I'd take cable TV + dial up - it is far better than your other option. With over the air TV you cannot and will not get to see what you want - weather channel, most sports, movies, etc. And over the air quality sucks. You may be lucky to get 1 channel that is clear - and maybe 4-5 other fuzzy channels. So you are giving up quite a bit. But with the cable TV + dial up you still get everything you want. A 56K V.92 modem is plenty fast for the vast majority of uses - except downloading movies. And in that case just download the movies at a friend/work/school/library and then transfer it home. You don't miss a thing.