• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Notebook ECS 90% thinking to buy

gsingh

Member
I have decided to buy ECS notebook.
It will have
P4 2.4GHZ
combo drive DVD/CD-RW
512 MB DDR
40GB
Win XP PRO

EDIT1: 15.1" 1400 X1050
weight 7lbs

EDIT2: http://www.desknote.biz/sub/i-buddie4.htm

for $1518.53 from Valex Computers.

It will allow me two use external monitor also - to increase viewing area.

But I wanted wireless technology WIFI, after finding that it is good upto 600 feet from hot spots, so it helped me not to worry about it. ECS does not integrate it. I can eventually buy USB card for it.

Please comment on my choice.
 
External or PCMCIA wireless is annoying. I know, I used one for many months. I won't buy another laptop with no integrated wireless.

LCD size?

Weight? I will likely never buy another laptop over 6 lbs. My 8 lb one hurt my shoulders. (15")
 
Honestly I think your nuts. ECS may be a big manufacturer, but quality is something they know nothing about.
 
It would be much easier to crituque your selection if you were to tell us the model number of the notebook you are considering.
 
Originally posted by: Yomicron
Originally posted by: gsingh
http://www.desknote.biz/sub/i-buddie4.htm

It would be much easier to crituque your selection if you were to tell us the model number of the notebook you are considering.

ahhh... its an i-Buddy, I trust you realize this is a Desknote, and does not have an internal battery.


review

EDIT, they apparently don't ship with the external battery, you have to purchase it separately.

Right. I own a Desknote A900 (1.1GHz Celleron-based). This is not a "laptop" per se (as in, its not really intended to sit on your lap and using it as a laptop is somewhat cumbersome), rather its a "mobile desktop". Its intended to be taken on a trip, setup on a desk and used as you would use a desktop. Or perhaps to replace a full size desktop in a situation where space is at a premium (i.e., college dorm). It does come with an "external battery" (referred to in the documentation as a UPS) that will run the Desknote for 30-60 minutes before dying, depending on load. So if you're intending to use this as a laptop, then you will probably be disappointed. However, if you really are looking for a "mobile desktop" than you may well be quite pleased. As a mobile desktop, it has many things going in its favor:

  1. It uses many desktop components, such as CPU and RAM (I can't remember if the new ones use desktop HDDs, mine has an IBM TravelStar - speaking of which, are they more reliable than the infamous "Deathstars"? Having it die on me would suck)
  1. The CPU, RAM, and HDD are all completely upgradable. In fact, Anand even managed to overclock the Desknote he reviewed a while back.
  1. It has a nice, large, clear screen. Also, unlike many LCDs, it looks nice in several resolutions.
  1. It has S-Video out and VGA out and dual-monitor support.
  1. It has four USB ports.
  1. It has integrated NIC and modem.

I hope this helps.
 
Originally posted by: Yomicron
Originally posted by: gsingh

ahhh... its an i-Buddy, I trust you realize this is a Desknote, and does not have an internal battery.


review

EDIT, they apparently don't ship with the external battery, you have to purchase it separately.
Yeeechhh! A laptop with a power sucking desktop P4, and with no internal battery. And the external battery lasts half an hour.
rolleye.gif
And it weighs 7 lbs without a battery. 😛

If all you need a portable desktop, that's fine, but this would be almost useless as a laptop. Tell us what you REALLY need and want to do, and maybe someone can help you out.
 
Originally posted by: Eug
Originally posted by: Yomicron
Originally posted by: gsingh

ahhh... its an i-Buddy, I trust you realize this is a Desknote, and does not have an internal battery.


review

EDIT, they apparently don't ship with the external battery, you have to purchase it separately.
Yeeechhh! A laptop with a power sucking desktop P4, and with no internal battery. And the external battery lasts half an hour.
rolleye.gif
And it weighs 7 lbs without a battery. 😛

If all you need a portable desktop, that's fine, but this would be almost useless as a laptop. Tell us what you REALLY need and want to do, and maybe someone can help you out.

Doesn't matter...sounds like he's going to buy this hunk of junk no matter what we're going to tell him. 🙂
 
Tell us what you REALLY need and want to do, and maybe someone can help you out.

Initially, I wanted with integrated WIFI but when I found out it is applicable to hotspots and you have to be near 300 feet of it to get the internet. I am not in school. I am looking for mobile desktop, Desknote fits the bill. I liked toshiba(ps610u-jhn849) because it had integrated WIFI as I stated above I have to near 300 feet of hot spots to get internet.

Also, I will be always near power so battery is irrelevant.

Please keep on prviding critique.
 
tkdkid:
$500 price difference. Other option is VPRmatrix from bestbuy but they do not provide winXPPRO.

So what makes this better than a regular laptop of the same price? I only see disadvantages.
 
spend your money on something else. it shouldn't be hard to find a better deal on a dell or ibm laptop.
 
Originally posted by: gsingh
Tell us what you REALLY need and want to do, and maybe someone can help you out.

Initially, I wanted with integrated WIFI but when I found out it is applicable to hotspots and you have to be near 300 feet of it to get the internet. I am not in school. I am looking for mobile desktop, Desknote fits the bill. I liked toshiba(ps610u-jhn849) because it had integrated WIFI as I stated above I have to near 300 feet of hot spots to get internet.

Also, I will be always near power so battery is irrelevant.
Get a smaller screen. eg. 14" (or even 13.3") instead of 15". The larger the screen the higher the price, and the heavier it will be. This thing is looking like it's gonna be equivalent to a standard laptop's 9 lbs, if you include the external battery.

I'd much rather have a smaller laptop that's easier to carry around. Plus the bit about the battery. Once you have a portable computer you'll understand the importance of an internal long-lasting battery. One cannot always guarantee a nearby power source. (eg. On the plane.) Even when you're sure you'll have a power source nearby, it's often easier to do without it.

You still haven't told us what you're going to be doing with it. Do you really need a 2.4 GHz DESKTOP processor? Certainly you won't be using it for games, because it has no real independent video card. Unless you're going to be doing hard core scientific number crunching, such a processor is overkill when you're on a budget.

By the way, unless you're in a big open field, even 300 feet is too far for WiFi. In you're in a building, an access point should ideally be within 50 feet, with not too many walls in between.

Re: The other desktop replacement:

The CPU, RAM, and HDD are all completely upgradable.
Well, on just about all laptops, the RAM and HDD are upgradable. Only the CPU isn't.
In fact, Anand even managed to overclock the Desknote he reviewed a while back.
I'm not sure anybody buying a laptop would really be worrying about this "feature".
It has a nice, large, clear screen. Also, unlike many LCDs, it looks nice in several resolutions.
It's just an LCD screen, like any other laptop. Maybe it has a better than average one, but 50% of all laptops have better than average screens. 😉
It has S-Video out and VGA out and dual-monitor support.
That is a very common feature, if you're talking about using the LCD screen in conjunction with a second monitor.
It has four USB ports.
That is not common, but 4-port hubs are very light and cost only $20.
It has integrated NIC and modem.
I would never buy a laptop without them. Indeed, most come with that these days. (In fact, my TiBook comes with Gigabit Ethernet (which I won't use).)
 
More and more I am inclined to buy this ECS PC. No vendor comes closer to this. I can always get external battery which I will not buy as I do not need it. Infact, not having internal drive keeps this system cooler. This notebook will last me forever and I am serious as I will eventually upgrade it to 1GB Ram. 2.4GHZ is over kill. I also intend to make tmp dir on RAM, size 100MB, to compensate for slow drives. Dedicate 32 MB for Graphics, 368 MB, plenty for applications.

This will be my mobile desktop from home to work.

Now 99%, 1500 delivered to my home, nobody this configuration.

More critque, plz.
 
Now 99%, 1500 delivered to my home, nobody this configuration.

More critque, plz.

Of course nobody (beats) this configuration, because other companies sell notebooks, ya know those things that can run off internal batteries.

Seems like WiFi would be pretty useless, generally if you are somewhere that has a wireless network, they probably have a wired network as well. When ever you go to use your "notebook" just plug in near a network jack.



If it not having a battery and weighing 8lbs (at least, after you add the AC adapter) isn't a problem with you, then the DeskNote is what is best for you. Just never ever call it a notebook.
 
Back
Top