<<
<< Given the choice, would you buy the Toyota Highlander (Lexus RX300) or the new Honda Pilot (Acura MDX) and why? >>
Easy Answer - Honda Pilot. Why?
More power, bigger displacement motor -
* Honda 3.5L v6 240hp, Toyota 3.0L v6 220hp
Lower cost and higher value -
* even though Pilot's price hasn't officially announced, Honda has always priced their products lower than a comprablaly equipped Toyota. Compare the price between the Accord vs Camry, Odyssey vs Sienna, Civic vs Corolla, ES300 vs TL/CL, MDX vs RX300, and Acura RSX Type-S vs Celica GTS, and you will see the Toyota always cost more and sometimes feature less (Sienna is a much smaller minivan)
Better interior -
* The Highlander carries over that ugly urinal style shift gate design from the RX300. The Pilot's steering wheel looks awesome. Pilot has a third row seat to seat upto 7 with a "magic" style hideaway that folds into the floor. Highlander seats max of 5.
That's all I can think of for right now. Toyota are great products, but IMO, they are very overpriced. >>
Well, we just got a '02 Highlander Limited and we couldn't be happier with it. It's a great vehicle and it fits our needs. And the Highlander has a more comfortable ride the MDX/Pilot twins. But for $32,500 fully loaded, we couldn't go wrong (OK, it didn't have heated seats, but who's keeping score?😉). And I LOVE the interior of our Highlander. The interior of the Pilot looks to "busy" to me.
The horsepower difference means NOTHING b/c the Highlander weights about 600 lbs less than the MDX. The Highlander wouldn't have any trouble dusting the MDX/Pilot😉
But I do agree with the price comparisons made. Toyotas are usually higher priced.