General feelings on the Maxtor drive?
Western Digital and Maxtor generally make the top-performing IDE drives. Seagate makes drives that are noticeably quieter. IBM is a bit harder to find these days, and never, ever found on "hot deals," plus a lot of people steer away from them after a very high incidence of failure from the "deathstar" (aka "Deskstar") series.
Here's a review that includes two different Maxtor series. You'll see that Maxtor and the WD are essentially even in the results, while Seagate is pretty far behind.
storagereview Personally, I don't think that any of the modern drives have much noise at all. The last one I really noticed was an 80GB IBM. This Maxtor, which I believe has fluid bearings, is a great buy. In sum, you can't go wrong at this price for a quality drive.
Off-topic: has anybody else noticed that hard drive space is getting close in cost to CD-R storage? A good quality 700MB CD-R is about $0.20, even on sale. That's $0.28/GB. This particular "hot deal" HD is $0.46/GB. When you consider that CD-R's very rarely fill all 700MB, while you can always fill all the space on a HD, the cost is very close to equal.