lozina
Lifer
Originally posted by: yllus
Okay, let's use your basis of the meaning of a straw man argument.
1. I did no such thing, as your position was "who will take the blame". I remarked that it was nice to see that was the angle which you cared to comment upon, instead of how to stop the attack, how many may be injured or killed, how this in any way has to do with Iran or Syria, et cetera. It's remarkable to me that what you felt was most worthy of comment was where the "blame" is going to fall. How does that misrepresent your position at all? It's a direct comment on that which you chose to highlight in your commentary on the article.
You misrepresented my position. I took a position of where blame for such an attack would lead us to, and instead of addressing that position you instead tried to represent me as someone who does not care for probable casualties. Someone else could come along and say that since I did not mention how such terrorist should be punished that I am therefore pro-terrorist. Do you see now why misrepresenting someone's position based on omission is stupid? Of course not, you have no shame.
4. This didn't either, as much as you vainly try to fit it. I made no some assumption about your thoughts on the Katrina matter. I inquired as to whether you acted in a similarly callous way during that disaster to see if a pattern of callousness existed. Assumption vs. inquiry, see any difference there at all? One is used to create a straw man argument, and the other isn't. Unless all questions are now out of bounds.
Nice try at trying to argue semantics. The point is you made me out to seem like one of "those people" who immediately blamed Bush for somehow causing Katrina, trying to discredit me. It does not matter that you presented it as an "inquiry". What you were doing is implying.
quote:
"Were you one of the folks who immediately went after President Bush during Hurricane Katrina as well? That was just as classy a move."
But again, I certainly did not expect you to admit it. You're like the criminal caught red handed who continues to bleat on about his innocence. But, at least you have been exposed for everyone else here.