• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Poll: What do you think about summer break for kids?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Which summer break scheme do you like best for kids?

  • 2-3 months off

    Votes: 24 53.3%

  • Full-time school with a corporate-like PTO scheme

    Votes: 4 8.9%

  • One or two 2 week breaks

    Votes: 12 26.7%

  • Something else

    Votes: 5 11.1%
  • Total voters
    45
Another thing, especially in high school, it was important to get the summer off so I could get a summer job. It's how most kids pickup money for post secondary. By the time I finished high school I had enough money for college from having worked summers.
 
I'm conflicted on this. Given how stupid most kids are when they get out of school part of me says that they should abandon breaks and teach more, The other part of me says that the Department of Education is such an utter failure that 20% more class time will leave the kids just as stupid as they are now.
 
snoopy7548 said:
PTO for school is one of the most asinine things I have ever heard of. I really hope it's not a thing these days. Yes, let's get our kids used to corporate life as early as possible! Remember, they're just another future worker/cog in the wheel. I don't even understand how PTO would work for school; as someone else said, you can't just take a couple of weeks or a few days off of school. You'll be behind your classmates and have to play catch-up. School is different than work - school keeps going no matter what because you actually learn new stuff all the time, work for the most part will generally stay put. This has absolutely nothing to do with coddling.
Click to expand...
Yes, God forbid we prepare kids for the real world ahead of time....

No no no no, let's not prepare them for responsibilities in life and instead let then fall flat on their face like current generations and their gender studies degrees. It won't have any lasting negative affects or anything....
 
Red Squirrel said:
Another thing, especially in high school, it was important to get the summer off so I could get a summer job. It's how most kids pickup money for post secondary. By the time I finished high school I had enough money for college from having worked summers.
Click to expand...
Probably the only halfway decent argument from the "keep summer break" side. Though it can be argued for kids to have a job during school anyways, since plenty of people in college have to work while going to school in order to pay bills and have food.

But from a percentage perspective, how many kids in the US do you think actually look for a job when on summer break? I would take a stab and say less than 10% ?
 
s0me0nesmind1 said:
Yes, God forbid we prepare kids for the real world ahead of time....

No no no no, let's not prepare them for responsibilities in life and instead let then fall flat on their face like current generations and their gender studies degrees. It won't have any lasting negative affects or anything....
Click to expand...

Taking away childhood for ever more materialism. The kids may make a lot of money but be miserable with themselves and others. Divorce follows. American life
 
I think that a 1 month after every 6 months of school should be the thing...? Give them a break in the early spring and early fall but only the day off for Thanksgiving and only 1 week for Christmas... This should be a good amount of time off and split up too...? Just my .02 thing... 😀

I mean they need a break too ya know so give it to them just not the whole summer as they do now... Split it up and spread it out which should give them more of something to look forward to...?
 
s0me0nesmind1 said:
Probably the only halfway decent argument from the "keep summer break" side. Though it can be argued for kids to have a job during school anyways, since plenty of people in college have to work while going to school in order to pay bills and have food.

But from a percentage perspective, how many kids in the US do you think actually look for a job when on summer break? I would take a stab and say less than 10% ?
Click to expand...

I think you are way off. Lifeguards, movie theaters, summer camps, landscaping and a pile of other things have kids working at them. It's also very regional. Places with high summer tourism also have a high number of high school kids working various things.
 
Working at the local fair during the summer was considered a rite of passage. I promptly blew my 3 week paycheck on my first computer, which brought me to this forum.

After typing that out, I'm not sure if that was an argument for or against summer break.
 
Ns1 said:
Working at the local fair during the summer was considered a rite of passage. I promptly blew my 3 week paycheck on my first computer, which brought me to this forum.

After typing that out, I'm not sure if that was an argument for or against summer break.
Click to expand...

You worked. You earned. You spent. American dream!
 
Red Squirrel said:
They definitely deserve it. I know when I was in school it was the only thing to really look forward to. School is the most stressful part of one's life. If your life after school is more stressful you are doing it wrong. 😉
Click to expand...
Holy crap, I totally disagree about school being the most stressful part of one's life. I'm sure some kids have it rough, with real family/behavioral issues, but no way even a majority of them do. Not having a prom date, what clothes to wear, not having a car in senior year, pfffft, that's not stressful things. Real world problems are not even comparable to that high school drama crap (that doesn't even f'ing matter once you graduate).
 
pauldun170 said:
2 months off to experience "non-school curriculum" stuff is pretty damn valuable.
Community service stuff, Scouting, travel or just socializing in general opens up all sorts of learning opportunities they can't get in a normal classroom environment. Hell, there are plenty of kids who are attending multiple 1 to 2 week "specialty camps" (science\music\sports\religion\language).

Unless you're a shitty parent who sticks a smart phone in their hand and points them in the direction of the xbox.....
then yeah..maybe you should find a year round school.
Click to expand...

That's being optimistic thinking kids will actually be put in such programs. Before they are 14, which includes a lot of years, they are put in various sports camps (glorified babysitting so they can play with friends) just to keep them from playing those video games. And it's quite costly at about $500/week around here. I work from home and even so I can't have them stay here all day every day.
 
rh71 said:
That's being optimistic thinking kids will actually be put in such programs. Before they are 14, which includes a lot of years, they are put in various sports camps (glorified babysitting so they can play with friends) just to keep them from playing those video games. And it's quite costly at about $500/week around here. I work from home and even so I can't have them stay here all day every day.
Click to expand...

It's a reality around here. Even if it's only a small percentage of households.
As for cost, some parents feel the sacrifice is worth it.
 
When I taught in South Korea my students had a month off in February and a month off in July. But, that was public education Kids in SK go year round, to schools like the hagwon that I worked at. As you guys know education in SK is relentless. The suicide rate is very high among 13-19 and most of that is due to the stress that they have to endure.

With that said, the world is drastically changing. It's not the world that we grew up in. Back in our day it moved at a slower pace, and we didn't have much challenge globally and domestic. There was little automation, and jobs were easier to obtain with little skills. It's much different now. Playtime has its place, but to spend all day for 2.5 months doing nothing is a waste. If I had kids I'd make them at least read for an hour. They could do work that they did while they were in school, so they don't get left behind. I wouldn't make it demanding. Just my thought.
 
PTO for kids in school? So you have kids out at random times for a week or two and they come back and have to catch up to the rest of the class? Yeah..no.

Summer vacation is fine just the way it is.
 
I think 2 week breaks between quarters and 6 week breaks between semesters.

Edit: But this is assuming the school has appropriate climate control (A/C).
 
Mai72 said:
When I taught in South Korea my students had a month off in February and a month off in July. But, that was public education Kids in SK go year round, to schools like the hagwon that I worked at. As you guys know education in SK is relentless. The suicide rate is very high among 13-19 and most of that is due to the stress that they have to endure.

With that said, the world is drastically changing. It's not the world that we grew up in. Back in our day it moved at a slower pace, and we didn't have much challenge globally and domestic. There was little automation, and jobs were easier to obtain with little skills. It's much different now. Playtime has its place, but to spend all day for 2.5 months doing nothing is a waste. If I had kids I'd make them at least read for an hour. They could do work that they did while they were in school, so they don't get left behind. I wouldn't make it demanding. Just my thought.
Click to expand...

Growing up, we used to get summer reading assignments from our English teachers. I think you had to write a short report on each book assigned and hand it in to your new English teacher at the start of the new school year. That was really my only "learning" during all of my summer vacations and I typically finished it as soon as possible; I spent about 95% of my time either playing videogames or watching T.V., playing outside and swimming with friends, or going on vacation with my parents, while the other 5% was spent being lazy. Once I turned 15 I got a summer job until I graduated high school.

I'm sure every older generation says this... but I seriously feel bad for kids these days. It seems like a lot more keeps getting expected of them and now they have to worry about social media and being connected 24/7; it's incredibly unhealthy for the mind. When I was in high school, "social media" was talking with your friends on AIM, and you could log out whenever you wanted to...
 
clamum said:
Holy crap, I totally disagree about school being the most stressful part of one's life. I'm sure some kids have it rough, with real family/behavioral issues, but no way even a majority of them do. Not having a prom date, what clothes to wear, not having a car in senior year, pfffft, that's not stressful things. Real world problems are not even comparable to that high school drama crap (that doesn't even f'ing matter once you graduate).
Click to expand...
QFT

As someone that went through all of that shit, it was entirely meaningless after the fact.
 
lxskllr said:
I'm a traditionalist. They should put the kids in the fields weeding and picking vegetables. They'll appreciate school more in the fall.
Click to expand...

Bah, it is the modern day. I say we do exchange programs with 3rd world countries. Send them to replace kids in sweatshops for the summer and the kids they replace can come have a nice leisurely summer working the fields, eating well and getting a full nights sleep.
 
GagHalfrunt said:
I'm conflicted on this. Given how stupid most kids are when they get out of school part of me says that they should abandon breaks and teach more, The other part of me says that the Department of Education is such an utter failure that 20% more class time will leave the kids just as stupid as they are now.
Click to expand...

It would give them 20% more time to teach them how to pass a standardized test to make the schools stats look better.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top