Originally posted by: Fencer128
There hasn't been a person alive after the mid 50s who didn't know smoking was bad for you. About the only person I'd think had a case was a person who smoked prior to 1950, quit as soon as the AMA declared it unhealthy, and THEN got sick.
You mean
Gulf Lore Syndrome? Seriously, read this entire article.
Many people believed the breast implant BS as well. So much so that a major American company was bankrupted. Yet it all turned out to be a pile of crap.
Here is a
counter article to your smoking reasoning (which is why I saw justification).
That's not a counter argument. That's excuses. You didn't NEED the tobacco companies to tell you smoking was bad. You needed the AMA and every freakin' doctor alive to tell you. And they HAVE been telling us smoking is harmful to one's health since before the mid fifties. Now, if the tobacco companies had squashed the AMA and every other medical journal, you might have an argument. But they did not, and the information that smoking is harmful has been common knowledge for 50+ years.
I mean, come on. Listening to the tobacco companies talk has been like listening to the Iraqi Information Minister, Everyone has KNOWN they are full of sh!t since the AMA came out with their initial reports. To now claim you needed the tobacco companies to tell you smoking is bad, when every freakin' doctor in the world has been doing so for 50+ years is just plain stupid.
Tobacco companies are not medical doctors. I don't expect them to tell me smoking is harmful to my health any more than I expect a speaker company to tell me loud music can cause hearing loss.
Here is the
article detailing the UK vets gulf war syndrome recent win. Having seen some of these people for myself (and there are 1000's of them) I find it hard to believe they are faking it! Something happened between them getting ready to go to the gulf and coming back that has left a lot of them with very dibilating conditions - not after a while, but shortly after returning from service.. I can't deny what is in front of my eyes.
I admit that it may be something not at all to do with the MOD - but how likely is that? I also admit that a number of "sufferers" may be lying and playing the system. This will run and run and is by no means conclusive...
Cheers for the info,
Andy
No one has claimed many gulf war veterans are not genuinely sick. So the "they can't be faking it" argument wont wash. The point is, just as with the breast implant hoax, is their illness related to the gulf war, medications given by the military, or other, more random causes? No matter what population you choose from, a % of them are going to be sick. I could point to millions of people who have cancer and have also eaten broccoli. Are we to draw the conclusion that broccoli made them sick?
Just as with breast implants, every illness -- imagined or real -- discovered by a Gulf War veteran has now been labeled "Gulf War Syndrome." If you look at Gulf War Syndrome, there is NO set illness. It is any and all illnesses combined. They have no repeatable, peer reviewed cause for Gulf War Syndrome either.
It's a hysterical bandwagon just like the breast implant crap. And it's taking away resources from veterans with real service connected disabilities.