Okay, so in The Goblet of Fire

Dec 27, 2001
11,272
1
0
Seems if there's a spell to turn something into a ferret it wouldn't much matter if it was a dragon. Right? The you could chase it around trying to smash it with your broom until it climbed behind some rocks or something.
 

Lorax

Golden Member
Apr 14, 2000
1,658
0
0
if you're really going to talk about logical inconsistencies in Harry Potter....
 
Dec 27, 2001
11,272
1
0
Originally posted by: Lorax
if you're really going to talk about logical inconsistencies in Harry Potter....

Dude, I've watched these things 2-3 times a day for the past few weeks. I have a three year old.
 

Illusions89

Senior member
Mar 21, 2006
261
0
0
haha i understand.....My Niece likes watching Harry Potter....i watch it with her whenever i babysit her.....But yeah id have to say that dragons are immune to magic.....if they werent...wouldnt you think that the people would have tried that already.....Gah i really dont know....but thats my guess
 

Beller0ph1

Golden Member
Apr 18, 2003
1,302
0
76
<geek>Here are two things about simply turning a dragon into something else. The first is stated above...dragonskin is pretty much impervious to magic, physical damage, whatever. The second thing is that transfiguration at their age is really hard. I don't even know if Mcgonagall can do that! </geek>

Wow...sometimes I even surprise myself.
 

HaxorNubcake

Golden Member
Jun 23, 2004
1,983
0
0
Originally posted by: HeroOfPellinor
Originally posted by: Lorax
if you're really going to talk about logical inconsistencies in Harry Potter....

Dude, I've watched these things 2-3 times a day for the past few weeks. I have a three year old.

relevance? don't even bother questioning things in the film unless you have some nifty time shifter things that provide you with an infinite amount of time.
 

sandmanwake

Golden Member
Feb 29, 2000
1,494
0
0
Contrary to popular beliefs, dragons are not immune to magic dispite being magical creatures themselves. The noted wizard, Diambert, once transformed a creature of magic into a frog once--a feat thought impossible at the time by most modern wizards. Diambert had to combine a summoning with the transformation spell to accomplish this and was quite drained by the experience. It was not an easy task and Diambert only came up with the method of transformation by accident. I would assume that being a magical creature also, spell casting on dragons, while possible, would be at least equally difficult if not more so. Considering that some species of dragons are quite intelligent and are spell casters themselves, for students like Mr. Potter to be able to cast a spell strong enough to subdue any dragon via transformation was highly unlikely.