I don't think I am very familiar with where you come from with your posts, but I know that recently I have seen something about your posts that has suggested I might find your views personally interesting. I must say this one rather adds to that feeling. I can't recall anybody approaching my viewpoint is quite the same, I think rather rational, way that you do here. Let me see then if I can address your points:
pmy: Even though this sort of psychologising is valid in many cases, it can also often be a luxury for those with security and power. People might not care about the psychological roots of bigotry if they are in real danger from the bigots.
M: Indeed, but my post was about a poll and not about a genocidal action. I was trying to address the fact that a polarized situation requires two opposite and generally extreme attitudes that feed off each other thus escalating. I was trying to say to the liberal side of the equation, the side I feel has the best chance to apply reason and suppress the bias of emotion, that they risk becoming as irrational as their opposition.
pny: It also completely ignores the social and political dimension. Not everything is about internal psychological traits, we exist in a social context that helps determine the costs and benefits for people of taking different attitudes.
Also, perhaps people said stuff as you did just before people started actually killing each other in Yugoslavia or Rwanda.
M: If you read that over pretending you didn't know what you meant, you may see, or at least I think I see that what it means is not stated in a way that is tremendously clear. I think you are saying that to see bigotry as a psychological issue is to divorce it from real world context, the effects that bigotry has on society and how it should react to, say that bigotry as a threat.
If so, my position is that the way to counter the threat of bigotry before it manifests as violent action and destroys the society in which it exists, is via understanding what bigotry is before that happens. I think what you are saying is that you fear bigotry to the extent that you are leaning toward the notion that the ends of preventing a mass psychosis of bigotry entitles you to some manner of force in it's address.
In the case of Yugoslavia, for example, I remember very well and perhaps to my shame, What I would have told the Serbs before they went to wars against the Bosnians had I been the supreme leader. I would have told them, OK go right ahead and invade. We will write off 250. thousand lives right off the books, but if you cross the border, those 250 thousand I will make sure are yours. We will bomb you until that many of your own are dead. And if, after you lose that many people and want to still cross that border, we will recalculate how many you still have the potential to kill and also take that many again. The reaction to a real act of genocide must be extermination of the threat. I remember because the estimate of the number exterminated by the Serbs was approximately 250 thousand. Naturally the last thing in this world I would do is seek such power.
The point is that when people's bigotry turns into actions against the rights of other people the use of force to stop them is justified, in my opinion, but only up to the limit of expunging the threat. This is simply a moral fact that can only be properly executed when there is no hate. No hate is required to do what is right. This, in my opinion, is just the sad face of compassion. The innocent must be protected from the insanity acted out side of hate.
pmy: I don't think the poll respondents were being literal, but (in making what they probably know full well is an irrational response to the question) they were expressing a degree of anger and hostility towards those Trump sees as enemies that doesn't bode well.
M: Exactly but what?????? All that you fear will happen happens when the fear it will happen causes it to. What is the point of what I am saying?:
We hate ourselves because we were put down as children. We were made to conform to ideas that are bigotry, made to feel that only those bigots who think the same are the good people and that everybody else deserves the same torture we experienced twisting us into bigots. I am saying that everything we fear is a lie we believe, that what we were made to hate is evil, because what we were made to hate is ourselves. Imagine if people knew they hated themselves, knew it was a lie and said well fuck that, the monster I saw in the other was simply what I felt about myself and it was a lie all this time. Let me step off this wheel of Karma and not add to the hate. There is only love. There is no other answer than not to feed the hate.