Do you have your system in a desk cubby hole, or out in the open? Do you have any intake fans on the back? If no to these two things, I don't see how the warm air can be getting sucked back in, unless your ambient room temp. is high. But then again your mobo temps are low... Maybe you have poor airflow in your case around the PSU??
I'm talking about the slots on the power supply. They are on the side opposite of the exhaust fan, should be facing your burner.