We didn’t initially consider Apple’s Airport Extreme for our article, as it didn’t even make the top three on SmallNetBuilder’s AC1750 router benchmarks. However, feedback from the Apple crowd has convinced us to give Apple’s Airport Extreme the same shakedown that we gave our finalists.
The results? The router did well across all our benchmark tests, but its price-to-performance ratio didn’t blow away our top pick, nor our step-down pick. Even though the Airport Extreme was easy to set up and comes with a few Apple-exclusive features, the router’s high price, limited feature loadout compared to most other routers, and the fact that it doesn’t play very nicely with Windows computers makes it a poor value for the majority of users (Apple-enthusiasts included).
If you already own a lot of Apple products, want a dead-simple setup process, and are willing to pay top dollar for fewer features and less flexibility, the Apple Extreme might be for you. Otherwise, we’re just not that fired up about Apple’s wireless-ac offering.