Poll: Which of these banners is better? Can you top me?

[Josh]

Hello Guys:
Your local little genius here . I just finished making two banners for Pokeball.net and I was wondering what you guys thought of it. Take the poll and tell me which one is better.

CLICK HERE TO CHECK OUT THE BANNERS

If you think you can come up with something better and it actually IS better please post it here and I will gladly send you a free Dragonball or Pokemon Movie Fansub or a Pokemon doll or Dragon Ball cards. Your choice. If it's damn good, I'll send you all of it!

 

[Bignate603]

sometimes no snide comment seems adequate

oh well, whatever floats your boat.

<Edit>I was refering to the pokemon, the banners actually show some skill, and you're probably right I couldn't do any better. But about the pokemon, well, i find it an odd hobby</EDIT>

 

[ForeverSilky]

Those banners look like ass. And I won't bother besting them cause you won't send me my free tape.

 

[eakers]

i prefer the first one.

*kat. <-- avoiding her skool work

 

[Azraele]

Why not instead of insulting them, offer some constructive criticism?

The banners look fine, as far as banners go.

<Edit>: as for which I like better, I like the top one better.

 

[Killbat]

Those banners are far more effective than most I've seen. KEEP IT SIMPLE

 

[Josh]

Thank You -- at least to the ones who actually HELPED me. As for BigNate and ForeverSilky; please try to top me. I wanna see how good you are, you gotta back up your words people, and I WILL send you a tape.

 

[godsgift]

Yeah very simple..........

 

[Josh]

Hehe, well if I made it more spicier then it would load too slow. I'm looking for something small and attractive.

 

[ForeverSilky]

<< and I WILL send you a tape >>


Like when you had that DBZ trivia contest but wouldn't send out the tapes?

 

[NaughtyusMaximus]

I like the top one better by far. I think what the bottom one is lacking is a background. The gradient you have in the first one does a good job of grabbing the eye to the 'toon character, while the plain black just seems bland to me. (It could also me the yellow character that I don't like, I'm not sure.)

 

[arod324]

<sigh> pokemon</sigh> Anyways I like the picture with Ash in it. <sigh> I actually know his name </sigh>

 

[Deeko]

Some of you should shoot yourselves. Such unnecassary bashing.

The first one looks pretty good. I'd go with that one.

 

[Josh]

Gotcha. First one it is. Do you think the second one would TOP the first one if there was a gradient present?

 

[FettsBabe]

I like the top one.

 

[SuperSix]

The banners are nice, but the fad is on it's way out.

Pokemon stuff is selling at Big Lots now! :Q

 

[Kaoru]

Yea, use the top one

 

[MajesticMoose]

Content aside, I like the first one.

m00se

 

[Josh]

Thank You

 

[Wagner]

Make one like the &quot;Punch the Monkey&quot; banner. But make it say &quot;Shoot the Pokemon&quot;. And make it so you can shoot the Pokemon.

 

[Josh]

Haha -- like I haven't heard enough &quot;Kill the Pokemon&quot; jokes!

 

[urameatball]

plain and simple. both are good.

but on the other hand... banners.... YUCK!!

I've learnt through the years to automatically filter them out... so I could goto a site full of banners and not notice any! I'm sure many of us do the same. Just like how I didn't notice there was a mushkin banner at the top of this site until someone told me...

try something new... like a... tv ad... haha, j/k

 

[shiznut123]

I remembered I posted in this thread. Where did it go? Anyway, the top one is the best.

 

[GoldenTiger]

The top one is better.

 

[Josh]

Thanks Dudes