Shorting metals long term right now is a VERY bad idea. Yeah, you might get lucky and make a dime intraday. Enjoy it. And don't spend it all in one place.
But to say your thesis for shorting Silver is that "its 'long term' value is $5, short it!!" ...without understanding the underlying reasons for its recent rise from $12 to $18.5 (a 50% increase), is
uniformed ...to put it mildly.
Dyarr.
Silver price when you edited that post: $18.71/ounce.
Silver price now: $17.37/ounce and falling.
How is your uniformed logic doing? Whatever uniformed logic means. Note: bolding in the quote above was yours, so the uniformity of the logic must have been impeccable.
My informed thesis is this:
1) Metals are overvalued due to irrational exuberance. Fear is driving their price, not their true underlying value. Metals were a hedge against this fear, but that fear has been waning for years. The sky didn't fall with the great recession, the Eurozone may fall apart but that will be over decades and seems to be reasonably orderly rather than in one overnight panic.
2) Metals were used a hedge against inflation by those who don't understand he underlying cause of inflation (how many hyperinflation threads did Anandtech have back then, it seemed like a new one came out each week?) A massive great recession is almost never the cause of inflation. Thus the hedge was misplaced. And people have been realizing this folly. Not all at once, but people have been realizing it for the last few years as the hyperinflation talk dies down.
3) Big institutions/countries with large metal stockpiles are getting more and more desperate to actually use that wealth rather than continue to watch it decline. As oil wealth declines, many countries are being caught overspending with nothing to back it up. Venezuela for example. Heck even Canada recently sold all of its gold.
4) Metals tend to go the opposite of interest rates. The US is looking to finally really start raising rates this winter. Thus metals, if following the typical pattern, will go down.
5) Metals will eventually go to their production cost value--which for silver is about $9/ounce. Metals have gone through this boom/bust multiple times before and it is often in a ~30-year cycle. Thus, no, they won't return to their true value overnight. But they will be returning.
Was that
uniformed enough?