Originally posted by: bamacre
Originally posted by: jonnyGURU
Even if the concert featured the current Floyd w/o Waters, they'd still rock. Water's voice has gotten so rough over the last 20 years. Gilmour still plays and sounds like he has for the last 30 some years. Delicate Sound of Thunder is one of my all time favorites and by far my favorite live album and that's Floyd without Waters.
The last time I heard Roger Waters sound good was The Wall, and that was predominantly Roger Waters. But The Wall certainly isn't some of Pink Floyd's best work.
Actually I saw two shows during his "In the Flesh" tour, and I thought it all sounded great, two of the best concerts I've ever been to. I consider The Wall nothing less than pure brilliance, with Dark Side being the only album that I thoguht was better (although they were quite different, and not very comparable).