Paul McCartney or Keith Richards?

[Big-Empty]

I personally like Paul McCartney because of his vocal ability but I like Kieth Richards for defying all odds.

Paul McCartney with Wings had one of the worlds greatest and most well known song ever,that song being "Band on the Run". Fantastic song.Kieth Richards I can't say that about.

I agree with mmntech because I feel that Paul McCartney has more talent but I also feel that Kieth Richards is more real in a sense. Kieth has defyed the odds for a long time too,look at all the people he outlived!! Gary Coleman,Michael Jackson,Leslie Nielsen,Heath Ledger. He outlived all of them...somehow.

 

[ProfJohn]

Keith is all kinds of awesome and did some great guitar work in his younger days.

But Paul... Yesterday, Hey Jude, Get Back, Let It Be and a few dozen other great songs.

Paul wrote Love Me Do at age 16! Just an amazing talent.

 

[Anomaly1964]

Bono...

 

[Kirby]

Bono...

lmfao!

 

[preslove]

Paul McCartney with Wings had one of the worlds greatest and most well known song ever,that song being "Band on the Run". Fantastic song.Kieth Richards I can't say that about.

Really? That song sucks & all of McCartney's post-beatles catalog is a huge negative in this comparison.

 

[manimal]

the walrus was paul

 

[nageov3t]

I've never really understood the Rolling Stones' popularity.

Paul McCartney for sure. he's probably one of the most prolific musicians of the past century.

I have nothing but love for John Lennon, but Paul was probably the biggest driving talent behind The Beatles.

 

[Big-Empty]

Really? That song sucks & all of McCartney's post-beatles catalog is a huge negative in this comparison.

Thats your opinion. I and everyone I know love that song,so thats our opinion. You can say that but its simply what you think, and it doesn't change a thing.