I think he wanted a better player than Dubinsky
True but they're rebuilding. Dubinsky is young and looks like he has the talent to grow quite a bit. He certainly hasn't reached his ceiling. He's not having the best year though so his stock has dipped a little
The rest of the package is nearly equivalent to 4 first round picks.
Christian Thomas, was taken in the 2nd at 40th overall, but is actually a higher end prospect than the other two.
Tim Erixon was taken 23rd overall and is the Rangers best defensive prospect
J.T. Miller was taken 15th overall and is also a great prospect. Their 3rd best forward in that regard
They probably needed to include Chris Kreider who is their only forward prospect rated higher than those other two, but they also get a 1st this year. They will probably be drafting 1st overall or 2nd with their own pick, then they have LA's and then would have had this one. 3 first round picks would be nothing to sneeze at.
I understand the above guys are just "prospects" but Christian Thomas could step right into their lineup next year, the Rangers are just so deep at Winger that he didn't make it out of training camp - but he would have made it on a lot of teams in the NHL.
My point is that they will likely get less than that come July 1st. Mark my words