Here is my estimate, based on my electric bills (in Maryland):
Running a 400Watt average total usage machine 24/7 runs up ~$16.98 monthly (my rate includes all taxes and surcharges). I have 3 computers, 2 with monitors and other peripherals. I'd roughly estimate the average usage at 80 watts (server/network equipment) + 160 watts (family comp/monitor/etc) + 240 watts (my workstation/monitor/etc). This places these computers within the $20-25/month area.
Keep in mind however, my wattage estimates are rough and depend greatly on how frequently and intensively the computers are used. The monitors shut off unattended, which makes a big difference. My cost could be $50/month if the CPU's worked constantly (hmm, Prime95) and the monitors remained on.
Nonetheless, I'm estimating on average my PC's account for 10-15% of the bill! :Q