Newegg ships open box Corsair RAM because Corsair does NOT seal it.

GeezerMan

Platinum Member
Jan 28, 2005
2,146
26
91
OK, so I ordered some expensve Corsair ram for 216.00, but has a 40.00 rebate. It arrives in the factory blister pack, but the edges had been cut off, so it had been opened before I got it. Is this common? I'm not thrilled to get open box items at all, especially expensive ram.
Is there a easy way to tell if I got what I paid for? I set up the Asus A8N-E mobo with the recommended settings from the Corsair forum, and I'll run the memory test they recommend on it tomorrow. Still, kinda peeved I got an open item. I might call them tomorrow.
 

GeezerMan

Platinum Member
Jan 28, 2005
2,146
26
91
It has the common blister pack, that normally has a machine pressed seal around it. You know the kind, you have to cut the edge off to open it. This blister pack had been neatly cut around the edge, but it was definitely cut off. It just opened right up.
 

JEDIYoda

Lifer
Jul 13, 2005
33,986
3,320
126
Originally posted by: insename2
cut open? or was it just not sealed? newegg often ships products unsealed

I would have called newEgg first before posting here....

It does none of us any good to know that you recieved something that was shipped opened...
I have ordered from NewEgg and it never has bothered me that some items appeared to shipped opened and not sealed...

But thats just me! I don`t actively look for issues and when I do find an issue I call the people immediately!!
If your that uncomfortable just call NewEgg and ask for a replacement..

 

Ken90630

Golden Member
Mar 6, 2004
1,571
2
81
Originally posted by: GeezerMan
OK, so I ordered some expensve Corsair ram for 216.00, but has a 40.00 rebate. It arrives in the factory blister pack, but the edges had been cut off, so it had been opened before I got it. Is this common? I'm not thrilled to get open box items at all, especially expensive ram.
Is there a easy way to tell if I got what I paid for? I set up the Asus A8N-E mobo with the recommended settings from the Corsair forum, and I'll run the memory test they recommend on it tomorrow. Still, kinda peeved I got an open item. I might call them tomorrow.

With something as sensitive as RAM, I might send it back & not chance it. I mean, if the blister pack has actually been cut open, that didn't happen by itself. I hate those blister packs -- some are harder to get into than Fort Knox. :roll:

Also, RAM, CPUs, and particularly video cards are often bought by adolescent gamer geeks who overclock them and damage them, then they dishonestly try to return them without telling the vendor (of course) that the device is damaged. And the vendor could of course just put it back on the shelf and then turn around & sell it to one of us. We know this happens because there are posts on this site all the time by weasels saying things like, "I overclocked my *insert component name here* and now I'm having *insert problem name here*. I think I fried it. Do you think if I return it anyone will know? Do they check 'em?"

You obviously could have gotten an "open" item that's perfectly fine -- maybe someone opened it and then just changed their mind for whatever reason -- or it could in fact be damaged. I wouldn't risk it with RAM, but it's up to you how much hassle you wanna go thru for peace of mind. :p

Bummer, man. Good luck. :)



 

Ken90630

Golden Member
Mar 6, 2004
1,571
2
81
Originally posted by: JEDIYoda
Originally posted by: insename2
cut open? or was it just not sealed? newegg often ships products unsealed

I would have called newEgg first before posting here....

It does none of us any good to know that you recieved something that was shipped opened...
I have ordered from NewEgg and it never has bothered me that some items appeared to shipped opened and not sealed...

But thats just me! I don`t actively look for issues and when I do find an issue I call the people immediately!!
If your that uncomfortable just call NewEgg and ask for a replacement..

Actually, I think it does do us good to know that he received something that was shipped opened. When a vendor does that, I wanna know. How else would we know if a vendor is slipping up (or worse) if people just keep quiet? And if it's a misunderstanding, I wanna know that too so we know to not hold it against the vendor.

And I don't think he's "actively looking for issues" -- his post sounds like a legitimate question. He didn't go looking for the problem -- it found him.

Heh heh ... coincidentally, I just ordered something from Newegg today. Let's hope I have better luck. :D
 

arsbanned

Banned
Dec 12, 2003
4,853
0
0
Originally posted by: JEDIYoda
Originally posted by: insename2
cut open? or was it just not sealed? newegg often ships products unsealed

I would have called newEgg first before posting here....

It does none of us any good to know that you recieved something that was shipped opened...
I have ordered from NewEgg and it never has bothered me that some items appeared to shipped opened and not sealed...

But thats just me! I don`t actively look for issues and when I do find an issue I call the people immediately!!
If your that uncomfortable just call NewEgg and ask for a replacement..


I disagree. I think it's fine for him to post this.
But that's just me! ;)
He's not "actively looking for issues" He received expensive RAM in an open package.

GeezerMan:

Don't let 'em charge a restocking fee on it either.
 

GeezerMan

Platinum Member
Jan 28, 2005
2,146
26
91
Thanks everyone. I have an aversion to opened items due to several experiences of buying open box items over the years. I spent about 1000.00 total with Newegg, and this was the only questionable item. Everything else went smooth with them, speedy shipping, nice packing job.
 

JEDIYoda

Lifer
Jul 13, 2005
33,986
3,320
126
Originally posted by: Ken90630
Originally posted by: JEDIYoda
Originally posted by: insename2
cut open? or was it just not sealed? newegg often ships products unsealed

I would have called newEgg first before posting here....

It does none of us any good to know that you recieved something that was shipped opened...
I have ordered from NewEgg and it never has bothered me that some items appeared to shipped opened and not sealed...

But thats just me! I don`t actively look for issues and when I do find an issue I call the people immediately!!
If your that uncomfortable just call NewEgg and ask for a replacement..

Actually, I think it does do us good to know that he received something that was shipped opened. When a vendor does that, I wanna know. How else would we know if a vendor is slipping up (or worse) if people just keep quiet? And if it's a misunderstanding, I wanna know that too so we know to not hold it against the vendor.
And I don't think he's "actively looking for issues" -- his post sounds like a legitimate question. He didn't go looking for the problem -- it found him.

Heh heh ... coincidentally, I just ordered something from Newegg today. Let's hope I have better luck. :D

What I highlighted up above doesn`t make any sense......
Think about it for a minute....

Had he contacted NewEgg right away got it taken care of and then posted that would have been fine and dandy....

But dood this is NewEgg sure they make mistakes but....they almost always are very quick to correct those mistakes...

Why do you need to know about a misunderstanding that will be or has already been corrected...hmmm......
 

DaveSimmons

Elite Member
Aug 12, 2001
40,730
670
126
Old-timers like me know that once in a while Newegg ships an RMA as new, though it's very rare.

They ship thousands of orders a day so it's not surprising that they only get it right 99.9% of the time.

It's not really news that they make mistakes. What would be news (given their excellent customer service) is if they didn't make things right after you contacted them calmly and politely.
 

thegorx

Senior member
Dec 10, 2003
451
0
0
Do you still have the UPC in the pack ?
What are the chips on the modules ?

seems kinda odd to me
 

GeezerMan

Platinum Member
Jan 28, 2005
2,146
26
91
I think the use of a post like this is to keep track of how a retailer is doing. The web has forced companies to be on their toes, and that's a good thing. They have exposure like never before. If a pattern develops, and I'm NOT saying there is one, then I think people would want to know. If you read in here 20 posts from 20 different people that a "Retailer XYZ" is shipping open merchandise on a consistent basis, and even if they take care of your complaint, then something is up with them. If you read in here that a company made a mistake one out of hundred times, that's a pretty damn good job on their part. I'm a fair man, at least I try to be, so I'll post their reply when I call tomorrow.
 

Ken90630

Golden Member
Mar 6, 2004
1,571
2
81
Originally posted by: JEDIYoda
Originally posted by: Ken90630
Originally posted by: JEDIYoda
Originally posted by: insename2
cut open? or was it just not sealed? newegg often ships products unsealed

I would have called newEgg first before posting here....

It does none of us any good to know that you recieved something that was shipped opened...
I have ordered from NewEgg and it never has bothered me that some items appeared to shipped opened and not sealed...

But thats just me! I don`t actively look for issues and when I do find an issue I call the people immediately!!
If your that uncomfortable just call NewEgg and ask for a replacement..

Actually, I think it does do us good to know that he received something that was shipped opened. When a vendor does that, I wanna know. How else would we know if a vendor is slipping up (or worse) if people just keep quiet? And if it's a misunderstanding, I wanna know that too so we know to not hold it against the vendor.
And I don't think he's "actively looking for issues" -- his post sounds like a legitimate question. He didn't go looking for the problem -- it found him.

Heh heh ... coincidentally, I just ordered something from Newegg today. Let's hope I have better luck. :D

What I highlighted up above doesn`t make any sense......
Think about it for a minute....

Had he contacted NewEgg right away got it taken care of and then posted that would have been fine and dandy....

But dood this is NewEgg sure they make mistakes but....they almost always are very quick to correct those mistakes...

Why do you need to know about a misunderstanding that will be or has already been corrected...hmmm......

Heh heh ... well, I think it makes perfect sense. Think about it for a minute ;) :

When someone posts about an experience like his, it does us all good because we find out about it. If we start seeing a number of similar complaints, from apparently legitimate sources, that might tell us a particular vendor is either careless, dishonest, or just someone we might be better off avoiding. I see posts like his and I just make a mental note of it. In and of itself, it wouldn't keep me from doing business with Newegg. But if I see a bunch of similar posts over the next several months or something, then yeah, I'd prolly say to myself, "Hmmm ... looks like Newegg might be slipping and I don't even wanna chance dealing with them. A lot of people have been complaining about them recently, and the complaints appear to be credible. There are other vendors with better reputations, so I'll give them my business instead." No offense, but what part of that doesn't make sense to you?

And whether or not Newegg makes mistakes and is "almost always very quick to correct those mistakes" is irrelevant. The legitimate question here (even if it's just implied) is whether or not it was actually a "mistake" or whether they did it on purpose, hoping the buyer wouldn't notice -- or care -- that the RAM had been opened. Surely you'd agree that someone at Newegg should have noticed that a blister pack had actually been cut open before selling the item as "new." "New" means new -- factory fresh and unopened. Period. So either they didn't notice, which would be carelessness, or they did notice but decided to just sell it again to some other poor sap rather than 'eat' the cost of tossing it out. I personally don't want some part that some overclocker dweeb has damaged and then returned, and I don't think you would either, would you?

As for, "Why do you need to know about a misunderstanding that will be or has already been corrected...hmmm......," think about it again :D : If it turns out that, say, the blister pack hadn't actually been cut but had just 'come open' during packing or shipping, then I wanna know so I don't hold that against Newegg. In such a case, I'd like the OP to let us know it wasn't Newegg's fault. I'm talking after the fact here -- obviously there wouldn't be any point in doing a post to say, "Hi, everyone, I got this opened part from Newegg today and I thought something was wrong, but it turned out there wasn't. It was my mistake. Just wanted to let you all know. See 'ya later." That would obviously be pointless. :laugh:

I don't hate Newegg or anything -- heck, I just ordered from them today :) -- but sometimes I think this silly deification of them by this site's members gets to be a bit much. We all know they gouge with their shipping policy -- big time -- and I can almost always find a better price somewhere else on any item I'd order from them. On the other hand, they have a good selection, a good reputation for customer service, they ship quick, and we all love the pictures of the items they have on their site, don't we?! :)

In a nutshell, I value hearing about suspect experiences with any vendor, be it Newegg or whoever. Millions of other people value this feedback as well, or there wouldn't be the "customer review" sections on Newegg and other sites. And sites like ResellerRatings.com and others wouldn't exist either. If companies screw up (intentionally or otherwise), they deserve criticism or scrutiny. If they do good, they deserve praise. Right? :)
 

Ken90630

Golden Member
Mar 6, 2004
1,571
2
81
Originally posted by: alimoalem
Originally posted by: Ken90630
I hate those blister packs -- some are harder to get into than Fort Knox. :roll:

how would you know if it's harder :p jk jk

Ask me no questions, I'll tell 'ya no lies. :laugh:

No, really ... I've never been to Fort Knox. *twitches* No, really. Don't even know where it is. *twitches again* Lots of gold, you say? Really ....

:evil:
 

Ken90630

Golden Member
Mar 6, 2004
1,571
2
81
Originally posted by: GeezerMan
I think the use of a post like this is to keep track of how a retailer is doing. The web has forced companies to be on their toes, and that's a good thing. They have exposure like never before. If a pattern develops, and I'm NOT saying there is one, then I think people would want to know. If you read in here 20 posts from 20 different people that a "Retailer XYZ" is shipping open merchandise on a consistent basis, and even if they take care of your complaint, then something is up with them. If you read in here that a company made a mistake one out of hundred times, that's a pretty damn good job on their part. I'm a fair man, at least I try to be, so I'll post their reply when I call tomorrow.

EXACTAMUNDO! :cool:
 

Duckzilla

Senior member
Nov 16, 2004
430
0
0
I don't know about the RAM you ordered, but Corsair's ValueSelect had no seal on it whatsoever. I bought some of their 512*2 packs on two different occassions.

All 4 sticks are fine. Lets await test results before we get bent out of shape.
 

Kogan

Golden Member
Mar 21, 2000
1,331
0
0
Newegg pulled the same thing on me twice with patriot ram about 6 months ago. At the time, newegg wanted to charge me some sort of restocking fee when I tried to confront them about their ram being used. Decided never to buy ram from them again, and went through patriot's RMA service to finally get a matched pair of working ram.
 

GeezerMan

Platinum Member
Jan 28, 2005
2,146
26
91
I got the twinx2048-3200c2 which are supposed to be a matched pair of 1GB each stick. I can run the memtest86 on it, but how does one see if they are truly matched?
 

kevinf2090

Senior member
Jul 23, 2005
684
0
76
ya i know, i don't think corsair seals their package, you just unsnap the edges and you take the ram out
 

Ken90630

Golden Member
Mar 6, 2004
1,571
2
81
Originally posted by: Duckzilla
I don't know about the RAM you ordered, but Corsair's ValueSelect had no seal on it whatsoever. I bought some of their 512*2 packs on two different occassions.

All 4 sticks are fine. Lets await test results before we get bent out of shape.

My Corsair ValueSelect 512 did have a seal on it -- a printed label stuck across the back of the package the module came in. And it was intact (think I ordered it from Monarch). But that was in 2003, and it didn't come in a blister pack (thankfully). Maybe they've changed their packaging since then, or maybe it's different on different modules.

I personally wouldn't even chance using opened RAM, CPUs, or video cards. Just too much likelihood some idiot damaged it and then returned it. But to each his own. :p
 

GeezerMan

Platinum Member
Jan 28, 2005
2,146
26
91
OK, this is interesting. My neighbor loaned me his Battlefield 2 game, said that should check the ram. It crashed, and rebooted the PC after 20 minutes.

I ran Prime95, it came up with an error message of :
FATAL ERROR: Rounding was 0.490234375, expected less than 0.4
Hardware failure detected, consult stress.txt file.

Of course, this still may not be a ram problem.

I'll run the memtest86 in a few minutes.