Propane suppliers quietly reduce size of refills

OutHouse

Lifer
Jun 5, 2000
36,410
616
126
FYI for all you Memorial day grillers... get your tank refilled so you dont get ripped off.


http://www.9news.com/money/art...oryid=116311&catid=344


DENVER (AP) - Backyard grillers may get a little steamed this holiday weekend when buying refilled propane tanks: They will be getting less fuel for their money than last Memorial Day.
Advertisement

When oil prices soared in 2008, propane suppliers quietly reduced by two pounds the amount of gas pumped into each 20-pound tank, saying they wanted to avoid raising prices.

Since then, propane prices have been cut in half as the price of oil has dropped. But smaller refills are still being sold nationwide by many dealers, and most buyers are unaware because the tank is the same size.

"It's a price increase," retired lawyer Stuart Barr said Friday as he swapped a tank at a Home Depot store in Denver. "I'm a great believer in full disclosure. Give me the information."

The problem, consumers say, is that no one tells them they're getting less propane. Companies have adopted similar practices in the packaging of coffee, sugar and laundry detergent.

"I'm not surprised," said Tammi Dorsey of Denver. Carrying a tank of propane from a store Friday, initially unaware that she got less this time.

For the past year, tank exchanges at retail stores have generally cost $20 to $25. For a few bucks less, consumers can take their tanks to some stores to get them refilled instead of exchanging them. Those refills usually contain the full amount of fuel allowed by law.

Until last year, Blue Rhino and Amerigas, two major suppliers, put 17 to 18 pounds of propane in each 20-pound tank. Tanks should not be filled completely for safety reasons.

About a year ago, that amount was cut to 15 pounds to save consumers a price hike, Blue Rhino spokesman Chris Hartley said.

"There are a number of companies in different industries across the country addressing product packaging, just because of the soaring costs," he said.

Last year, all energy costs increased sharply, as did the price of steel used in tanks. Crude prices soared past $100 per barrel at the start of 2008 and climbed toward $150 by July. Propane futures hit $1.95 per gallon in the same month.

Those prices have all fallen this year, which would suggest bigger profits for propane distributors.

Hartley would not say if there were plans to return propane refills to the same levels as before the 2008 price spikes, but he did say that energy markets remain volatile.

In the last year, propane futures on the New York Mercantile Exchange have dropped from about $1.73 per gallon to just above 71 cents. They have climbed 11 cents since January.

Retailers who offer propane say they have not increased the volume of fuel in each tank because propane companies have not reduced prices.

Home Depot, which offers propane tank exchanges, said cutting the amount of propane in 20-pound tanks was an industry-wide measure.

There have been no customer complaints, spokeswoman Jean Niemi said.

Jose Rivera of Denver did the math in his head and concluded that the extra money spent on propane could have helped pay for other cookout supplies.

"That's some steaks," he said.
 

mwmorph

Diamond Member
Dec 27, 2004
8,877
1
81
That is annoying but its the same in many industries. OJ that went to smaller containers haven't come back either.

I also fly all the time. My fares have stayed the same but the checked luggage I'm allowed to bring for free went from 2 pieces to 1 piece to now no pieces (on the company formerly known as NWA, now Delta)
 
Mar 10, 2005
14,647
2
0
"that's not a price hike. you're still getting $20 worth."

people like that should be dragged into the street and beaten with a big stick.
 

91TTZ

Lifer
Jan 31, 2005
14,374
1
0
The public should form an action committee and have rolling boycotts of companies guilty of doing this. Make the companies live in fear.

I think this all started when the companies HAD to reduce portions to avoid price hikes. But once the cost of goods went back down, these established companies could not resist the temptation of additional profits and kept the portions the same.

This will all be temporary, though. With any competitive market the opportunity will present itself for new companies to spring up and offer more product for the same price. If the profit margins are really that high new startups will be able to undercut the established greedy companies.
 
Mar 10, 2005
14,647
2
0
Originally posted by: 91TTZ

I think this all started when the companies HAD to reduce portions to avoid price hikes.

a reduced amount at the same price is a price hike, professor.

But once the cost of goods went back down, these established companies could not resist the temptation of additional profits and kept the portions the same.

This will all be temporary, though. With any competitive market the opportunity will present itself for new companies to spring up and offer more product for the same price. If the profit margins are really that high new startups will be able to undercut the established greedy companies.

no, i'm pretty sure gouging is the name of the game. if the customer has no idea (who weighs their propane tanks?), all the better.
 

PlasmaBomb

Lifer
Nov 19, 2004
11,636
2
81
Originally posted by: The Boston Dangler
Originally posted by: 91TTZ

I think this all started when the companies HAD to reduce portions to avoid price hikes.

a reduced amount at the same price is a price hike, professor.

Increase the sticker price then...
 
Mar 10, 2005
14,647
2
0
Originally posted by: PlasmaBomb
Originally posted by: The Boston Dangler
Originally posted by: 91TTZ

I think this all started when the companies HAD to reduce portions to avoid price hikes.

a reduced amount at the same price is a price hike, professor.

Increase the sticker price then...

people would notice that, tho. it's easier to go from 12 oz. to 10.5 oz. in the same jar.
 

Jeff7

Lifer
Jan 4, 2001
41,596
20
81
Originally posted by: The Boston Dangler
Originally posted by: PlasmaBomb
Originally posted by: The Boston Dangler
Originally posted by: 91TTZ

I think this all started when the companies HAD to reduce portions to avoid price hikes.

a reduced amount at the same price is a price hike, professor.

Increase the sticker price then...

people would notice that, tho. it's easier to go from 12 oz. to 10.5 oz. in the same jar.
And of course change the packaging so that it either looks the same from the front, or so that it looks even bigger, like cereal boxes that have the same width and height as the old sizes, but the thickness went down.
Just more businesses continuing the age-old tradition of deceptive marketing.

 

Lonyo

Lifer
Aug 10, 2002
21,938
6
81
Well to be fair, they might still be paying higher prices.
The problem is, it goes something like this:

Company gets futures contract for product at price X. Sells to consumers at price Y.
Price of thing goes up. Company puts its prices up to Y2 (even though their contract is still at price X).
Company sorts out new contract at price X2. Sells to consumers still at Y2 (which is reasonable, their costs increased).
Prices go down.
Company is still buying at price X2 because thats what they agreed to, so they still have to sell at Y2 to maintain margins.

The problem is the lag time is overinflated between raw costs dropping and consumer prices dropping, and they increase prices as soon as they can to make more then without dropping them in a corresponding manner.
 

natto fire

Diamond Member
Jan 4, 2000
7,117
10
76
Originally posted by: xSauronx
gas?

pffft, ima be usin charcoal, fools. :p

Took a while for an actual griller to post in the thread. Propane is for heating and running engines only folks!
 

91TTZ

Lifer
Jan 31, 2005
14,374
1
0
Originally posted by: The Boston Dangler
Originally posted by: 91TTZ

I think this all started when the companies HAD to reduce portions to avoid price hikes.

a reduced amount at the same price is a price hike, professor.

You're surely getting less for your money, but it's not a price hike. The customer still sees the same price on the price tag. Other than that you're pointing out the obvious and it makes me question why you'd even challenge me on that.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
I've always wanted to put one of those 20 pound tanks in a fire and shoot a hole in it. I figure that'd make a pretty damn big fireball.
 

BUTCH1

Lifer
Jul 15, 2000
20,433
1,769
126
I just got an Amergas refill that has a $2.50 rebate slip on the tank with an explaination " we want our customers to know what they are buying so we increased the size of the 15lbs sign on the tank, apparently some of our customers did not know they were only getting 15lbs per refill", right, f-ing thieves IMO. I'm going back to dragging my tanks to a local campground and getting them refilled there..
 

se7en

Platinum Member
Oct 23, 2002
2,303
1
0
Originally posted by: Captain Howdy

Took a while for an actual griller to post in the thread. Propane is for heating and running engines only folks!

Charcoal is for making pretty little artsy painting things :D
 

Engineer

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
39,230
701
126
Originally posted by: Jeff7
Originally posted by: The Boston Dangler
Originally posted by: PlasmaBomb
Originally posted by: The Boston Dangler
Originally posted by: 91TTZ

I think this all started when the companies HAD to reduce portions to avoid price hikes.

a reduced amount at the same price is a price hike, professor.

Increase the sticker price then...

people would notice that, tho. it's easier to go from 12 oz. to 10.5 oz. in the same jar.
And of course change the packaging so that it either looks the same from the front, or so that it looks even bigger, like cereal boxes that have the same width and height as the old sizes, but the thickness went down.
Just more businesses continuing the age-old tradition of deceptive marketing.

Yep. Try finding a true half-gallon of ice cream now. You generally can't. Many are 56 oz. now. Hell, even the gallon of car wash solution that I bought in the past has now shrunk to 100 oz. I placed a new bottle next to the old gallon jug and the height is about the same, but the diameter of the bottle is smaller. The companies are quietly decreasing the sizes all the while, the markets are slowing increasing the prices. I personally think inflation is much more than the advertised rate that the gooberment is publishing. I see it every time I go shopping.
 

allisolm

Elite Member
Administrator
Jan 2, 2001
25,342
5,010
136
As BUTCH1 said there's an Amerigas $2.50 rebate and there's also a Blue Rhino $3 one here.
 

BUTCH1

Lifer
Jul 15, 2000
20,433
1,769
126
Originally posted by: Captain Howdy
Originally posted by: xSauronx
gas?

pffft, ima be usin charcoal, fools. :p

Took a while for an actual griller to post in the thread. Propane is for heating and running engines only folks!

While I do prefer the taste of charcoa,l gas grills are just so damm convenient I'll keep using one. Wood chips help mitigate the problem as far as taste goes, think I might buy a charcoal grill for the weekends when I have more time to devote to grilling and have the best of both worlds..
 

BUTCH1

Lifer
Jul 15, 2000
20,433
1,769
126
Originally posted by: allisolm
As BUTCH1 said there's an Amerigas $2.50 rebate and there's also a Blue Rhino $3 one here.

I think they are just "throwing us a bone" so to speak and hoping we'll forget the fact that we were getting ripped off. What about the 10-15 tanks I've paid for since last august?, I guess it's gone but I'm on my last Amergas re-fill for sure, taking my tanks to the campground may be less convenient for me but I refuse to continue to support these Co's that pull this crap..
 

mshan

Diamond Member
Nov 16, 2004
7,868
0
71
"What about the 10-15 tanks I've paid for since last august?"
Wow, sounds like you are a perfect candidate for buying own empty propane cylinder, finding a local propane distributor that refills tanks, and save a lot of money (I read comment elsewhere that it only cost person $13 to do so, though YMMV).