...
The fact that Americans overwhelmingly told Congress to vote against bombing Syria for its use of poison gas tells how much the divide on this issue in America was not left versus right, but top versus bottom. Intervening in Syria was driven by elites and debated by elites. It was not a base issue. I think many Americans could not understand why it was O.K. for us to let 100,000 Syrians die in a civil war/uprising, but we had to stop everything and bomb the country because 1,400 people were killed with poison gas.
I and others made a case why, indeed, we needed to redraw that red line, but many Americans seemed to think that all we were doing is drawing a red line in a pool of blood. Who would even notice?
Many Americans also understood that when it came to our record in the Arab/Muslim world since 9/11, we were 0 for 3. Afghanistan seems headed for failure; whatever happens in Iraq, it was overpaid for; and Libya saw a tyrant replaced by tribal wars. I also think a lot of people look at the rebels in Syria and hear too few people who sound like Nelson Mandela that is, people fighting for the right to be equal citizens, not just for the triumph of their sect or Shariah. Its why John McCains soaring interventionist rhetoric was greeted with a No Sale.
I also think the public picked up on Obamas ambivalence his Churchillian, this-must-not-stand rhetoric, clashed with his On second thought, Im going to ask Congresss permission before I make a stand, and I wont call lawmakers back from vacation to do so. The bombing was going to be bigger than a pinprick but also unbelievably small. It just did not add up.
Finally, there was an Are you kidding? question lurking beneath it all a sense that with middle-class incomes stagnating, income gaps widening and unemployment still pervasive for both white- and blue-collar workers, a lot of Americans were asking: This is the emergency you are putting before Congress? Syria? Really? This is the red line you want to draw? Im out of work, but this Syria thing is what shall not stand?