you gotta know saying Brady is a shitty QB is just like saying "hey, look at me everyone, I'm an idiot!". You don't have to love the guy but he's an all-time top 10 QB.
I knew the patriots would be depleted this year but watching them in the first two games it's pretty shocking just how bad they are (despite winning both games). I could see them only winning 6 or 7 games this year. They are going to start figuring things out, but so will all the other teams (except for maybe the browns/jags

)
That's very true.
People get really emotional about football. Emotion usually destroys or distorts logic, at best.
Of course, even statistics and raw data can only take you so far, you need that X factor to truly go from great on paper to a legendary champion.
I'm a Dallas fan but not real big on Romo. Perhaps I'm too hard on him, but I've seen way too many years where he crumbles under pressure. Last year he won more of my respect though, Dallas would have easily been in the playoffs had his receivers not dropped so many bullets right in the numbers. It was atrocious. Anyway, point being, Romo is great on paper but hasn't translated that to post-season.
P Manning, he's obviously a damned legend, but because he played for one of the worst teams in the world for most of his career, well .. he has not much to show for post-season. Put the 90s cowboys under his helm, and he would have 6 or 7 rings lol. Say he played there from '90-'97, it'd be a hard thing to bet against that package. Troy was spectacular, but P Manning is better. As a cowboy fan I can totally say that honestly.
Now how about the other legit legends :
Montana, Elway (similar to P-Man, the Broncs were usually deficient in their O-line, he overachieved bigtime), Staubach, Marino (another great QB + crap team combo), etc. It's hard to say that Marino and Elway wouldn't have had more (or any?) SBs had their teams been AAA quality.
All round I'd probably still take Montana over just about anyone. X-factor out the wazoo, I don't care if he did have the best receiver in the history of the universe. Stats be damned, I'd start him haha. He was so good it made Steve Young look second-rate by comparison, and Steve Young was a damned fine player.
So anyway, I guess of the choices above P Man is the one. I just wanted to ramble
