Poll: No Doubt vs. Talk Talk: Who sings "It's My Life" better?

Red Dawn

Elite Member
Jun 4, 2001
57,530
3
0
Originally posted by: BostonRedSox
I usually don't like remakes, but I must say No Doubt definately improved this song.
No they didn't. No Doubt has sucked since their second album.
 

duke

Golden Member
Nov 22, 1999
1,240
0
0
I like them both. Or I should say No Doubt did a very good cover.
 

Led Zeppelin

Diamond Member
Oct 15, 2002
3,555
0
71
Originally posted by: Red Dawn
Originally posted by: BostonRedSox
I usually don't like remakes, but I must say No Doubt definately improved this song.
No they didn't. No Doubt has sucked since their second album.

C'mon, you can't honestly say that TT's version is better than ND's. One of the other few remakes that I think is better is Pearl Jams "Last Kiss", over Frank Wilson and the Cavaliers, and Kim Wilde's "Keep Me Hanging On".
 

jcwagers

Golden Member
Dec 25, 2000
1,150
14
81
I think that in order to have a fair comparison.....we need a music video from Talk Talk to compete with the video from No Doubt. :) That said....I think the No Doubt one is cool.

jc
 

Ness

Diamond Member
Jul 10, 2002
5,407
2
0
Originally posted by: Red Dawn
Originally posted by: BostonRedSox
I usually don't like remakes, but I must say No Doubt definately improved this song.
No they didn't. No Doubt has sucked since their second album.


No Doubt hadn't been heard of until their 3rd or 4th album, Tragic Kingdom... If you are saying that album sucked, then I think it's safe to consider your opinion null and void.


On a side note, I've enjoyed all of No Doubt's albums. They are excellent in their own sort of way, and it doesn't sound like they just released the same album again.
 

Muadib

Lifer
May 30, 2000
17,916
838
126
Originally posted by: jcwagers
I think that in order to have a fair comparison.....we need a music video from Talk Talk to compete with the video from No Doubt. :) That said....I think the No Doubt one is cool.

jc

Talk talk had a video too. It had wild animals.:D
 

jcwagers

Golden Member
Dec 25, 2000
1,150
14
81
Yes....but it did NOT have some idiot getting fried in a bathtub by a hairdryer. :D The look on that guy's face was priceless.......much like the look on the other guy's face before she ran him into the gate. :D

jc