Patriots a dynasty? I think not.

[Evdawg]

Congrats to patriots and brady, but i think that people are living in the moment too much. THey think brady is greatest QB etc etc. What are your thoughts?

 

[NathanBWF]

EDIT: NM

 

[JonnyBlaze]

hes better than your fav. teams qb

JB

 

[yobarman]

You really didn't explain why you don't think they're a dynasty. You pretty much made a blanket statement thats being discussed in a bigger thread than your tiny one.

 

[rgwalt]

3 wins in 4 years does not a dynasty make. Lets seem them do it again next year, and the next, and the next...

R

 

[b0mbrman]

I think Manning is a better regular season quarterback but Brady's got the rings...Similar to the Leinart vs. Rodgers debate in college football...

 

[rsd]

Originally posted by: rgwalt
3 wins in 4 years does not a dynasty make. Lets seem them do it again next year, and the next, and the next...

R

So who are the dynasties?

The Pats are only the 2nd team EVER to win 3/4.

What are the criteria exactly? Obviously there isn't a hard rule, but I think in this day of free agency and salary cap, they are absolutely a dynasty. In fact, there isn't really much to debate about that matter.

 

[Ynog]

You can argue the status of Brady's greatness.

But if the Patriots aren't a Dynasty, then neither were the 90's Cowboys or the 80's Niners.

 

[Passions]

Originally posted by: rgwalt
3 wins in 4 years does not a dynasty make. Lets seem them do it again next year, and the next, and the next...

R

Patriots are a dynasty in this day and age of free agency. :thumbsup:

 

[Freejack2]

Massachusetts is having a heck of a year sportswise, first the Sox and now the Patriots. Wonder if Boston had another "happy" riot again.

Edit: I do agree that so far the Patriots are a dynasty. If they win just a couple more games this decade you can bet the next decades they'll be recalling the Patriots as the first dynasty of the millenia.

 

[aplefka]

Repost.

Pats >= Dynasty

 

[Anubis]

Originally posted by: rgwalt
3 wins in 4 years does not a dynasty make. Lets seem them do it again next year, and the next, and the next...

R

seeing as the other team with 3 wins in 4 years is called a dynasty, i say you are wrong,

 

[Evdawg]

Originally posted by: yobarman
You really didn't explain why you don't think they're a dynasty. You pretty much made a blanket statement thats being discussed in a bigger thread than your tiny one.

I believe theyre a great team, indeed... but i think the patriots get it done... thats all they do. Cowboys had a lot of star players that made big big plays. How many insane plays did you see? Maybe 1 or 2 from the patriots... You must admit the game wasnt THAT exciting. Anyways, I think once again people are living in the moment. What about joe montana and the great 49'ers? John elway and the broncos?

I think people should step back, look at the situations, and look at the skills. (not that brady isnt skillfull at all, hes great.)

 

[Anubis]

Originally posted by: Freejack2
Massachusetts is having a heck of a year sportswise, first the Sox and now the Patriots. Wonder if Boston had another "happy" riot again.

it was fairly tame last night actually, people were out downtown in teh streets and such, but they had a billion cops there as well so it didnt get out of hand

 

[Anubis]

Originally posted by: Evdawg

Originally posted by: yobarman
You really didn't explain why you don't think they're a dynasty. You pretty much made a blanket statement thats being discussed in a bigger thread than your tiny one.

I believe theyre a great team, indeed... but i think the patriots get it done... thats all they do. Cowboys had a lot of star players that made big big plays. How many insane plays did you see? Maybe 1 or 2 from the patriots... You must admit the game wasnt THAT exciting. Anyways, I think once again people are living in the moment. What about joe montana and the great 49'ers? John elway and the broncos?

I think people should step back, look at the situations, and look at the skills. (not that brady isnt skillfull at all, hes great.)

the fact that they DID NOT have a bunch of superstar players but still managed to "get it done" is more proof of their greatness as a team

 

[Freejack2]

Originally posted by: Anubis

Originally posted by: Freejack2
Massachusetts is having a heck of a year sportswise, first the Sox and now the Patriots. Wonder if Boston had another "happy" riot again.

it was fairly tame last night actually, people were out downtown in teh streets and such, but they had a billion cops there as well so it didnt get out of hand

That's good. Still I'm glad I don't have to head out to Boston until tomorrow.

 

[Ilmater]

R (and don't tell me what to b1tch at you for and what NOT to b1tch at you for)

 

[Looney]

This thread sucks. Only because the OP started out with a sh1tty post.

 

[cmdavid]

Originally posted by: Evdawg
Congrats to patriots and brady, but i think that people are living in the moment too much. THey think brady is greatest QB etc etc. What are your thoughts?

wow.. thats a very very convincing argument i must say...

 

[Evdawg]

Originally posted by: Anubis

Originally posted by: Evdawg

Originally posted by: yobarman
You really didn't explain why you don't think they're a dynasty. You pretty much made a blanket statement thats being discussed in a bigger thread than your tiny one.

I believe theyre a great team, indeed... but i think the patriots get it done... thats all they do. Cowboys had a lot of star players that made big big plays. How many insane plays did you see? Maybe 1 or 2 from the patriots... You must admit the game wasnt THAT exciting. Anyways, I think once again people are living in the moment. What about joe montana and the great 49'ers? John elway and the broncos?

I think people should step back, look at the situations, and look at the skills. (not that brady isnt skillfull at all, hes great.)

the fact that they DID NOT have a bunch of superstar players but still managed to "get it done" is more proof of their greatness as a team

I don't know about yall.. but i sure as hell woudl rather watch the 90's cowboys or the 80's 49'ers play the patriots today... or hell, any team for that matter. Agreed?

 

[Evdawg]

Originally posted by: cmdavid

Originally posted by: Evdawg
Congrats to patriots and brady, but i think that people are living in the moment too much. THey think brady is greatest QB etc etc. What are your thoughts?

wow.. thats a very very convincing argument i must say...

it was weak because i had to quickly edit the post befor ei got flamed.. i accidentally hit enter after i typed in the topic

 

[RagingBITCH]

Originally posted by: Evdawg

Originally posted by: Anubis

Originally posted by: Evdawg

Originally posted by: yobarman
You really didn't explain why you don't think they're a dynasty. You pretty much made a blanket statement thats being discussed in a bigger thread than your tiny one.

I believe theyre a great team, indeed... but i think the patriots get it done... thats all they do. Cowboys had a lot of star players that made big big plays. How many insane plays did you see? Maybe 1 or 2 from the patriots... You must admit the game wasnt THAT exciting. Anyways, I think once again people are living in the moment. What about joe montana and the great 49'ers? John elway and the broncos?

I think people should step back, look at the situations, and look at the skills. (not that brady isnt skillfull at all, hes great.)

the fact that they DID NOT have a bunch of superstar players but still managed to "get it done" is more proof of their greatness as a team

I don't know about yall.. but i sure as hell woudl rather watch the 90's cowboys or the 80's 49'ers play the patriots today... or hell, any team for that matter. Agreed?

That doesn't not make them a dynasty if they're "less enjoyable" to watch.

 

[Anubis]

Originally posted by: Evdawg

Originally posted by: Anubis

Originally posted by: Evdawg

Originally posted by: yobarman
You really didn't explain why you don't think they're a dynasty. You pretty much made a blanket statement thats being discussed in a bigger thread than your tiny one.

I believe theyre a great team, indeed... but i think the patriots get it done... thats all they do. Cowboys had a lot of star players that made big big plays. How many insane plays did you see? Maybe 1 or 2 from the patriots... You must admit the game wasnt THAT exciting. Anyways, I think once again people are living in the moment. What about joe montana and the great 49'ers? John elway and the broncos?

I think people should step back, look at the situations, and look at the skills. (not that brady isnt skillfull at all, hes great.)

the fact that they DID NOT have a bunch of superstar players but still managed to "get it done" is more proof of their greatness as a team

I don't know about yall.. but i sure as hell woudl rather watch the 90's cowboys or the 80's 49'ers play the patriots today... or hell, any team for that matter. Agreed?

no i dont agree

 

[Evdawg]

Originally posted by: Anubis

Originally posted by: Evdawg

Originally posted by: Anubis

Originally posted by: Evdawg

Originally posted by: yobarman
You really didn't explain why you don't think they're a dynasty. You pretty much made a blanket statement thats being discussed in a bigger thread than your tiny one.

I believe theyre a great team, indeed... but i think the patriots get it done... thats all they do. Cowboys had a lot of star players that made big big plays. How many insane plays did you see? Maybe 1 or 2 from the patriots... You must admit the game wasnt THAT exciting. Anyways, I think once again people are living in the moment. What about joe montana and the great 49'ers? John elway and the broncos?

I think people should step back, look at the situations, and look at the skills. (not that brady isnt skillfull at all, hes great.)

the fact that they DID NOT have a bunch of superstar players but still managed to "get it done" is more proof of their greatness as a team

I don't know about yall.. but i sure as hell woudl rather watch the 90's cowboys or the 80's 49'ers play the patriots today... or hell, any team for that matter. Agreed?

no i dont agree

why? I mean youre entitled to your opinion.. i just dont understand, i was somewhat bored with the superbowl, i never saw any REAL exciting plays.

 

[Feldenak]

Originally posted by: Evdawg

Originally posted by: Anubis

Originally posted by: Evdawg

Originally posted by: yobarman
You really didn't explain why you don't think they're a dynasty. You pretty much made a blanket statement thats being discussed in a bigger thread than your tiny one.

I believe theyre a great team, indeed... but i think the patriots get it done... thats all they do. Cowboys had a lot of star players that made big big plays. How many insane plays did you see? Maybe 1 or 2 from the patriots... You must admit the game wasnt THAT exciting. Anyways, I think once again people are living in the moment. What about joe montana and the great 49'ers? John elway and the broncos?

I think people should step back, look at the situations, and look at the skills. (not that brady isnt skillfull at all, hes great.)

the fact that they DID NOT have a bunch of superstar players but still managed to "get it done" is more proof of their greatness as a team

I don't know about yall.. but i sure as hell woudl rather watch the 90's cowboys or the 80's 49'ers play the patriots today... or hell, any team for that matter. Agreed?

I disagree. I like watching consistant, steady teams just get it done.