That's where my age issue comes into play. I don't think a lot of that really imprints on kids under the age of 8 or 10. After that the benefits start to become much more tangible and productive. But that's just my opinion.
Wrong.
I am a parent and a coach and ref ... this all starts with the parents and the league/group you are involved with for that sport.
My son is 8 (as of this month) and started playing in a local soccer league when he was 4 (2 seasons a year Fall and Spring). I started coaching his second season in the league. My daughter (soon to be 11 ... YIKES!!) plays as well but only 1 season a year.
As a parent I think it is great so long as the child is interested and the league/group you are involved in is not too competitive. The soccer club we are in keeps no scores, does no trophies, and is not pushy in any way on the REC level. They do have a Travel program that is competitive but not fanatically so.
What my kids have learned from this is that you have to work together as a team and sportsmanship. While there are some "overly competitive" parents in the league most of it is very happy go lucky and supportive of the kids.
As a coach I think it is very important as well ... all the kids I coach (not just my own) learn basic soccer skills (it's all I have LOL) but more importantly they learn teamwork, responsibility, and sportsmanship. My teams are always well behaved, work hard, and most importantly have a lot of fun out there. The kids keep score on their own which you just cannot stop but if they get caught teasing or bragging I pull them from the game. That's not what it is about. Some parents don't like it when I do this but most are very happy about it and typically I get 1/2 - 3/4 of the same kids back each season (the remainder usually move up to the Advanced Teams or Travel).
What does suck is the scheduling. We only practice once a week ( x 2 since I have 2 kids in 2 different age groups). Then there is 1 game per Sat for 7 weeks for each kid. The Sat games are all at the same field but tend to be spread apart (anywhere from 1 hour to 3 hours in between games) so in season our Saturdays are kind shot. Fortunately we live about 15 mins from where we play and practice so its not too bad.
I can tell you that there are many kids that do TOO MUCH (ie play something all year round - soccer, baseball, football, basketball etc etc) and that is ridiculous and does tend to be about getting the kid all over the place and no family time. We will never be this way. Also some sports (can you say Football) are so ridiculously competitive than arguments routinely breakout in the stands, coaches scream and yell, many kids ride the bench for the whole season in favor of the stars, and worse yet many kids get downright abused on the field physically, mentally, and emotionally. This is what I have a problem with in league sports.
For anyone to bash league sports "unilaterally" is wrong. Are there bad leagues, bad people ... yes. But there are some good ones out there as well and you have to find the ones that work for you (locality and philosophy wise).
I think in the right organization it is very good and important for the kids ... in the wrong one ... no it is not.
Greg