Pentium 4 3.0 vs Pentium D dual core

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

stevty2889

Diamond Member
Dec 13, 2003
7,036
8
81
Originally posted by: Stumps
just one question...what is the difference between the DS3 and S3?...i can't find any differences on Gigabytes website, however their is a considerable price difference here in Australia of nearly AU$70

The only differance is that the DS3 has solid capacitors, which supposedly helps with overclocking, although that doesn't seem to be the case, since the cheaper S3 usualy does as well, or better than the DS3.
 

Stumps

Diamond Member
Jun 18, 2001
7,125
0
0
Originally posted by: stevty2889
Originally posted by: Stumps
just one question...what is the difference between the DS3 and S3?...i can't find any differences on Gigabytes website, however their is a considerable price difference here in Australia of nearly AU$70

The only differance is that the DS3 has solid capacitors, which supposedly helps with overclocking, although that doesn't seem to be the case, since the cheaper S3 usualy does as well, or better than the DS3.

thank for that info :thumbsup:

 

DrMrLordX

Lifer
Apr 27, 2000
22,886
12,943
136
Originally posted by: Stumps
[
He already has a PCI-E Vid card and DDR2 so there is really no point with getting that motherboard.

There would be one point, and that is that it's ridiculously cheap.

Granted, it would do a poor job handling his DDR2 and his PCI-e video card. It could, but not elegantly.
 

Zombeh

Senior member
Dec 3, 2006
338
0
0
Originally posted by: Stumps
Originally posted by: DrMrLordX
If you want a real budget board for a Core 2 Duo, you can always go with this:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16813157092

He already has a PCI-E Vid card and DDR2 so there is really no point with getting that motherboard.

hid bet bet would be to get a P965 board ,i've heard good things about the Gigabyte model Myocardia listed.....but like I said before....his best bet would be to ask Duvie or Stevty2889, these guys know their stuff.


the only problem i have with that board is... has only 2 ddr2 slots and 2 ddr1, i need 4xddr2 :/ otherwise id be interested in it. it doesnt say its for c2d's either, but im assuming it is since it supports dual core p-d's. any other products for under say $80?

 

Stumps

Diamond Member
Jun 18, 2001
7,125
0
0
ewww ECS.....you would be better off with the Gigabyte mobo...SLI is a wank anyway.

but it's your money, feel free to blow it on garbage ECS motherboards if you want.
 

secretanchitman

Diamond Member
Apr 11, 2001
9,352
23
91
im guessing its a prescott p4...but if i had to pick only between those two, i would go for the pentium D. oh, the pentium D better be a 900 series processor too.

if not, you might want to make the jump to a core 2 duo E6300 (kicks the hell out of any pentium 4/D cpu overclocked or not).
 

Stumps

Diamond Member
Jun 18, 2001
7,125
0
0
what is wrong with ECS?

they suck....poor quality products and even poorer quality warranty(at least in Australia anyway).

If you are planning to go the C2D route don't be a tight wad when it comes to purchasing a mobo......get a decent mobo and the results will be really satisfying.

you should be able to get a decent overclock(if you are into that sort of thing....like the rest of us) using your P4 with the gigabyte motherboard....I'm sure that if you don't like gigabyte, Asus has some good motherboards as well.
 

Zombeh

Senior member
Dec 3, 2006
338
0
0
Well i'm not really into overclocking, ive never done it and i dont really have the need. i want my stuff to last longer.


- so heres another deal thats going through my head. i was thinking about getting this deal.


reason: well it's SLI (incase i wanna go dual 8800's), has the P-D (will hold me off on buying a core 2 duo for a while.) or is there really no difference in gaming and overall performance compared to my p4? should i save the $90 towards a new processor?
 

Stumps

Diamond Member
Jun 18, 2001
7,125
0
0
Firstly gaming wise a P-D will make very little if any difference in performance...getting a lower clocked P-D than your P4 will cause frame rate to be lower, you have to realise that a P-D is just 2 P4's on a single die...so clock for clock in single threaded applications(IE 99% of games) a 3ghz P-D is identicle to a 3ghz P4.

For me the cons of getting a P-D far out weigh any benifits you would get from the second core....sure some multi threaded application and generally multitasking will be slightly improved but the high temps can lead to a few problems(like overheating and clock throttling), especially if the ventilation in your case is very ordinary.

Secondly as I have already said and others have too, SLI is a huge wank..epsicially with a lower performing CPU like a P-D...and two video cards, especially higher end models can generate considerable amount of heat, which the could make an already overheating P-D problem worse...not to mention the beefy PSU requirered for SLI.

and last but not least...ewwww ECS....but you've already heard what I have to say about that.


If I was you and this is just a suggestion, I'm only trying to but you on the right path, I would get a could 965P motherboard, the Gigabyte one seems very popular...but really ask Duvie and Stevty2889 about a good motherboard they are more than willing to help you out, and just maybe get a decent HSF unit and overclock your P4...you should be able to get a decent boost out of it, probably more than what a stock P-D could do for your gaming.

And then save up a few pennies down the road and buy a C2D and a GF8800 and live happily ever after.

this is just my opinion.
 

Zombeh

Senior member
Dec 3, 2006
338
0
0
alright you talked me into it. i'm just going to get a mobo that supports both p4 and C2D. When quad-cores come out will they be skt 775 and fit in it too maybe?
 

myocardia

Diamond Member
Jun 21, 2003
9,291
30
91
Originally posted by: Zombeh
alright you talked me into it. i'm just going to get a mobo that supports both p4 and C2D. When quad-cores come out will they be skt 775 and fit in it too maybe?
Intel's quad-cores are already out, and yes, that S3 supports them: link.
 

Stumps

Diamond Member
Jun 18, 2001
7,125
0
0
Originally posted by: Zombeh
alright, should i buy now or after christmas?

hmmm not sure about the US, but here in Australia we usually get some decent deals right before christmas.

But I would say that at a guess, when ever you can afford it would be a good start :p
 

Stumps

Diamond Member
Jun 18, 2001
7,125
0
0
why???

that mobo doesn't support C2D, you would just be wasting your money.

Just save yourself some hassles, get a C2D mobo, run your P4 in it until you can afford a nice C2D cpu.

your P4 will still be sufficent for new games for at least the next year or so....hell even older AXP's (I still have a 3000+@2.33ghz and a 2800+ in my collection of PC's)can run games fine if you have a decent video card and enougth ram.

the case looks alright...
 

Zombeh

Senior member
Dec 3, 2006
338
0
0

I think because i'm waiting for a good deal, i know if i wait on a motherboard and cpu i'll save money. so if i get this and use it for a few monthes, prices will drop.