Outpost.com 80gig WD drive and rebate IS A SCAM PLEASE READ MY EXPERIENCE

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

wasssup

Diamond Member
Nov 28, 2000
3,142
0
0
I hate outpost. Before flooz.com died, I had placed a few preorders...outpost successfully took the funds out of my flooz account. Five weeks later when flooz dies, outpost cancels my orders claiming they were going to refund the money to flooz (bull$hit..why the hell would anyone refund money to a company that just filed for bankrupcy).

They also have the dumbest CSR's I have ever dealt with...

 

rj2828

Member
Sep 28, 2001
59
0
0
I got in on this deal - and what a deal it is!

My thoughts:

Fraud-

Dunno if you can accuse Outpost of fraud on this one - serious incompetence maybe, but not fraud. Way more people have received the retail drives (non-refurbs) than those who received OEM packaged drives. The initial people who got refurbs weren't given any run around - they were told they'd be provided with new retail drives.

Service-

Outpost was never the best at customer service - but ever since Fry's acquisition of them, they've gotten worse. Still - on par with many retailers. They ship fast, and have a fair return policy. Also - I have no doubt that you could fight the charge with your credit card company, and Outpost wouldn't put up too much resistance.

Value-

My drive cost was $44 after PM and rebate - if the rebate comes through. If not - then I'll look into BB claims against Outpost. I'll give them the benefit of a doubt for now, since they've never screwed me before. My opinion would be different if they had.

Risk versus reward-

It's worth the risk - it's a $125 drive (at bare minimum, after shipping) and you're getting it for $40-60. Half price is worth the risk, especially with the protection provided by credit cards.

My $0.02,
-rj
 

smf96822

Member
Apr 4, 2002
83
0
0


<< I got in on this deal - and what a deal it is!

My thoughts:

Fraud-

Dunno if you can accuse Outpost of fraud on this one - serious incompetence maybe, but not fraud. Way more people have received the retail drives (non-refurbs) than those who received OEM packaged drives. The initial people who got refurbs weren't given any run around - they were told they'd be provided with new retail drives.


The fact that as you say people that received refurbs got them replaced with retail boxes speaks volumes about outpost behaviour to me and to ?others. Yes indeed they told me a mistake had been made and the customer service guy put in the computer (as we spoke) the request for the correct drive to be sent. Apparently the higher level people decided these replacements(corrections) would no longer be fulfilled and perhaps programmed their system to NOT send retail boxes. The second time I spoke to Marc(customer service) to tell him they had sent me the same drive, he sung a different tune, telling me clearly they would not send the correct drive. I don't need to be a genius to figure out the second tier had spoken with the first tier.

A friend purchased this for me and in gratitude I did a bit of computer troubleshooting/reconfiguring. Now as if the initial favor were not enough, that person must spend additional time in correctinve action. I am embarrased and feel like a heel. First their time, then my time on the phone with outpost, western digital, a drive to mail the initial drive back. Perhaps while involved in all this I lost the opportunity to get a comparable deal on a different drive.


I have had the opportunity to consult with parties well versed with business tactics and the "bait and no rebate" is a favorite with some management, sadly enough.

Outpost should have just cancelled the deal publicly via their website.

To add insult to injury, outpost actually e maild me a rebate attachment to go along with the replacement drive received today. Below is copied and pasted. first the email with attachment 3006469.pdf . immediately below it is the copy/paste of rebate. I guess the lower level customer service legitimately thought outpost would honor their word.

I wonder if Western Digital condones these business practices. Perhaps I should share the info with them.



From :
Marc Frasca <MFrasca@outpost.com>

To :
"'steve96822@hotmail.com'" <steve96822@hotmail.com>

Subject :
Western Digital 80GB Rebate

Date :
Tue, 9 Apr 2002 17:29:22 -0400

Attachment : 3006469.pdf (87k) see below
=================================================
Buy a Western Digital 80 GB 7200 RPM
retail packaged hard drive from Fry?s
Electronics and get $55 cash back from
Western Digital.
Offer valid only at Fry?s Electronics 4/5/02 thru 4/11/02.
Requests must be postmarked within 14 days from the date
of purchase.
See other side for details
Get $55 Cash Back
$5500
Mail-in Rebate
U.S. DOLLARS
WD 80 GB/ FE $55 MIR
P.O. Box 3207
Young America, MN 55558-3207
Western Digital capacity label
as proof of purchase
MAIL TO
To receive your $55.00 rebate:
Purchase a Western Digital 80 GB 7200 RPM retail packaged hard drive (WD800BBRTL) from Fry?s Electronics
during the promotional period of 4/5/02 to 4/11/02.
Offer valid on the applicable product specified on this rebate form and must be postmarked within
14 days from the date of purchase and received no later than 5/11/02. Any requests postmarked or
received after applicable dates will be returned as ineligible. Receipt must include a date that corresponds
within the promotional period. No reproduction of capacity label accepted. Requests from groups, post office
boxes or organizations will not be honored. Western Digital is not responsible for late, lost, misdirected or
postage due mail. If terms and conditions are not met, rebate will not be sent. Incomplete or illegible
submissions will be returned. Keep copies of the capacity label, receipt and rebate form for your records.
All materials submitted will become Western Digital property and will not be returned. Rebate checks are void
if not cashed within 90 days of issuance and cannot be reissued. Offer is limited to one rebate check per
customer/name/address. Fraudulent submission of multiple requests could result in federal prosecution
under US Mail Fraud Statutes (18 USC, sections 1341 and 1342). Offer good only in USA and Canada. Void
where prohibited, taxed or restricted by law. Inquiries regarding this offer received later than 90 days after
the expiration date of this promotion will not be acknowledged. Please allow 6 to 8 weeks, after receipt of
rebate request, for processing. If you have not received your rebate after 8 weeks, please call 888.292.0667.
 The completed WD rebate request form.
&#10103; The original WD capacity label from
your Western Digital 80 GB 7200 RPM
retail packaged hard drive box as proof
of purchase.
&#10104; A copy of your purchase receipt dated
April 5, 2002 to April 11, 2002.
(Please retain original receipt for your records.)
SUBMIT PLEASE PRINT LEGIBLY
Name
Address
(P.O. boxes not accepted)
City State
Zip Phone
E-mail
SAMPL
E




Service-

Outpost was never the best at customer service - but ever since Fry's acquisition of them, they've gotten worse. Still - on par with many retailers. They ship fast, and have a fair return policy. Also - I have no doubt that you could fight the charge with your credit card company, and Outpost wouldn't put up too much resistance.

Value-

My drive cost was $44 after PM and rebate - if the rebate comes through. If not - then I'll look into BB claims against Outpost. I'll give them the benefit of a doubt for now, since they've never screwed me before. My opinion would be different if they had.

Risk versus reward-

It's worth the risk - it's a $125 drive (at bare minimum, after shipping) and you're getting it for $40-60. Half price is worth the risk, especially with the protection provided by credit cards.

My $0.02,
-rj
>>

 

smf96822

Member
Apr 4, 2002
83
0
0


<<

<< Your message

To: services@outpost.com
Sent: Thu, 11 Apr 2002 17:32:56 -0400

did not reach the following recipient(s):
>>

Maybe that's bc the actual address is "service@outpost.com" not "services@outpust.com" ;)
>>





Be that the case I offer my full apology to affected parties.
 

Fritzo

Lifer
Jan 3, 2001
41,920
2,161
126
Hmmm, Outpost has always been one of my favorite retailers. I've never had a problem with them, customer service has always recitified problems, and I like the fact that their UPS ground shipping always gets to me in 1-2 days (their warehouse is like 150 miles from here :) ). Must just be lucky I guess.
 

labgeek

Platinum Member
Jan 20, 2002
2,163
0
0
>...The fact that as you say people that received refurbs got them replaced with retail boxes speaks volumes about outpost behaviour to me...

The refurbs were in RETAIL boxes. This was WD fault not Outposts. It was admitted by WD to be thier mixup. So it says NOTHING about Outpost's behaviour.


Call them back. Ask to speak to a supervisor or manager. Explain to them that they had advertised a retail drive, and the you got the OEM. Tell them that it is "unacceptable" (actually use that word - it leps to set in thier mind that you will not be swayed from your position without putting them on the defensive). Be calm. Listen when they speak - don't try to talk over them. Don't ever yell at them. Remain calm but persistant. If you find yourself getting angry (from your messages above their's a definite hint of anger in your tone), ask to speak to thier manager - don't be ugly about it. Just simply tell them they cannot help you, and you would like to speak to thier boss - be nice! Keep going up if you have to. At some point, you won't be able to get to a higher up. Unfortunately, in most companies it's pretty quick. In a good company you should be able to go all the way up to the top but that rarely happens. When you hit that wall, if they are still unwilling to fix this calmly tell them "OK, you will simply have to go to your credit card company and do a charge-back on it. And that you will be following that with letters to (their state) and (your state)'s Attorneys General's office, as well as the Better Business Bureau." I'd leave out the FTC unless you really think this is a widespread con that they're meaning to pull. Not likely on a company that size - too much to lose. More likely its incompetance. Don't make it sound like a threat, just state it matter of factly. Try your hardest to keep your emotions out of it. If you start getting angry and start yelling, threatening, etc., they will go on the defensive and you will get no-where. I used to be in retail management - I know how the game is played.

I ran a toy store for a while... I once refused a refund on motorized car. Customer claimed they bought last week, and it wasn't working anymore. It looked like they bought it 2 years before, and had run over it multiple times with the family pickup... I hadn't sold any of that particular model in 3 months. They customer called my boss, the chain's owner, and he authorized the return... I still refused to take it out of my store Profit/Loss statement, and xfer'ed the item/charge back to him as well as the cost of the new one (actually made out like 1 was sold - helped my p/l). And he was quite embarrassed when he saw the shape it was in. But the customer won because they remained calm and played the game.

I also worked in a major electronics chain - 2 words - second word sounds like the name of a famous basketball player's nickname. The customer played the game there, and we took back a satellite dish from Honduras with BULLET HOLES in it... Charged that one to the regional manager's store...

 

Shagger

Golden Member
Feb 12, 2001
1,046
0
0
What team is the famous player on and is he over 300 lbs?

The customer played the game there, and we took back a satellite dish from Honduras with BULLET HOLES in it... Charged that one to the regional manager's store...

Hmmm - I wonder how you can refurb a dish with bullet holes in it... Were they .22 cal or .45 cal bullets?
Maybe use a little aluminum foil...
 

Shagger

Golden Member
Feb 12, 2001
1,046
0
0
One more question - What was the customers rationale for the need for a replacement dish?
The dish was flawed because it wasn't bulletproof?
 

tazmania99

Golden Member
Mar 19, 2001
1,644
0
0
Why not simply just return it for refund if you are not satisfied? You are not gonna lose anything.
 

labgeek

Platinum Member
Jan 20, 2002
2,163
0
0
He plays for the Lakers, is over 300, and wears a size 22 shoe.

Holes looked too big to be .22s I would think, but I'm no expert on bullet holes.

They wanted to return it because it didn't work anymore. Apparently they believed the warranty should cover bullets hitting it.

As for refurbing it, aluminum foil would be bad. Don't even paint your dish with high gloss paint. The reflected heat from sunlight can overheat the LNB. As far as I know, the dish is still sitting in the regional manager's store. Was when I left the company way back when...

 

JustMichael

Member
Aug 4, 2000
45
0
0
I have just two questions: Did Outpost.com state the drive was a retail model? If not, why would you be expecting one?
 

Hgabriel

Golden Member
Dec 13, 2000
1,053
0
0
Ummm, this is clearly fraud. After attempts made by the consumer to remedy the situation, Outpost did nothing but return the original drive returned for replacement. Perhaps it was an employee error and an additional claim should be made to a 'MANAGER' at outpost. I think if you speak with a Manager and describe your situation, they would quickly send you the correct drive.

1) Make sure your receipt says retail drive or that the product number matches up to a retail item with WD.
2) Talk to Outpost management.
3) If steps 1 and 2 are ignored by Outpost, then contact the states attorney in California.
 

smf96822

Member
Apr 4, 2002
83
0
0
Friday Update;


re: J450684800011

Dear Steve/Management,

This will confirm our telephone conversation today regarding the above order, continuing dilemma.
Thank you for assuring me the label off the oem WD 80 gig 7200rpm drive is valid and will be honored for the rebate and that you haven't had problems with such a label used for rebate purposes.
I am deeply saddened though by your refusal to e mail me a simple reiteration of this.
Thank you for informing me that the drive ordered is an IDE while the rebate specific drive is not but an ATA U100 and this is also the reason why the rebate does not apply. Strange though how later on in our conversation you said the rebate is valid.
Again there continues to be gaps in the understanding of issues pertinent in this matter, namely as I spoke with a supervisor at WD Rebate Dept. named Kelley. Kelley asked me for the PO Box on the rebate form and was clear in that the only valid label for the rebate is the one depicted on the rebate form, the capacity sticker on the retain box.
You also questioned the credibility of anandtechforum posters that claimed they actually received retail boxed drives as to your knowledge few if any retail boxed drives were sent.
Although the purchaser has an Asian name, yes she does speak English contrary to the question you posed.
I did supply you with her telephone number XXX XXX XXXX
We look forward to hearing from you.

Steve Friedman/Yaling Yuu
 

MrPhelps

Golden Member
Sep 9, 2001
1,421
0
0
Although the purchaser has an Asian name, yes she does speak English contrary to the question you posed



LOL:)
 

smf96822

Member
Apr 4, 2002
83
0
0


<< Ummm, this is clearly fraud. After attempts made by the consumer to remedy the situation, Outpost did nothing but return the original drive returned for replacement. Perhaps it was an employee error and an additional claim should be made to a 'MANAGER' at outpost. I think if you speak with a Manager and describe your situation, they would quickly send you the correct drive.

1) Make sure your receipt says retail drive or that the product number matches up to a retail item with WD.


Receipt says WD 80gb 7200 UDMA/100 EIDE Hard Drive, nothing more nothing less. I have indeed bought oem drives before and I knew they were OEM because the vendor stated it on the web/invoice. In this case Outpost charged 184 dollars for the drive, and have a nenticing rebate to boot.
What is happening is outpost does not mind shipping OEM's at Retail box prices although the customer believes they are getting the rebate valid drive. They even told me the OEM box rebate will be honored by WD but refused to put their mouth where their money is by emailing me the same statement. I wonder if the person I spoke with 1)really believes this 2) Must say this per management 3) saying anything to get me to keep the drive and get off his case. (see post titled "Friday Update"

Today I spoke with a supervisor at WD rebate dept that told me clearly the oem label is not valid for the rebate. I was told that WD is not responsible for the behaviour of its vendors. I asked ; If WD had knowledge of fraudulent vendor activities would it then care? The answer was yes.



2) Talk to Outpost management.



I have requested this but was not put through to management. They said I would be contacted within 24 hours. Today is the target for their callback, I am in Hawaii, it is past 5PM on the east coast where the agent said the offices were.

3) If steps 1 and 2 are ignored by Outpost, then contact the states attorney in California.
>>




The question is where are they incorporated? In which state as they tell me Ohio, and another east coast state. No mention when I asked them of CA.

What I thought would be a simple order from a reputable company has turned into a nighmare of telephone calls, e mails. My to date result is drive and a long wait at the post office (I guess tax season related) and the pleasure to pay additional shipping charges.




I will keep everyone posted in this saga.

Steve
 

smf96822

Member
Apr 4, 2002
83
0
0


<< I have just two questions: Did Outpost.com state the drive was a retail model? If not, why would you be expecting one? >>






1) Is it a reasonable assumption that at 184 dollars and the lack of specific and very important OEM disclaimer anywhere (on url or invoice) that it is a retail boxed drive?
 

Athena

Golden Member
Apr 9, 2001
1,484
0
0
«Ummm, this is clearly fraud.»

Get real, it is clearly not fraud. A commercial failure to perform is not automatically fraud; fraud implies an intention to deceive and there is no evidence whatsoever that Outpost intended anything but to offer new, retail Western Digital drives. Anyone who is not satisified with what he received or Outpost offers for restitution should pack it up, request a return authorization and get a refund -- end of story.

Personally, I'm a happy camper. My April 1 order was put on backorder and shipped on the 8th. I received it today with a packing slip that shows both dates. I will be mailing the $75 rebate coupon tomorrow (12 days after the purchase date) and my Amex claim is in the works. It was definitely a good deal for me.
 

Bob/NYC

Golden Member
Oct 9, 1999
1,278
0
0
Retail Model # 3006489 $199, or $179(now) depending when bought w/rebate.
Says Retail and has retail model # Detailed Description (Manufacturer # WD800BBRTL 80GB BOX).
Retail 80G

=============================================================
OEM Model # 3031739 $184 now, no rebate. Doesn't say OEM, but gives OEM model # Detailed Description (Manufacturer# WD800BB 80GB UDMA100).
OEM Drive


If you paid $184, you bought an OEM drive. The added RTL in the model # is retail, although drives are all marked the same. My retail receipts don't say retail, or ...RTL.
 

TranceNation

Platinum Member
Jan 6, 2001
2,041
0
0


<< Although the purchaser has an Asian name, yes she does speak English contrary to the question you posed



LOL:)
>>




hehe, I thought that was funny also.
 

smf96822

Member
Apr 4, 2002
83
0
0


<<

<<

<< I already got my WD 80GB from outpost... it was a retail... and it was new. I sent in the rebate on Monday and my AMEX Blue PM was already authorized. No problems so far assuming the rebate comes. Total cost $42 shipped! >>





Congratulations as one of the lucky ones.
>>




I can't tell if you are being sarcastic... but I didn't mean to throw it in your face. I just wanted to point out that quite a few of us had no (or only minor) problems. Right in the beginning when a couple people received refurbs, my order was put on hold but when it was fufilled a few days later it came through fine. It sucks that it takes so much time but I'm pretty confident if you go high enough up at Outpost the should be able to resolve your problem so you get the same deal I did (assuming you bought it with an AMEX). Good Luck.
>>





No not at all. I sincerely congratulate you. Now I will add sarcasm; Are you sure you are not too sensitive a person to be on this forum?


Regards
 

smf96822

Member
Apr 4, 2002
83
0
0


<< Retail Model # 3006489 $199, or $179(now) depending when bought w/rebate.
Says Retail and has retail model # Detailed Description (Manufacturer # WD800BBRTL 80GB BOX).
Retail 80G

=============================================================
OEM Model # 3031739 $184 now, no rebate. Doesn't say OEM, but gives OEM model # Detailed Description (Manufacturer# WD800BB 80GB UDMA100).
OEM Drive


If you paid $184, you bought an OEM drive. The added RTL in the model # is retail, although drives are all marked the same. My retail receipts don't say retail, or ...RTL.
>>



================================================================================================

How does the average person readily know these things? Even given the benefit of the doubt, the second unit they shipped me(replacement unit) was accompanied with an email from outpost with a pdf attachment The 55 dollar rebate that is worthless(see thread for cc). I guess I can use it as toilet paper.
 

smf96822

Member
Apr 4, 2002
83
0
0
Update;

Despite being given the purchasers tel # Outpost hadn't called so she called them.

The outpost last position was that if they re-ship the retail boxed drive now she will have already fallen out of the rebate timeframe limits.


An RMA was obtained as it was clear that no headway would be made with outpost.


It amazes me how outpost finds it preferible to deal with possible inquiries etc from the state attny general, Western Digital Corporate, and/or FTC regarding allegations of interstate "bait and no rebate" then ship one retail hard drive and honor THEIR OWN REBATE.

The drive being sent back does not impact the principle of the matter nor what may be construed as deceptive business practices.

I will not be the judge of that, it will up to appropriate state, private, and federal authorities.

Have a nice weekend.

 

smf96822

Member
Apr 4, 2002
83
0
0


<<

<< I have just two questions: Did Outpost.com state the drive was a retail model? If not, why would you be expecting one? >>






1) Is it a reasonable assumption that at 184 dollars and the lack of specific and very important OEM disclaimer anywhere (on url or invoice) that it is a retail boxed drive?
>>





In addition if you do a quick check at pricewatch.com you will see that OEM's WD80/7200 typically are available for 110-120.

With this in mind, why would anyone in their right mind pay 184 were it not for incentive offers.