Hmmm... let's see here
Defiantly not pwned by his own dog. I personally define ownage as being smacked down hard by ones peers here for doing utterly stupid sh!t. This was just bad luck and he doesn't come off as a complete tool at all during the thread, unlike the rest here.
Not the Lord Raiden Thread. He's just incredibly dumb, no hard core ownage going on. Certainly lots of shooting himself in the foot, though. Only minor flame feeding.
The ethicalangel thread is primarily flame bait. Nicely fed flame bait, too, but only at the beginning. Love the lawyer background, you really couldn't tell from anything else. Having the past dug up sucks. The english ees also net so good either. For me, making fun of ppl who can't communicate on the net is like making fun of retarded people IRL. All in all, too short.
CT2TXtech got pwned is a nice one

Lying about RL in VR and getting caught (especially making contradictory
threads so close together) always sucks large. Especially on the scale that happened here. The net never forgets

Well, all that and his english = teh suxor. Man never learned not to feed the flames either. Kind of admitted to being a lying dirt bag, but no retractions or apologies.
The Aimster thread has a high ownage value. Much feeding of the flames, I like that, though only at the beginning and towards the end in a "salvage" situation. The fact that the story changes with each post and includes utterly massive contradictions just make him look all the more a tool. The things from the past are great, especially the pizza stories. Alas, he doesn't try and defend the situation enough just deny it was him, thus not feeding the ownage as much as others.
So far Finding Nemo, WHSLacrossekid Thread is defiantly a good contender!! Nothing like owning yourself multiple times over while pissing off a good portion of the ATOT pop by coming off as a money grubbing little weenie. Enough flame feeding to remind me of Pompeii. Plus, unlike CT2TX, WHS never had the grapes to admit he was a lying sack of sh!t.
What takes the cake, though, is defiantly the brick thread. That one looked like a stable floor after a heard of cows was fed diuretics. The fact that he constantly tried to save face made it all the better. Yeah, this one gets the award for me thus far.
-- Jack
The audiophile population of ATOT will be here en masse to pimpslap the Stupid out of you. Please hold.
-- moonshinemadness, ATOT