• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Poll: Best war movie...

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Im going to go with Saving Private Ryan since it was the first war movie i saw that i said, "Good freakin gravy, now thats a war movie!"
 
Originally posted by: Rogue
Anymal,

Perhaps you should read some of these stories from this reporter. This isn't the stuff that made mainstream media because it was too factual, not sensational enough to fit in a 15 second blurb.

http://www.kansas.com/mld/kansas/news/special_packages/extra/5647091.htm

Rogue - I am certainly not trying to discredit your brother, in fact let me be the first one here to say that I appreciate the courage and commitment that he and other soldiers displayed and all the sacrifices they made and continue to make. It's just it was so... I dunno, just hard to believe you know? Then again, stranger things have happened.
 
I second and third We Were Soldiers. Forgot all about that one. Still gotta read the book on that one too. Add We Were Soldiers please.

Oh, BTW, Sam Elliot stands as best depiction of a Sergeant Major in any movie. R. Lee Ermey will always be best Drill Sergeant/Instructor ever though.
 
although saving private ryan wins in the realism department, i think that in the movie trying to get the "war is hell" feeling across, platoon wins out.
 
FMJ hand's down. The only one that even comes close is Saving Private Ryan.

By the way, how come you don't have Windtalkers listed 😛
 
As a soldier myself, my training has taught me that it is entirely possible what was described. Perhaps you've seen too often where you drop someone in a similar fashion in a video game and they just go right down. If you read the book Black Hawk Down, you will understand this better. A problem they had in Somalia was that they were using armor piercing rounds of a small caliber and they could shoot a Somali 3, 4, 5 times or more and the round would go right through them, leaving a nice hole and they'd keep coming anyway. Adrenaline is a powerful drug. Do you remember the scene in the beach invasion in Saving Private Ryan? There was a part in there were a soldier reached down and picked up his own severed arm and carried it around. Severe trauma combined with unnatural events (war) and adrenaline make unbelievable things happen. Add in some powerful drugs such as cocaine and god knows what else those guys were on and you get some pretty hard to rationalize stuff. In my Combat Lifesaver classes, we were actually taught that a soldier may in fact lose an entire limb and continue to fight as if nothing happened until they bleed out. We were trained by a Combat Medic who saw time in just about every major conflict since Vietnam before he retired shortly after Desert Storm. He had similar stories, too many to recount. It does happen, it did happen the way he said it happened. There are less publicized articles on the 'net about Operation Iraqi Freedom if you look for them. They give you things like the first story I linked that you didn't hear on CNN, Fox, or MSNBC.

I'm not taking offense to your disbelief BTW. I am trying to let you know that what you seen in BHD, We Were Soldiers, Saving Private Ryan, etc. are very real and happen in real combat. Those things are not simply theatrical in nature to up the ante.
 
band of brothers, but that was a miniseries so...SPR otherwise, but i haven't seen patton yet
 
Originally posted by: HOWITIS
TORA! TORA! TORA! a superb war movie. my fave.

I like the look that Yamamoto has when he realizes that they bombed 55 minutes early. You can see defeat in his eyes.
 
Band Of Brothers even though It wasn't a movie. It was pretty much Saving Private Ryan with Soap Opera.
 
Originally posted by: Zebo
I can't believe Apoc is trailing with a measly 4%.....

Totally, you guys are lost. Apocalypse Now is easily the best movie on this list.

Edit: Most of the youngsters here probably haven't even seen it or "don't get it"
 
Back
Top