• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Poll: What is your favorite (best) IDE cdrom and why?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
ASUSTeK 50x has been going strong for me over a year and a half here. It isn't that loud compared to the rest of the fans in my case, but it sure is fast and reliable. DAE is great too.
 
I tried putting a creative 52x in a system I was building for someone, the thing died after about 15 minutes of use. It felt like a piece of junk, and it sounded like a miniature jet engine, the thing was so darn loud. I ended up going with a Sony 48x cd-rom drive, it is a very nice drive; I throw the Sony's in all the lower end systems I build now.
 
My Toshiba 40x does DAE at about an average of 11x according to CDSpeed. Maybe not the fastest, but definitely not "crappy". Additionally, Toshiba's are quiet and reliable.
 
I like my Mitsubishi 50X. Mitsubishi makes the 50X drives for Acer too. These drives are cheap, very fast, and exteamly reliable. Still going after a year without 1 problem!
(Although so has my Media Vision (bankrupt!) 2X SCSI CD-ROM drive, made by Sanyo...still working perfectly after 6 1/2 years!!)
 
Stay away from Creative Labs. I have a Creative Infra 48x, and it sounds like it is going to explode when reading a disc. I've just ordered a Toshiba 48x to replace my Creative drive.

I've been reading user reviews of Kenwood drives. Kenwood drives break too easily and fail to read many CD-R and CD-RW. I would avoid Kenwood.

From what I've read so far, Asus, Teac, and Toshiba make fast and reliable IDE CD drives. Asus drives are somewhat louder, but not too horribly annoying. Asus has the best data/audio extraction. Toshiba is the weakest of the three in data/audio extraction but reads almost any CD, CD-R, and CD-RW out there. And Toshiba is quiet. Teac seems to be the compromise between Asus and Toshiba.
 
Afreey 52X IDE cdrom drive does the job for me. Not many people may know this brand and it's also cheaply priced. It does very fast DAE, about 20+ speed.
 
My CD-ROM just burned out...so I am looking for another one.

So they have 'Sorta' fixed the Bug in the Kenwood 72X TrueX...which stand at a cost of around $75 after coupons.

Then there is the Teac540E 40X at around $50 after Coupons.

Then the Toshiba 48X........I have yet to find information online, or price, or place to purchase...can someone give me a link?

Until I see the Toshiba, my research seems to lean to the Teac540E above any others...too many reported bugs in Kenwood(although the technology is cool!)...
 
cheapest prices on the web from companies with the drive in stock:

Sony 48x: $44.48 shipped (to zip 87102) from Allstarshop.com. Allstarshop is a good company; I've bought stuff from them before.

Teac 40x 540E: $47.99 w/free shipping from Onvia.com. Onvia.com ain't bad; I bought from them before too.

Toshiba 48x XM-6702B 48x:
$49.50 shipped (to zip 87102) from PCLink
$50.66 shipped (to zip 87102) from Puicorp.com
$40.56 + s/h from Memorymedia.com
I never bought from any of these places.

from what I've read, it seems the Teac is the best all around drive. all 3 of these drives can read subchannel data and audio (handy for PSX backups).
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top