Originally posted by: Lemon law
Originally posted by: palehorse
Do you think we'd argue against such strikes?! Hell no! It sounds great to me! It's about damn time your military starts to do something proactive besides sitting in their bases launching indiscriminate artillery shells into the hills.
Then again, unlike Pakistan, all you really need to do is give us the coordinates, and any Taliban we find at the locations are as good as dead! (What happens when we provide Pakistan with coordinates for AQ or Taliban bases? Those bases "mysteriously" relocate within hours... profound difference, I'd say)
But yeah, it's nice to see your guys getting motivated to really fight... are you planning to sign up and help TGB?
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Wonderful plan, just the way to get 100% of the people in Afghanistan and Pakistan to support the Tailban. Because it would only create even more anarchy and almost 100% of the Nato and Pakistani military retaliation would fall on civilians while making the whole region into a shooting gallery.
Get a clue, the Taliban is a reactionary idea and a ideological cure for Western abuses, and as such, the only way to defeat an idea is present a better and more viable idea. We have failed because we have not even started to implement those
ideas or make them viable, and we are playing into the Taliban's characterization of us by trying to kill our way out of the problem.
What those people above all want is an orderly society, and what we have given them is corruption, chaos, and a broken government for seven years now. And in areas under Taliban control, they at least know that some sort of justice prevails. And the rich and more corrupt don't get richer in a system where everything works by bribes. Can't pay the bribe money, and you own nothing.
Yes I agree, the Taliban do not fit into a modern world, but they better fit the world of the Afghans and those in the Pakistani tribal regions than Nato does. But cheer up, the world Nato has created in Afghanistan allows Nato to function militarily, but it makes political progress or social progress impossible. And also explains why our military leadership does not have these grim realities on their radar screen, but in the ideological battle for hearts and minds, our understanding compass is pointed 180 degrees off of true North and has been for seven years running.
Its why we in Nato and the USA are losing, and there is something very wrong with that picture. And its been my thesis, for four years running now on P&N, until we get our radar screens focused on what we need to do to win, we will keep failing. Petraeus has said it quite clearly, we can't kill our way out of the problem. But that statement does little to implement anything, but it does show how wrong many on this forum are.