Just noticed that Jarred Walton greatly expanded the benchmarking suite for his test of the HD7970M vs. GTX680M:
http://www.anandtech.com/show/6369/avadirect-clevo-p170em-part-2-gtx-680m-grudge-match/4
I'm not posting this to discuss the outcome of this particular test, but rather to start a discussion of the games he's added to the suite and whether we as forum members would recommend that these games be used for upcoming video card tests. Here's what he had to say:
I know a lot of folks around here think that the more games that are tested, the better the test, and therefore link to other sites more often than Anandtech. There's also a lot of talk about Nvidia-bias vs. AMD-bias, and it seems Jarred is trying to account for that. So what do we think of the following lineup?
(1) Batman: Arkham City (old)
(2) Battlefield 3 (old)
(3) Civilization V (old)
(4) Dirt 3 (old)
(5) Elder Scrolls: Skyrim (old)
(6) Portal 2 (old)
(7) Total War: Shogun 2 (old)
(8) Metro: 2033 (old)
(9) Starcraft II (old)
(10) Crysis: Warhead (old)
(8) Borderlands 2 (new)
(9) Diablo 3 (new)
(10) Dirt Showdown (new)
(11) Guild Wars 2 (new)
(12) Max Payne 3 (New)
(13) Sleeping Dogs (new)
(14) Sniper Elite V2 (new)
(15) The Witcher 2 (new)
First, assuming Anandtech can actually test 15 games in every test, any games you'd use in place of the ones above?
Second, assuming Anandtech can only test 10 games as it has in the past, which 10 games would you choose? Keep in mind that Jarred already had to drop Starcraft II, Crysis: Warhead, and Metro 2033 to keep the list down to 15.
UPDATE - 10/18/12
Based on input from the community, as well as Anandtech editors Jarred Walton and Ryan Smith, here's a suggested list for Anandtech to consider for the 2013 gaming suite:
(1) Battlefield 3 (Single-Player for repeatibility)
(2) The Witcher 2 Enhanced Edition
(3) Total War: Shogun 2 (Ultra Settings)
(4) Crysis: Warhead - to be replaced with OR joined by Crysis 3 depending on the product tested
(5) Metro: 2033 - to be replaced with Metro: Last Light
(6) Dirt Showdown
(7) Sleeping Dogs
(8) Batman: Arkham City (for Unreal Engine testing)
Note: Ryan is in need of new strategy and sim games - one suggestion is Anno 2070, and Project CARS on the racing sim side.
http://www.anandtech.com/show/6369/avadirect-clevo-p170em-part-2-gtx-680m-grudge-match/4
I'm not posting this to discuss the outcome of this particular test, but rather to start a discussion of the games he's added to the suite and whether we as forum members would recommend that these games be used for upcoming video card tests. Here's what he had to say:
Our 2012 gaming suite currently ranges in age from over two years old (Civ5) to as recent as 11 months old (Batman), with an average age of around 16 months. Hardware and games have both changed during that time, so we dug through our games folder and added a few other titles to the mix. Okay, truth be told, we actually have quite a few gaming codes from AMD and NVIDIA (as well as Guild Wars 2 from ArenaNet), and we figured a selection of games from both sides should be more or less “fair”. To that end, we’ve benchmarked eight additional games: Borderlands 2 (NVIDIA), Diablo 3 (“agnostic”, DiRT Showdown (AMD), Guild Wars 2 (“agnostic”
, Max Payne 3 (NVIDIA), Sleeping Dogs (AMD), Sniper Elite V2 (AMD), and The Witcher 2 (NVIDIA). That’s three NVIDIA “TWIMTBP” (The Way It’s Meant To Be Played) games and three AMD “Gaming Evolved” titles, so overall things should be relatively even. Here’s how the two mobile GPUs stack up using the latest available drivers (NVIDIA 306.97 and an as-yet-unreleased 12.9 Hotfix from AMD), at all three of our target settings.
I know a lot of folks around here think that the more games that are tested, the better the test, and therefore link to other sites more often than Anandtech. There's also a lot of talk about Nvidia-bias vs. AMD-bias, and it seems Jarred is trying to account for that. So what do we think of the following lineup?
(1) Batman: Arkham City (old)
(2) Battlefield 3 (old)
(3) Civilization V (old)
(4) Dirt 3 (old)
(5) Elder Scrolls: Skyrim (old)
(6) Portal 2 (old)
(7) Total War: Shogun 2 (old)
(8) Borderlands 2 (new)
(9) Diablo 3 (new)
(10) Dirt Showdown (new)
(11) Guild Wars 2 (new)
(12) Max Payne 3 (New)
(13) Sleeping Dogs (new)
(14) Sniper Elite V2 (new)
(15) The Witcher 2 (new)
First, assuming Anandtech can actually test 15 games in every test, any games you'd use in place of the ones above?
Second, assuming Anandtech can only test 10 games as it has in the past, which 10 games would you choose? Keep in mind that Jarred already had to drop Starcraft II, Crysis: Warhead, and Metro 2033 to keep the list down to 15.
UPDATE - 10/18/12
Based on input from the community, as well as Anandtech editors Jarred Walton and Ryan Smith, here's a suggested list for Anandtech to consider for the 2013 gaming suite:
(1) Battlefield 3 (Single-Player for repeatibility)
(2) The Witcher 2 Enhanced Edition
(3) Total War: Shogun 2 (Ultra Settings)
(4) Crysis: Warhead - to be replaced with OR joined by Crysis 3 depending on the product tested
(5) Metro: 2033 - to be replaced with Metro: Last Light
(6) Dirt Showdown
(7) Sleeping Dogs
(8) Batman: Arkham City (for Unreal Engine testing)
Note: Ryan is in need of new strategy and sim games - one suggestion is Anno 2070, and Project CARS on the racing sim side.
Last edited: