charged and hope he does some time in jail to think about his stupidity
 

Czar

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
28,510
0
0
Originally posted by: GoPackGo
Dress up like you might be wearing a bomb...get busted for wearing a bomb.

I am glad this idiot has been charged and hope he does some time in jail to think about his stupidity

yeah because the right to protest is just so undemocratic:roll:
 

sandorski

No Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
70,418
5,964
126
Wires = bomb. Just ignore the fact that a scene was faithfully recreated as statement. Did the Iraqi in the photo have a bomb attached to him?
 

CanOWorms

Lifer
Jul 3, 2001
12,404
2
0
more pictures as well as an article that seems to be more in the point of view of the protestors

------------

Wired war protester gets break

Prosecutors are considering ``amending'' bomb-threat charges against a Boston College student who mimicked an infamous photo from Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq to protest inmate abuse by American armed forces.
``The young man's appearance was putting some passers-by in fear,'' David Procopio, spokesman for Suffolk District Attorney Daniel Conley, said yesterday, ``but we're not aware that he indicated he had a bomb.''
On May 26, Joseph Previtera Jr., 21, an international studies major and the son of Westwood Conservation Commission Chairman Joseph Previtera, stood on a crate outside the Military Recruiting Center on Tremont Street in a black hood and sheet. From his outstretched forefingers dangled two wires leading to the box.
``I did this to offer another perspective for those thinking of enlisting in the military and because of the abuses they may be asked to commit,'' Previtera said.
 

fjord

Senior member
Feb 18, 2004
667
0
0
Published on Thursday, June 3, 2004 by the The Progressive

McCarthyism Watch: S.F. Art Gallery Owner Beaten Up for Showing Anti-Torture Painting
by Matthew Rothschild

 Lori Haigh runs an art gallery in San Francisco. Well, she used to.

On May 16, according to AP, she installed a piece of artwork by Guy Colwell entitled "Abuse." The painting (which you can see at www.nobeliefs.com/abuse.htm) is an elaboration of the torture that went on at Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq. In the foreground of Colwell's painting are two grinning U.S. soldiers, one man and one woman, with American flags on their sleeves. The man is holding a cattle prod, and the woman, a cigarette dangling from her mouth, is holding electrical wires. Those wires are attached to the fingers of three naked male Iraqi detainees, who are standing on cylinder blocks. The prisoners are hooded. In the background, two other American soldiers in sunglasses are leading a shackled and blindfolded woman into the room.

Haigh placed the painting in the front window of her gallery. Two days later, "someone threw eggs and dumped trash on the doorstep," AP reported, and "people started leaving nasty messages and threats on her business answering machine." She told AP that she received "about 200 angry voicemails, e-mails, and death threats."

So she decided to remove the painting, but still things got worse.

One day, someone walked into the gallery and spit in her face.

And then on May 27, someone "knocked on the door of the gallery, then punched Haigh in the face, knocking her out, breaking her nose, and causing a concussion," AP said. Two days later, she still had a bad black right eye, with purple on the cheek next to the eye, one bandage over the nose, and another over her right eyebrow.

The abuse was too much for her--she has two young kids--so she has closed her gallery down. If you go to capogallerysf.com, you will see a picture of the gallery's front door, with yellow caution tape across the front. "The Capobianco Gallery is closed," the site says.

"This isn't art-politics central here at all," Haigh told AP. "I'm not here to make a stand. I never set out to be a crusader or a political activist."

On Saturday, May 29, artists, poets, and other defenders of the First Amendment rallied in support of Haigh, her gallery, Colwell, and free expression.

"In effect, the attackers, instead of writing 'Jew' on the window, wrote 'Artist' on the window," poet Jack Hirschman, who spoke at the rally, tells me. "The attack was really something out of the Brown Shirts."

Hirschman says more than 100 people attended.

"This is all too scary for me," Haigh, who was at the rally, told the San Francisco Chronicle. But the paper said she was "visibly moved by the show of support" and is "weighing her options."

(I could reach neither Haigh nor Colwell for comment. I called the phone number of the gallery and got only this message: "Thank you for calling the Capobianco Gallery. Please leave a message after the tone.")

Here is Hirschman's poem he read at the rally. I'm reprinting it here with his permission:

Defiant
For the Capobianco Gallery
Not just elsewhere
But right here
In North Beach
The power of painting
To provoke and endure

Has called out
The old hatreds:
Death threats, spittle,
A physical attack on a
Gallery owner by

Detestable little
Worms from the fascist can of abuse
That's been thrown wide open.
Enough!
When the people
Gather, what's been terrifying

Turns to dust.
And brush strokes
Turn into the proverbial
Thumbs in the eyes of
Censoring war thugs,

Because the freedom
To create a work of art
Is of the deepest affirmation
Of the human heart
And its very deathlessness

Is why no violence can
Ever long prevent the beauty
Of its truth of liberty from being
Triumphant in its struggle
Against the lie of the living dead.

"The enemy cannot be triumphant in this kind of situation," Hirschman says. "The gallery has to open again."

Copyright 2004 The Progressive
 

CanOWorms

Lifer
Jul 3, 2001
12,404
2
0
he could have hidden an anthrax dispensing device in that hood!!! he should have protested in the nude
 

Perknose

Forum Director & Omnipotent Overlord
Forum Director
Oct 9, 1999
46,664
10,097
146
Originally posted by: freegeeks
it's clear from the photos that the guy is not a threat
Obviously.

One day, someone walked into the gallery and spit in her face.

And then on May 27, someone "knocked on the door of the gallery, then punched Haigh in the face, knocking her out, breaking her nose, and causing a concussion," AP said. Two days later, she still had a bad black right eye, with purple on the cheek next to the eye, one bandage over the nose, and another over her right eyebrow.

The abuse was too much for her--she has two young kids--so she has closed her gallery down. If you go to capogallerysf.com, you will see a picture of the gallery's front door, with yellow caution tape across the front. "The Capobianco Gallery is closed," the site says.
Such hateful, violent ignorance, and it goes unpunished. No arrests here. :|
 

cumhail

Senior member
Apr 1, 2003
682
0
0

Tab

Lifer
Sep 15, 2002
12,145
0
76
I would have up and pushed him over, then tell him he is electrocuted and dead. Putting blame on the soldiers is completely disrespectfull thing to do. I could care less if some hyper nationalist punched him.
 

slick230

Banned
Jan 31, 2003
2,776
0
0
Originally posted by: sandorski
Wires = bomb. Just ignore the fact that a scene was faithfully recreated as statement. Did the Iraqi in the photo have a bomb attached to him?

No, but some jerkoff activist looking to make a point might think that a good idea. Protest all you want, fine, but use some common sense. Especially after the warnings about people with wires hanging off of them, come on. I don't find it too much of a stretch for the police to think some activist (or terrorist) wanting to make a statement and go out with a bang, would camp out in front of a recruitment center, dressed like the "abused" prisoner, and wait until enough people are around to blow himself up.
 

sandorski

No Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
70,418
5,964
126
Originally posted by: slick230
Originally posted by: sandorski
Wires = bomb. Just ignore the fact that a scene was faithfully recreated as statement. Did the Iraqi in the photo have a bomb attached to him?

No, but some jerkoff activist looking to make a point might think that a good idea. Protest all you want, fine, but use some common sense. Especially after the warnings about people with wires hanging off of them, come on. I don't find it too much of a stretch for the police to think some activist (or terrorist) wanting to make a statement and go out with a bang, would camp out in front of a recruitment center, dressed like the "abused" prisoner, and wait until enough people are around to blow himself up.

Ridiculous.