• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

POLL: Opteron SMP, Xeon SMP, or P4 HT kicks most a$$?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
I'd wait for the socket 939 or 775 if you are Intel preferenced. Couple of things to note, personally I love the Intel HT and I use a lot of simultaneous apps as well, office apps, photoshop, etc. I would not go with the A64 single channel chips, which while good chips are going to suffer in multitasking environments.

My thinking is to go with a 775 P4, since you do audio work amongst your interests, but I'd wait for the socket 775 versions to be out, you'll get good multitasking and when Tejas (dual core cpu) comes out you can drop that into your machine and be back to dual core goodness again.

If you prefer AMD, I'd say wait for the socket 939, go with a Newcastle chip (ie stay cheap for the time being), then get a dual core based FX chip when they come out in 2005 and drop that into your machine.

In either case, you'll have to make a slight compromise now, but you'll have the equipment in place to get exactly what you want 1 year from now. And in the meantime you won't drive your budget through the roof.

 
i did say i want to stay SMP... but i also challenged anybody who wanted to to convince me to go with a P4 HT... back when i built my old rig, dual P3s was hands down the way to go... things have changed a bit since then....


can someone explain the upgrade paths people keep talking about if i go w/ a P4? and what are these dual core chips? there's no way they'll be on the same chipset or socket as today's P4s, is there?

i understand that if i upgrade an SMP machine's CPUs i have to buy 2.. but wont opteron's probably stay on the socket 940 well into the future and let me upgrade as i do along?

i like SMP and im willing to pay a premium to stick with it (it just sounds cooler to say you have dual processors 😛) but there are also some drawbacks that didnt exist back in the dual P3 days.

will a P4 HT let me burn a DVD and play ut2k4 at the same time?

I want top performance across many, many applications (few of them need SMP, but i like to run alot of things at once). i want to be able to handle future software (like 64bit aware UT2k4 or windows 64 -- hence my leaning towards the opterons in the first place).. and i want to be future proof with easy upgrade paths (like replacing the chips in a year)

if the opterons only make sense at the higher clock speeds, i'd be up for buing one now (the 246?) and another later. but i can probably only afford the MSI mobo (about $200)... and i dont really intend to go SCSI... i'll stick with the raptors.

i really appreciate all the input. it's just a tough choice....

 
Back
Top